PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO

2459 N Halsted St, Chicago
(312) 800-1600

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Prosciutto E Funghi Pizza
Proper Pizza Margherita
Crunchy Nutella Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Cheeseburger 24
Pepperoni Pizza
Mushroom Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Truffle Pizza
Garlic Bread

Menu

Individual Pizza (12)
Build Your Own Pizza (12)
0. Cheese Pizza (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
19. Buffalo Chicken (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, buffalo chicken, and sesame seeds.
18. Cheeseburger (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, meatballs, iceberg lettuce, burger sauce, ketchup, chives, and sesame seeds.
17. Truffle (12)
White sauce, truffle paste, truffle oil, mushrooms, pecorino cheese, pine nuts, sesame seeds.
16. Macho (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken meatballs, macho sauce, chives, sesame seeds.
15. American Gangster (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, ham, sliced black olives, onions, mixed peppers, mushrooms, loca sauce, sesame seeds.
14. Crudo Parmezan (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, rucola, parma ham prosciutto, sliced parmesan, cherry tomato, and sesame seeds.
13. Hawaiian (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pineapple, ham, and sesame seeds.
12. 4 Cheese (12)
White sauce, special proper chees, gorgonzola, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, sesame seeds,
11. Sausage Pizza (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper chees, sausage, sesame seeds
10. Blues Brother (12)
Tomato sauce, 5 ingredients of your choice, sesame seeds.
9. Proper Pizza (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, smoked beef prosciutto, smoked beef sausage, mushrooms, and sesame seeds.
8. Anchovies (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, anchovies, olives, sesame seeds.
6. Tuna (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, tuna fish, sesame seeds.
5. Pepperoni (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
4. BBQ Chicken (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken, bbq sauce, and sesame seeds.
3. OMG Vegetarian (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, caramelized onions, eggplants, onions, sesame seeds.
2. Mushroom Pizza (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mushrooms, sesame seeds.
1. Margherita (12)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.

Sharing Pizza (16)
Free Nutella
Get 2 Sharing Cheese Pizzas and get Free Nutella
Build Your Own Pizza (16)
0. Cheese Pizza (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
19. Buffalo Chicken (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, buffalo chicken, and sesame seeds.
18. Cheeseburger (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, meatballs, iceberg lettuce, burger sauce, ketchup, chives, and sesame seeds.
17. Truffle (16)
White sauce, truffle paste, truffle oil, mushrooms, pecorino cheese, pine nuts, sesame seeds.
16. Macho (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken meatballs, macho sauce, chives, and sesame seeds.
15. American Gangster (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, ham, sliced black olives, onions, mixed peppers, mushrooms, loca sauce, sesame seeds.
14. Crudo Parmezan (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, rucola, parma ham prosciutto, sliced parmesan, cherry tomato, and sesame seeds.
13. Hawaiian (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pineapple, ham, and sesame seeds.
12. 4 Cheese (16)
White sauce, special proper chees, gorgonzola, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, sesame seeds,
11. Sausage Pizza (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper chees, sausage, sesame seeds
10. Blues Brother (16)
Tomato sauce, 5 ingredients of your choice, sesame seeds.
9. Proper Pizza (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, smoked beef prosciutto, smoked beef sausage, mushrooms, and sesame seeds.
8. Anchovies (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, anchovies, olives, sesame seeds.
6. Tuna (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, tuna fish, sesame seeds.
5. Pepperoni (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
4. BBQ Chicken (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken, bbq sauce, and sesame seeds.
3. OMG Vegetarian (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, caramelized onions, eggplants, onions, sesame seeds. .
2. Mushroom Pizza (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mushrooms, sesame seeds.
1. Margherita (16)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.

