Pizza was fresh and hot out of the oven - amazing! Reminds me of NYC style pizza and loved it! My fave was the Pesto Margherita handsdown!
Jose Paulin
Only been here for Simpsons trivia nights, but pizzas good.
James Zahornacky
Got take out pizza. The crust and toppings were delicious. Not a deep dish pizza but an East Coast thickness pizza. We will go back for more.
Gina Fazzini
We’ve tried pretty much everything on the menu at this point and so far they haven’t missed. We love the spinach artichoke dip, the pesto flatbread, the spinach salad, and their pizza is delicious!
joseph santonato
Super busy but we'll run and great pizza
Caleb
The pizza is always really good, and the staff are nice even when dealing with angry people waiting for their pizza. On weekends the pizza always takes longer than it says if you order online, so just be prepared.
Amit Mallik
Great pizza spot on Belmont. There’s a lot of pizza around, but hard to find a place as reliable as Serio, especially when it comes to something that that’s not deep dish or Chicago-style thin crust. It’s an oven fired pizza, but not quite as thin as Neopolitan style.
The crust is just chewy enough to be addictive without being too bready. Standout ingredient if you pick a pizza or build your own is fresh mozzarella.
It has saved the day when the pizza itch has hit many a time 🙂
Lauren Stygar
The staff was so nice when I walked in asking about the EL when my Lyft ride didn't show. Would like to return. Take care.
Christine Lee Fatt
Feb 2025 Ambience was casual, went on a Wednesday night. Great service. Food did not wow us- got the pesto margherita pizza and the goat cheese dip. The pizza lacked flavor. However their dough so great. Would not come back because there are so many better pizza places in Chicago!
Perfect place to host a private event! They were extremely easy to work with. Event space was perfect for a shower. Food and service was awesome as always. And able to accommodate several dietary restrictions. Thank you for making hosting so easy!
Thomas Sauers
UPDATE
Within a few minutes of this review, they reached out to us to express their apologies for the way the night went. They were short staffed, Valentine’s Day, along with bad weather, made for a difficult night. The pizza that we ordered was not hot and needed to be reheated, it was still excellent. The fact that they immediately called to take care of the issue was amazing.
Unreal, I ordered our pizza at 607 with an estimated delivery time of 722. I called at 737 and they told me it just left to be delivered. They arrived to deliver the pizza at 830 and the driver put the COLD pizza on the step and ran. We attempted to call the location and we were welcomed with a busy signal. I can understand that deliveries will be delayed due to Valentine’s Day and the snow, but I ordered with plenty of time. I didn’t just order a $20 pizza, my total was 118.61 with tip and delivery. Not happy at all, and I would recommend that no one order from this place if they want it delivered within a timely manner and communication. First time and last time customer.
Maria McCaffrey
Staff was fantastic! Set up a great spot for my daughter’s bday dinner with friends. They made it so easy to make this happen and were a delight to work with from start to finish. Thanks, Pizzeria Serio!
Allyson Burns
great pizza, great salads, kid friendly, staff is super nice.
kelly frank
Great pizza place with friendly staff and great food. The Tuesday $12/$18 small/large pizza deal is a great value. I love the Diavola pizza.
Pizza was fresh and hot out of the oven - amazing! Reminds me of NYC style pizza and loved it! My fave was the Pesto Margherita handsdown!
Only been here for Simpsons trivia nights, but pizzas good.
Got take out pizza. The crust and toppings were delicious. Not a deep dish pizza but an East Coast thickness pizza. We will go back for more.
We’ve tried pretty much everything on the menu at this point and so far they haven’t missed. We love the spinach artichoke dip, the pesto flatbread, the spinach salad, and their pizza is delicious!
Super busy but we'll run and great pizza
The pizza is always really good, and the staff are nice even when dealing with angry people waiting for their pizza. On weekends the pizza always takes longer than it says if you order online, so just be prepared.
Great pizza spot on Belmont. There’s a lot of pizza around, but hard to find a place as reliable as Serio, especially when it comes to something that that’s not deep dish or Chicago-style thin crust. It’s an oven fired pizza, but not quite as thin as Neopolitan style.
The crust is just chewy enough to be addictive without being too bready. Standout ingredient if you pick a pizza or build your own is fresh mozzarella.
It has saved the day when the pizza itch has hit many a time 🙂
The staff was so nice when I walked in asking about the EL when my Lyft ride didn't show. Would like to return. Take care.
Feb 2025
Ambience was casual, went on a Wednesday night. Great service. Food did not wow us- got the pesto margherita pizza and the goat cheese dip. The pizza lacked flavor. However their dough so great. Would not come back because there are so many better pizza places in Chicago!
The best pizza in Chicago
Restaurantji Recommends
Perfect place to host a private event! They were extremely easy to work with. Event space was perfect for a shower. Food and service was awesome as always. And able to accommodate several dietary restrictions. Thank you for making hosting so easy!
UPDATE
Within a few minutes of this review, they reached out to us to express their apologies for the way the night went. They were short staffed, Valentine’s Day, along with bad weather, made for a difficult night. The pizza that we ordered was not hot and needed to be reheated, it was still excellent. The fact that they immediately called to take care of the issue was amazing.
Unreal, I ordered our pizza at 607 with an estimated delivery time of 722. I called at 737 and they told me it just left to be delivered. They arrived to deliver the pizza at 830 and the driver put the COLD pizza on the step and ran. We attempted to call the location and we were welcomed with a busy signal. I can understand that deliveries will be delayed due to Valentine’s Day and the snow, but I ordered with plenty of time. I didn’t just order a $20 pizza, my total was 118.61 with tip and delivery. Not happy at all, and I would recommend that no one order from this place if they want it delivered within a timely manner and communication. First time and last time customer.
Staff was fantastic! Set up a great spot for my daughter’s bday dinner with friends.
They made it so easy to make this happen and were a delight to work with from start to finish.
Thanks, Pizzeria Serio!
great pizza, great salads, kid friendly, staff is super nice.
Great pizza place with friendly staff and great food. The Tuesday $12/$18 small/large pizza deal is a great value. I love the Diavola pizza.
Loading...