Note: I got to try this place from TooGoodToGo, so I had to re-heat the pizza afterwards.
I got two slices here, the cheese (ricotta maybe) and the buffalo chicken pizza.
I liked the chewiness and doughiness of the crust, it’s a thicker pizza but pretty light. The bottom was fried in olive oil, which adds a nice touch to it.
The buffalo chicken pizza was definitely better than the cheese, I would’ve loved to try the pepperoni, which I know people speak highly of.
The brownie was also delicious.
I think if I had just a simple sausage or pepperoni pizza, or if I got to try the corner pizza instead of the middle, I would’ve liked it a bit more. But it’s worth checking out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jarrett Sanchez
Ordered for a large party! Service and pizza were both great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
TKO
The pizza is actually delicious. Fluffy and crispy and flavorful.
The brownie is decent, but some pieces might've had baking paper still on it.
Counter service. 20% tip selected by default.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Burrata
Ginger Douglas
I ordered the slice box for delivery, however my Uber eats driver had tampered with my food and I had to throw it out. I ordered a second box and received this beautiful crispy, cheesy, airy flavorful medley! I called the restaurant to let them know what had happened with the first order and kindly asked them to seal the new order, which they made sure of and gave me free dessert for the hassle! My experience was FRIENDLY and the pizza was worth the hassle. Thank you for great customer service!
I ordered via toast for the sundsay football special. I took out 2 pizza's one being a pepperoni and the other the mushroom miso. As others state this is a think doughy pizza with really no sauce on it. The peperonni seemed to be a little scarce compared to the google pics. overall it was decent/ average (Jet's is better). Lacked flavor compared to similar spots in chicago.
As for the second pizza i thought it was worth mentioning I love mushrooms but they put an overwhelming amount on the mushroom pizza. I'd say about 2" thick piled on top. Since there is no sauce or very little it is over kill, not even sure they put any cheese on this one. You can't even eat the pizza slice without a pile falling off the slice. By the time you finish a single slice the pile of left over mushrooms is just as big as the initial slice. I also think they are marinated in miso broth so thats all you taste. I wanted to try this place based on the reviews but I will not be going back. Professor Pizza blows this place away on all levels. Their grandma style offers a way better pizza than what is offered here with way better flavors. Over all I was disappointed and underwhelmed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Adam Triplett
Just ate the most delicious brownie of my life here, pizza was good also
Zack T
The pizza (focaccia) is great. It’s unique and delicious.
Kira Morgan
I’ve been following PFP on Instagram for a while and have been wanting to go on Monday for their $3/slice so I can try more than one flavor.
I went this past Monday because it was a holiday so less traffic. As I pulled up to the corner, I found parking right in front. I walked in and passed the tables to the counter. The menu is pretty simple, but the pizzas are not.
I got 2 slices of the Burrata, Pepperoni, and Sausage (which also has Giardiniera). They were so delicious! I cannot wait to go back and try more off their menu.
There was plenty of seating and a patio that you walk through the kitchen to get to.
I'm very disappointed in my experience here honestly. I keep seeing all of these great reviews and I was soooo excited to try the miso mushroom and potato pesto pizzas. I ordered 1 slice of 4 different kinds of pizza to try a few and I got two of the exact same thing. Pepperoni and idk maybe plain cheese?? Literally the two that I wanted most i didn't get and I didn't even order a plain cheese one! And then you pay 3 dollars for dips the burratta okay it's expensive $3 I understand but a half full ranch that's very obviously store bought in bulk (not good) being $3 is absolutely crazy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
Brooke Berg
Quick service, but staff was unfriendly. Came in at 7pm to find multiple flavors were unavailable. We did takeout but assuming would be better in house.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Drake Shafer
Loved the Dinner for Two with salad, breadsticks, and pizza. I got the pepperoni and burrata slices. They were both great but wish the pepperoni one had more toppings and the burrata would have some fresh burrata on it.
Will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata
Khalil Mouline
Everybody knows the rules
Food: 5
Dawn Geoffroy
Thank you for having vegan pizza!! What a treat to find you at The Salt Shed! Delicious pizza and an outdoor concert? Yes please!
