Brothers Creamery Frozen Custard

Mediocre experience. If you have an ice cream craving, I’d go elsewhere (i’m aware this is custard not ice cream). Custard isn’t the best but if you have a specific liking for it then sure. I ordered the oreo malt at first which was very soupy so I exchanged for an oreo fudge concrete which was better. The employees were nice with my issue which was appreciated.

best ice cream in chicago 🍦🤍

Such a great local spot in Lakeview for ice cream! One thing I feel that do exceptionally well is mix the mix-ins all the way through!

The Biscoff cookie is my go-to favorite, but I do like trying their seasonal offerings. I appreciate the pup cups when I have my dog along. My only disappointment is that they’re not open on Mondays, when I’m often craving their custard!

Nutella shake to die for (Oreo fudge for my partner) We keep coming back.

Very good vibe and food

Amazing custard!! Anyone saying Shake Shack is better doesn’t know good ole Midwestern custard. The Nutella Oreo mix in worked so well and the workers are so kind!

The founders behind Brothers Creamery are a compassionate, enthusiastic duo who together create a space & sense of community that Lakeview East is fortunate to have. They’ve got a nice selection of wonderful flavors and typically offer new, creative flavor profiles seasonally and year round. Check out their spacious and cozy Crepe Shop two doors down, too! Cheers to the Toader Brothers.

What an amazing ice cream shop, or more specifically frozen custard shop. I got the biscoff concrete and it was delicious blend of biscoff cookies and frozen custard.

The menu had an interesting list of options. Going to try next the cinnamon rice pudding flavor concrete that is described as tasting like horchata. Or maybe the Belgian Butter Pecan.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Biscoff Concrete

Mom and I were visiting Chicago from Canada and we went here for all 5 nights for dessert. One of the best custards I've ever had, we both loved it. Awesome flavors, great location, and amazing staff and customer service. It was packed everyone we went.

Highly recommended.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Nutella, Biscoff Concrete, Oreo

This has become a regular spot for us, I take all my out of town guests here. When in the Midwest….eat delicious custard. Brother’s creamery is a quality and quantity spot, I can’t finish a small and always get some help.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is not frozen custard. The recipe is totally wrong. Sorry to be harsh but it tastes of stabilizer and gum rather than frozen real custard! I am sure no eggs are used .

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Frozen custard was tasty but... Not so frozen sadly so it melted super fast. Got the pecan concrete and my friend got the sundae which was nice and frozen still. Flavors seems awesome tho

Must have! Lakeview’s best! Our kids love it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wildberry Cheesecake, Biscoff Concrete

Throw away the lid you won’t need it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5