Doing my research before coming to Chicago I had found this gem on YouTube. Robert described the process for his craft is great detail and with a charm for his city that intrigued me. Coming from South Alabama I wanted to make every restaurant pick meaningful. I awoke promptly at 8am as instructed by his website and secured my 6pm spot. Milly’s was truly worth the hype, would highly recommend. The staff is welcoming and very friendly.
Even though it is clearly stated online and posted in plain English on the door we were amazed to see how many people could not grasp the concept of a limited availability. The staff was very kind and friendly to them regardless of their actions.
If you haven’t already been here it’s a must while in the Chicago proper. Stay blessed Milly’s
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christopher Blaker
After you walk into this charming little pizzeria and pick you order. It's time to chow down and you are left wIth no choice but to love this pizza! Millie's has earned a right to be on Chicago's Mount Rushmore of Pizza. Pick any three other local favorites you like but leave a spot for this perfect pan pizza🍕🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jamie Gomoll
You wouldn’t let me order online at 5pm and when I come into your store in person at 5:15pm I was told you didn’t have any pizza…you have no reliable business plan. You’re going to fail. I’m positive
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
LadyViola
Ordered online for a 4:30 delivery and pizza was delivered promptly at 4:30. I don’t mind the whole online ordering process but because of this, I must say I was expecting this pizza to blow my mind; it did not. It’s a respectable pizza and I appreciate the beautiful presentation but it was your typical Chicago deep dish pie. No better and no worse than the million other options. I would eat here again but I would not be jumping through any hoops to do so.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ashley Karadsheh
We were SO excited when Milly’s came to west town since this area desperately needed a pizza joint. I’m reluctant to even write this review since it always sells out and I don’t want more people to know about it- but it’s probably the best pizza I’ve had in Chicago. For the LOVE OF GOD MAKE MORE PIZZAS! Hear me out: more pizzas, more profit, happier neighbors. What do you say?
Food: 5
Chris
It’s a good pizza and service was good. Good to try once but for the hassle around trying to place an order days ahead of time before it sells out, probably won’t bother again.
Alexandria Srbino Arenella
I have not had a good experience with Milly’s. My family and I have tried to go a few times and every time we go they are sold out of the pizza.
This has been going on for the last five weeks !!!!
I went on the website this afternoon at about 3 PM and it indicated that there’s no delivery or pick up available because they are sold out until next Wednesday . what type of business runs out of pizzas in the afternoon and it indicates that if you order at 8 AM you should be able to pick up a pizza that day? Just curious who orders pizza at 8 AM?
Andrew Dorazio
Best pizza in chicago hands down
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Juan Carlos
The best deep dish pizza you’ll ever find in Chicago, trust me.
Important: they make a limited number of pizzas each day, so you must order online at least one day in advance.
Now, about the pizza: amazing, amazing, amazing, we got the Only Pans, and let me tell you, you can instantly feel the quality of the ingredients the moment you open the box. The smell is incredible, the flavor is rich, and the consistency of the cheese is superb. Best ricotta I’ve ever had.
The combination of chili honey and pesto is superb, the pepperoni adds a bold kick that blends perfectly with the creamy ricotta. The pizza is thick and hearty, but not hard to chew, just the right texture.
This pizza is pure poetry for your mouth.
Quick note on logistics: it’s takeout only, you order online, pick it up, and that’s it. No dine-in. Judging by all the local customers around, you can tell this is a true Chicagoan gem. 10 out of 10.
Unreal pan pizza. West town is now the undisputed pizza capital of the Midwest
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Burkart (Sourskittles714)
Amazing pizza. Did feel odd to schedule pizza pick up days in advance only for them to be about 20 minutes late in having it ready though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Eduardo Melecio
I made the drive out here today and it was absolutely worth it. The store has a cozy atmosphere, the staff were friendly and welcoming, and the food made the hour trip more than worthwhile. The pizza crust was soft and airy with a perfectly crispy exterior. The pepperoni had a satisfying crunch, while the spinach stayed tasting fresh. The sauce was rich and well balanced. I can't wait to come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pancakes and Protein Shakes
Can’t recommend a place enough. Chicago pizza destination to say the least. Staff was insanely polite and you can tell they were incredible people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffrey Miner
Incredible story and the people behind this magic are the kindest most humble in the game. Pizza is from another world!! get there!!