Mind blown. Call me a regular.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Pesto
Note: I got to try this place from TooGoodToGo, so I had to re-heat the pizza afterwards.
I got two slices here, the cheese (ricotta maybe) and the buffalo chicken pizza.
I liked the chewiness and doughiness of the crust, it’s a thicker pizza but pretty light. The bottom was fried in olive oil, which adds a nice touch to it.
The buffalo chicken pizza was definitely better than the cheese, I would’ve loved to try the pepperoni, which I know people speak highly of.
The brownie was also delicious.
I think if I had just a simple sausage or pepperoni pizza, or if I got to try the corner pizza instead of the middle, I would’ve liked it a bit more. But it’s worth checking out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ordered for a large party! Service and pizza were both great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is actually delicious. Fluffy and crispy and flavorful.
The brownie is decent, but some pieces might've had baking paper still on it.
Counter service. 20% tip selected by default.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Burrata
I ordered the slice box for delivery, however my Uber eats driver had tampered with my food and I had to throw it out.
I ordered a second box and received this beautiful crispy, cheesy, airy flavorful medley!
I called the restaurant to let them know what had happened with the first order and kindly asked them to seal the new order, which they made sure of and gave me free dessert for the hassle!
My experience was FRIENDLY and the pizza was worth the hassle.
Thank you for great customer service!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata, Sausage, Potato Pesto
Really nice place great pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I ordered via toast for the sundsay football special. I took out 2 pizza's one being a pepperoni and the other the mushroom miso. As others state this is a think doughy pizza with really no sauce on it. The peperonni seemed to be a little scarce compared to the google pics. overall it was decent/ average (Jet's is better). Lacked flavor compared to similar spots in chicago.
As for the second pizza i thought it was worth mentioning I love mushrooms but they put an overwhelming amount on the mushroom pizza. I'd say about 2" thick piled on top. Since there is no sauce or very little it is over kill, not even sure they put any cheese on this one. You can't even eat the pizza slice without a pile falling off the slice. By the time you finish a single slice the pile of left over mushrooms is just as big as the initial slice. I also think they are marinated in miso broth so thats all you taste. I wanted to try this place based on the reviews but I will not be going back. Professor Pizza blows this place away on all levels. Their grandma style offers a way better pizza than what is offered here with way better flavors. Over all I was disappointed and underwhelmed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Just ate the most delicious brownie of my life here, pizza was good also
The pizza (focaccia) is great. It’s unique and delicious.
I’ve been following PFP on Instagram for a while and have been wanting to go on Monday for their $3/slice so I can try more than one flavor.
I went this past Monday because it was a holiday so less traffic. As I pulled up to the corner, I found parking right in front. I walked in and passed the tables to the counter. The menu is pretty simple, but the pizzas are not.
I got 2 slices of the Burrata, Pepperoni, and Sausage (which also has Giardiniera). They were so delicious! I cannot wait to go back and try more off their menu.
There was plenty of seating and a patio that you walk through the kitchen to get to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza, Burrata, Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
I'm very disappointed in my experience here honestly. I keep seeing all of these great reviews and I was soooo excited to try the miso mushroom and potato pesto pizzas. I ordered 1 slice of 4 different kinds of pizza to try a few and I got two of the exact same thing. Pepperoni and idk maybe plain cheese?? Literally the two that I wanted most i didn't get and I didn't even order a plain cheese one! And then you pay 3 dollars for dips the burratta okay it's expensive $3 I understand but a half full ranch that's very obviously store bought in bulk (not good) being $3 is absolutely crazy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
Quick service, but staff was unfriendly. Came in at 7pm to find multiple flavors were unavailable. We did takeout but assuming would be better in house.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Loved the Dinner for Two with salad, breadsticks, and pizza. I got the pepperoni and burrata slices. They were both great but wish the pepperoni one had more toppings and the burrata would have some fresh burrata on it.
Will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata
Everybody knows the rules
Food: 5
Thank you for having vegan pizza!! What a treat to find you at The Salt Shed! Delicious pizza and an outdoor concert? Yes please!
Dietary restrictions: Vegan
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Basil Pizza
Loading...