First Slice Pie Cafe

5357 N Ashland Ave, Chicago
(773) 275-4297

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Michigan Sour Cherry Pie
Traditional Apple Pie
Blueberry Cheesecake
Polka Dot Cheesecake
Strawberry Rhubarb
Coffee Toffee Pie
Chocolate Cream
French Silk Pie
Raspberry Pear

Menu

Fruit Pies
Traditional Apple Pie
Granny smith apples, brown sugar, juice, butter, flour, shortening, cornstarch, vanilla, sugar, salt, cinnamon, spices.
Michigan Sour Cherry Pie
Michigan sour cherries, flour, butter, shortening, cornstarch, cinnamon, cane sugar, vanilla, salt.
Balsamic Raspberry Pear Pie
Raspberry, balsamic vinegar, pear, sugar, cinnamon, butter, flour, egg, salt.

Cream Pies
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Peanut butter, cream cheese, sugar, vanilla, whipped cream, chocolate, peanuts, oreo.
French Silk Pie
Unsweetened chocolate chips, eggs, sugar, heavy cream, butter, vanilla, flour, shortening.
Polka Dot Pie
Chocolate, almond paste, eggs, kahlua, espresso, vanilla, almond extract, sugar, cream cheese. Gluten free.
Chocolate Cream Pie
Oreo crust, chocolate chips, cream, egg yolks, vanilla, corn starch, salt.
Coffee Toffee Pie
Coffee, unsweetened chocolate, eggs, confectioners sugar, heavy cream, butter, oreo crumbs, espresso.
Key Lime Pie
Condensed milk, sugar, lemon juice, lime juice, heavy cream, egg yolks, lime zest, graham cracker, butter.

Cheesecake
Blueberry Cheesecake
Blueberry, graham cracker, butter, sugar, heavy cream, powdered sugar, cream cheese, vanilla, brown sugar, cornstarch, lemon juice, cinnamon, spices.

Sandwiches
Chicago-Style Vegetarian Sandwich
Spinach, mushrooms, grilled red onions, smoked Gouda, cheddar, catsup, mustard, pickle relish.
Goat Cheese and Roasted Vegetable Sandwich
Spinach, mushroom, roasted cauliflower, poached pear, grilled red onion, Goat cheese, sun-dried tomato. Vegetarian.
Smoked Ham and Cheddar Sandwich
Smoked ham, grilled red onion, smoked Gouda, cheddar, sun-dried tomato, mustard.
Smoked Turkey and White Cheddar Sandwich
Smoked turkey, grilled red onion, romaine, white cheddar, cranberry cherry chutney.
Chicken Curry Sandwich
Chicken curry salad, romaine.
Chicken and Bleu Cheese Sandwich
Amish chicken breast, grilled red onions, spinach, bleu cheese, sun-dried tomato.
Duck Confit and Mozzarella Sandwich
Duck confit, spinach, mushroom, grilled red onion, mozzarella, sun-dried tomato.
Chicken and Guacamole Sandwich
Chicken breast, red onion, romaine, pinto beans, chihuahua, guacamole.
Beef Barbacoa Sandwich
Shredded barbacoa, tomato, avocado, romaine.
Cuban Sandwich
Ham, braised pork, Swiss cheese, pickles, mayo, mustard

Salads
Harvest Salad
Baby mixed greens, poached pear, grilled red onion, garbanzo beans, radish, candied pecans, spiced pepitas, bleu cheese, and cranberry vinaigrette. Vegetarian. Vegan. Gluten free.
Cobb Salad
Romaine, chicken breast, bleu cheese, bacon, candied pecans, apple, radish, scallions, cranberry vinaigrette. Vegetarian. Vegan. Gluten free.
Latin Hip Hop Salad
Romaine, roasted cauliflower, tomato, scallions, grilled red onion, radish, queso fresco, spiced pepitas, tortilla strips, and mojito vinaigrette. Vegetarian. Vegan. Gluten free.
Apple and Baby Lettuce Side Salad
Green apple, baby lettuce, tomato, radish salad with vinaigrette dressing. Vegetarian. Vegan.