Party Pizza (24)
Build Your Own Pizza (24)
0. Cheese Pizza (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
19. Buffalo Chicken (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, buffalo chicken, and sesame seeds.
18. Cheeseburger (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, meatballs, iceberg lettuce, burger sauce, ketchup, chives, and sesame seeds.
17. Truffle (24)
White sauce, truffle paste, truffle oil, mushrooms, pecorino cheese, pine nuts, sesame seeds.
16. Macho (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken meatballs, macho sauce, chives, and sesame seeds.
15. American Gangster (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, ham, sliced black olives, onions, mixed peppers, mushrooms, loca sauce, sesame seeds.
14. Crudo Parmezan (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, rucola, parma ham prosciutto, sliced parmesan, cherry tomato, and sesame seeds.
13. Hawaiian (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pineapple, ham, and sesame seeds.
12. 4 Cheese (24)
White sauce, special proper chees, gorgonzola, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, sesame seeds,
11. Sausage Pizza (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper chees, sausage, sesame seeds
10. Blues Brother (24)
Tomato sauce, 5 ingredients of your choice, sesame seeds.
9. Proper Pizza (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, smoked beef prosciutto, smoked beef sausage, mushrooms, and sesame seeds.
8. Anchovies (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, anchovies, olives, sesame seeds.
6. Tuna (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, tuna fish, sesame seeds.
5. Pepperoni (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
4. BBQ Chicken (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken, bbq sauce, and sesame seeds.
3. OMG Vegetarian (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, caramelized onions, eggplants, onions, sesame seeds.
2. Mushroom Pizza (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mushrooms, sesame seeds.
1. Margherita (24)
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.

Sides
Baby Arugula Salad
Arugula Salad with Extra virgin olive oil, Balsamic vinegar, Sweet Balsamic, Cherry tomato, Pine nuts, and shaved Parmesan Cheese
Chicken Tenders
6 Fresh Chicken tenders with a choice of flavor and dressing sauce
Chicken Wings
Fresh jumbo wings seasoned with our spices, served plain or tossed in buffalo or BBQ sauce with a choice of dressing
Cesar Sauce
Ranch Sauce
Loca Sauce
Macho Sauce
Cesar Salad
Crisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing, and grated cheese
Cesar Salad with Chicken
Crisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing, grated cheese, and Chicken
Garlic Bread & Cheeses
A cross between garlic bread and pizza, cheesy bread is a quick, easy, and delicious party snack, with macho sauce.

Soft Drinks
Sprite
Diet Coke
2L Soda
Red Bull
Natural Water
Sparkling Water
Coca Cola Zero
Coca Cola

Sweet Corner
Tiramisu
A delicious coffee-flavored Italian dessert. Ladyfingers dipped in coffee, layered with a whipped mixture of eggs, sugar & mascarpone cheese, flavored with cocoa.
Crunchy Nutella
Nutella, Caramel, Granulated Peanuts, Graham Cracker Crumbs, and a pinch of Love

Holiday Special

Free Nutella
Get 2 Sharing Cheese Pizzas and get Free Nutella
Free Nutella and 2L Coke
Get 2 Party Size Cheese Pizzas 24'' to get Free Nutella and 2L Coke

Vegan Pizza
Vegan Veggie (12)
Tomato sauce, vegan vitialite mozzarella cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, eggplants, onions, and sesame seeds.
Cheese Vegan (12)
Tomato sauce, vegan mozzarella cheese, sesame seeds.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: ubereats
+35 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+34 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Pizza was delicious, loved the sesame seed crust. Got the vegan veggie, which was $24 ($30 after tax & tip) but it was not enough to feed two people. The photo showed the pizza loaded with veggies but there was maybe half as much on the actual pizza. The identical pizza with dairy cheese was $19. Shouldn’t be $5 more just for vegan cheese. Overall enjoyed the meal, but for the price I expected a lot more food :/
January 2026
Not only is the pizza absolutely delicious but the service and kindness of the owner/staff is unmatched. This is your classic neighborhood spot that will always be our favorite. A must go! Once you try the crust - there’s no going back. Love love love Proper Pizza!
December 2025
Welcoming place. I was walking past and stopped in. I only had a slice but the manager welcomed me like I was a long time customer. Proper is an international chain from Europe. Their pizza is a bit different with a sesame seeded crust. Nice change. It was mostly empty when I visited but with a regular stream of takeouts. Check it out.
November 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Noodles In the Pot - 2453 N Halsted St
Thai, Noodles, Vegan, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly
Hunter's on Halsted - 2447 N Halsted St
Bar
Paula's Thai Kitchen - 2441 N Halsted St
Thai, Vegetarian

PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO

2459 N Halsted St, Chicago, IL 60614
(312) 800-1600