Pagliai's Pizza

$$ • Pizza, Coffee, Tea, Pasta Shops

1600 Lincoln Ave, Charleston
(217) 345-3400


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Pagliai's Pizza

A Favorite in Charleston and still delicious as ever! When they're busy the register worker is overwhelmed and an unfortunate bottleneck forms that harms an otherwise good experience. I'm recommending a 2nd register for dine-in so take-out can keep flowing and diners can get out gracefully.Food: 5/5

Pros - Friendly amd talented staff, some of the best pizza in Charleston, ILNeeds Improvememt - Dining it, felt really cramped. A lil bit on the oilier side with pizza so take your tums if you have a weak stomach like me. Oil doesnt affect pizza's taste.Overall: 4/5, but still my #1 pizza place in this college city. Would come here every time if I had to choose.

I came in for a bite earlier today with my daughter and close friend after touring the EIU campus. Visiting from Chicago, of couse there's obviously no shortage of pizza places to choose from, but I can say Pagliai's can run with the best of them. The thin crust pizza was top-notch, and the cheese sticks were really delicious. Our server was excellent and very attentive, and the iced tea was also perfectly sweetened. We'll definitely be back anytime we're in Charleston.

More Reviews(149)


Monday 4 - 9PM
Tuesday 4 - 9PM
Wednesday 4 - 9PM
Thursday 4 - 9PM
Friday 4 - 10PM
Saturday 4 - 10PM
Sunday 4 - 9PM