Cone Cottage
1192 Main St, Crete
(708) 672-1250
Customers' Favorites
Vanilla Chocolate Swirl
Vanilla Ice Cream Swirl
Death by Chocolate
Whipped Cream
Banana Split
Sherbert
Sundaes
Nachos
Menu
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I come here a few times during their open season. Today 10/02/25 I went and puechased a chocolate malt and a vanilla/chocolate ice cream cone. Upon tasting the malt I realized it tasted spoiled. I tried my son’s ice cream and it tasted spoiled as well. I went back to the register and let “Maddie” know. Her first words were “our ice cream isn’t spoiled.” I told her both that I purchased tasted spoiled so she gave me a refund. The same thing happened last year around...
Stopped by Cone Cottage in Crete for a quick treat! The ice cream was tasty and the prices were fair for what you get. The place has a classic small-town feel, and the staff was friendly enough. What really made the stop fun was that they offered a doggie sundae, which our pup absolutely loved! It’s always nice to find a spot that thinks of the four-legged family members too. Nothing fancy, but a solid choice on a warm day if you’re in the area. Would visit again!
Cone Cottage is an absolute staple and gem ice cream spot in this area! Their prices are fantastic, along with their friendly staff. Everything is made well and quick. They have amazing options and a variety of them too! Our favorite is their "Elephant Poop Blaster" which is seriously one of the best flurries out there. Don't knock it until you try it!!! :)
You May Also Like
Evil Horse Brewing Company - 1338 Main St
![]()
Brewery, Bar, Pet Friendly
Super Burrito - 1358 Main St
![]()
Mexican