70's Style Salads
70's Style Salad Single Serving
8 oz. of the salad of your choice, on bed of romaine lettuce and a piece of garlic toast.
70's Style Salad Combo of 2
10 oz. of the salad of your choice, on bed of romaine lettuce and a piece of garlic toast.
70's Style Salad Combo of 3
12 oz. of the salad of your choice, on bed of romaine lettuce and a piece of garlic toast.
Curry Chicken 70's Style Salad
Poached chicken breast, green apple, dried cherry, scallions, shredded carrot, yellow curry, yogurt sauce. Gluten free.
Cucumber Chicken 70's Style Salad
Diced chicken, cucumber, red onion, carrot, scallions, yogurt dressing. Gluten free.
Pesto Tortellini 70's Salad
Tri-color cheese tortellini, mayonnaise, fresh basil, basil pesto, cherry tomato. Vegetarian.
Greek Grain 70's Salad
cucumber, bulgar wheat, tomato, red onion, garbanzo beans, kalamata olives, feta cheese, parsley

Soups
Spicy Grain Soup
Vegetable stock, carrot, onion, guajillo, celery, tortilla, tomato, lentil, brown rice, herbs, and spice. Vegetarian, vegan. Gluten free.
Roasted Tomato Soup
Tomato, onion, carrot, celery, olive oil, garlic, herbs: served with grilled cheese garnish. Vegetarian, vegan. Gluten free.
Turkey Chili
Turkey, medley of beans, tomato, onion, chili, butternut squash, peppers, and spices. Gluten free.
Cuban Black Bean Soup
Black beans, peppers, onion, celery, garlic, spices. Vegetarian, vegan. Gluten free.

Quiches
Broccoli and Cheddar Quiche
Broccoli, cheddar, with a side salad. Vegetarian.
Bacon and Sweet Onion Quiche
Bacon, onion, mozzarella, with a side salad.
Mediterranean Quiche
Spinach, Goat cheese, sun-dried, tomato, mushroom, with a side salad. Vegetarian.
Whole Broccoli and Cheddar Quiche
Broccoli, cheddar. Vegetarian.
Whole Bacon and Sweet Onion Quiche
Bacon, onion, mozzarella.
Whole Mediteranean Quiche
Spinach, Goat cheese, sun-dried, tomato, mushroom. Vegetarian. Hi

Community Plates
Green Lasagna
Butternut squash, spinach, mushroom, with a side salad. Vegetarian.
Traditional Meat Lasagna
Beef and pork sausage, with a side salad.
Coffee Braised Pork Burrito
Coffee braised pork, roasted apple, black beans, with a side salad.

Cafe Specials
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Chicken breast, romaine, red onion, tomato, bleu cheese, ranch, Buffalo sauce, flour tortilla, served with chips.
Turkey Cobb Wrap
turkey, bacon, avocado, bleu cheese, spinach, flour tortillas, with chips

For the Kids
Kids Grilled Cheese
Served with chips and fruit. Vegetarian.
Kids Macaroni and Cheese
Served with fruit. Vegetarian.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: foursquare
+69 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+68 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Cutest spot for an afternoon slice of pie and a cup of coffee. Nice that they have an espresso machine and a nice variety of delicious pies. They have a pretty extensive lunch menu as well but didn’t get to try- will definitely be back. Limited seating in the back especially on weekends but a great atmosphere. Lots of pies and other items that you can take to go as well.
February 2026
I love this place. The sandwiches are outstanding and are served with chips and a side salad that’s always crisp and fresh. There are delicious frozen meals you can purchase to bring home - you should definitely take home a chicken pot pie if you want something savory. Then there’s the pie which is so scrumptious. I’m partial to key lime but they also have an excellent strawberry cheesecake and tons of other options. My friend tried the brownie and a piece of apple pie and...
February 2026
I stopped by for the first time yesterday and grabbed a strawberry cheesecake pie for a work potluck, I was in and out in two minutes, the person behind the counter was so sweet, and every nurse in my department raved about how delicious it was and asked for the name of the shop it came from! Will definitely be back. Thank you
January 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Elixir - 1509 W Balmoral Ave
Cocktail Bar, Lounges, Venues & Event Spaces
Replay Andersonville - 5358 N Clark St
Bar, American, Arcades, Sports Bar, Pet Friendly
sweetgreen - 5400 N Clark St
Health Food, Vegetarian, Salad

First Slice Pie Cafe

5357 N Ashland Ave, Chicago, IL 60640
(773) 275-4297