This place is a joke, never available pizza.
Service: 1
Doing my research before coming to Chicago I had found this gem on YouTube. Robert described the process for his craft is great detail and with a charm for his city that intrigued me. Coming from South Alabama I wanted to make every restaurant pick meaningful. I awoke promptly at 8am as instructed by his website and secured my 6pm spot. Milly’s was truly worth the hype, would highly recommend. The staff is welcoming and very friendly.
Even though it is clearly stated online and posted in plain English on the door we were amazed to see how many people could not grasp the concept of a limited availability. The staff was very kind and friendly to them regardless of their actions.
If you haven’t already been here it’s a must while in the Chicago proper. Stay blessed Milly’s
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
After you walk into this charming little pizzeria and pick you order. It's time to chow down and you are left wIth no choice but to love this pizza! Millie's has earned a right to be on Chicago's Mount Rushmore of Pizza. Pick any three other local favorites you like but leave a spot for this perfect pan pizza🍕🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
You wouldn’t let me order online at 5pm and when I come into your store in person at 5:15pm I was told you didn’t have any pizza…you have no reliable business plan. You’re going to fail. I’m positive
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ordered online for a 4:30 delivery and pizza was delivered promptly at 4:30. I don’t mind the whole online ordering process but because of this, I must say I was expecting this pizza to blow my mind; it did not. It’s a respectable pizza and I appreciate the beautiful presentation but it was your typical Chicago deep dish pie. No better and no worse than the million other options. I would eat here again but I would not be jumping through any hoops to do so.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
We were SO excited when Milly’s came to west town since this area desperately needed a pizza joint. I’m reluctant to even write this review since it always sells out and I don’t want more people to know about it- but it’s probably the best pizza I’ve had in Chicago. For the LOVE OF GOD MAKE MORE PIZZAS! Hear me out: more pizzas, more profit, happier neighbors. What do you say?
Food: 5
It’s a good pizza and service was good. Good to try once but for the hassle around trying to place an order days ahead of time before it sells out, probably won’t bother again.
I have not had a good experience with Milly’s. My family and I have tried to go a few times and every time we go they are sold out of the pizza. This has been going on for the last five weeks !!!! I went on the website this afternoon at about 3 PM and it indicated that there’s no delivery or pick up available because they are sold out until next Wednesday . what type of business runs out of pizzas in the afternoon and it indicates that if you order at 8 AM you should be able to pick up a pizza that day? Just curious who orders pizza at 8 AM?
Best pizza in chicago hands down
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best deep dish pizza you’ll ever find in Chicago, trust me.
Important: they make a limited number of pizzas each day, so you must order online at least one day in advance.
Now, about the pizza: amazing, amazing, amazing, we got the Only Pans, and let me tell you, you can instantly feel the quality of the ingredients the moment you open the box. The smell is incredible, the flavor is rich, and the consistency of the cheese is superb. Best ricotta I’ve ever had.
The combination of chili honey and pesto is superb, the pepperoni adds a bold kick that blends perfectly with the creamy ricotta. The pizza is thick and hearty, but not hard to chew, just the right texture.
This pizza is pure poetry for your mouth.
Quick note on logistics: it’s takeout only, you order online, pick it up, and that’s it. No dine-in.
Judging by all the local customers around, you can tell this is a true Chicagoan gem.
10 out of 10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Unreal pan pizza. West town is now the undisputed pizza capital of the Midwest
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pizza. Did feel odd to schedule pizza pick up days in advance only for them to be about 20 minutes late in having it ready though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
I made the drive out here today and it was absolutely worth it. The store has a cozy atmosphere, the staff were friendly and welcoming, and the food made the hour trip more than worthwhile. The pizza crust was soft and airy with a perfectly crispy exterior. The pepperoni had a satisfying crunch, while the spinach stayed tasting fresh. The sauce was rich and well balanced. I can't wait to come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Can’t recommend a place enough. Chicago pizza destination to say the least. Staff was insanely polite and you can tell they were incredible people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Incredible story and the people behind this magic are the kindest most humble in the game. Pizza is from another world!! get there!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...