Kilwins Evanston

1724 Sherman Ave, Evanston
(847) 868-8739

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Kilwins Original Recipe Hand-Packed Ice Cream Quart
Peanut and Pecan Caramel Apple
Hand-Packed Ice Cream Quarts
Ice Cream Cone
Peanut Brittle

Most Popular
Kilwins "Original Recipe" Hand-Packed Ice Cream Quarts
Kilwins "Original Recipe" Ice Cream is the creamiest, most delicious Ice Cream you'll ever enjoy!
Milk Chocolate Pecan Snapper 5 oz.
Our Milk Chocolate Pecan Snapper features mammoth pecan halves in a pool of hand-crafted copper-kettle Caramel, covered with Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge
Our Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge features our classic Chocolate Fudge and Peanut Butter Fudge - the perfect combination!
Double Dark Chocolate Fudge
Our Double Dark Chocolate Fudge contains twice as much Chocolate as our classic Chocolate Fudge, for a dark, rich, smooth experience.
Nutcracker Sweets 8 oz.
Our Nutcracker Sweets features freshly-popped corn, whole almonds & mammoth pecans in our classic homemade copper-kettle Caramel.
Family Assortment 9 oz.
Our Family Assortment is our most popular Heritage Chocolate assortment with something for every taste!
Caramel Chews 6 oz.
Our own hand-crafted copper-kettle Caramel is cut into bite sized chews & perfectly packaged for you.
Milk Chocolate Pecan Tuttles 1/2 lb
Kilwins Milk Chocolate Pecan Tuttles are our best-selling Chocolate confection, featuring fresh pecans, copper-kettle hand-dropped Caramel, & velvety Kilwins Heritate Milk Chocolate.
Kilwins Milk Chocolate Cashew Bear Claw 5 oz.
Our Kilwins Milk Chocolate Bear Claw features our hand-crafted copper-kettle Caramel hand-dropped on a mound of whole jumbo cashews & covered with Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate.
Milk Almond Toffee Bars 1/2 lb
Kilwins Milk Almond Toffee Bars feature buttery toffee enrobed in Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate & topped with chopped almonds.

Picked for you
Kilwins "Original Recipe" Hand-Packed Ice Cream Quarts
Kilwins "Original Recipe" Ice Cream is the creamiest, most delicious Ice Cream you'll ever enjoy!
Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge
Our Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge features our classic Chocolate Fudge and Peanut Butter Fudge - the perfect combination!
Family Assortment 14 oz.
Our Family Assortment is our most popular Heritage Chocolate assortment with something for every taste!
Milk Chocolate Cherry Cordials 8 oz.
A delightful whole cherry center is enrobed in a double layer of rich Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate.
Milk Chocolate Pecan Snapper 5 oz.
Our Milk Chocolate Pecan Snapper features mammoth pecan halves in a pool of hand-crafted copper-kettle Caramel, covered with Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate.

Ice Cream
Double Scoop in a Dish
Double Scoop of Kilwins "Original Recipe" Ice Cream in a Dish
Gourmet Cake & Ice Cream
Available in 6 varieties, Kilwins Gourmet Cake & Ice Cream is hand-crafted, & layered with our "Original Recipe" Ice Cream, delicious cake, & inclusions such as hand-chopped nuts, chocolate shavings or cookie crumbles, all expertly frosted.
Kilwins "Original Recipe" Hand-Packed Ice Cream Quarts
Kilwins "Original Recipe" Ice Cream is the creamiest, most delicious Ice Cream you'll ever enjoy!
Single Scoop in a Dish
Single Scoop of Kilwins "Original Recipe" Ice Cream in a Dish
Toppings

Tuttles and Toffee
Milk Chocolate Pecan Tuttles 1/2 lb
Kilwins Milk Chocolate Pecan Tuttles are our best-selling Chocolate confection, featuring fresh pecans, copper-kettle hand-dropped Caramel, & velvety Kilwins Heritate Milk Chocolate.
Milk Almond Toffee Bars 1/2 lb
Kilwins Milk Almond Toffee Bars feature buttery toffee enrobed in Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate & topped with chopped almonds.
Dark Almond Toffee Bars 1/2 lb
Kilwins Dark Almond Toffee Bars feature buttery toffee enrobed in Kilwins Heritage Dark Chocolate & topped with chopped almonds.
Dark Chocolate Pecan Tuttles 1/2 lb
Kilwins Dark Chocolate Pecan Tuttles feature fresh pecans, copper-kettle hand-dropped Caramel, & velvety Kilwins Heritate Dark Chocolate.

Specialty Chocolate Assortments
Family Assortment 14 oz.
Our Family Assortment is our most popular Heritage Chocolate assortment with something for every taste!
Family Assortment 9 oz.
Our Family Assortment is our most popular Heritage Chocolate assortment with something for every taste!
9-piece Truffle Assortment 4.75 oz
Our 9-piece Truffle Assortment is a delightful array of our "Extraordinary Everyday" Truffles - sure to impress the most discerning tastes!
Truffle Assortment 1/2 lb
Our 1/2 lb. Truffle Assortment is a delightful array of our "Extraordinary Everyday" Truffles - sure to impress the most discerning tastes!
Chocolate Cream Assortment 1/2 lb
Our Chocolate Cream Assortment is a delicious assortment of Katy Kilwin's favorite Creams.
Sea-Salt Chocolate Caramel Assortment 6oz
Don Kilwin's original Caramel recipe is cooked to perfection in a copper kettle, covered in Kilwins Heritage Milk & Dark Chocolate, and sprinkled with sea salt from around the world.

Fudge
Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge
Our Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge features our classic Chocolate Fudge and Peanut Butter Fudge - the perfect combination!
3 Slice Fudge Assortment
3 half pound slices of our classic Mackinac Island Fudge. Choose an assortment from our available flavors.
Chocolate English Walnut Fudge
Our Chocolate English Walnut Fudge features our classic Chocolate Fudge loaded with delicate English walnuts.
Double Dark Chocolate Fudge
Our Double Dark Chocolate Fudge contains twice as much Chocolate as our classic Chocolate Fudge, for a dark, rich, smooth experience.

Other Favorites
Milk Chocolate Pecan Snapper 5 oz.
Our Milk Chocolate Pecan Snapper features mammoth pecan halves in a pool of hand-crafted copper-kettle Caramel, covered with Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate.
Kilwins "Heritage" Milk Chocolate Bar 2.25 oz.
Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate Bar is made with Fair Trade & Kosher Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate, featuring a rich caramel flavor.
Kilwins "Heritage" White Chocolate Bar 2.25 oz
Kilwins Heritage White Chocolate Bar is made with Fair Trade & Kosher Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate, featuring flavor notes of vanilla, & rich caramel.
Kilwins Milk Chocolate Cashew Bear Claw 5 oz.
Our Kilwins Milk Chocolate Bear Claw features our hand-crafted copper-kettle Caramel hand-dropped on a mound of whole jumbo cashews & covered with Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate.
Dark Chocolate Cherry Cordials 8 oz.
A delightful whole cherry center is enrobed in a double layer of rich Kilwins Heritage Dark Chocolate.
Peanut Brittle 14 oz.
Our Peanut Brittle features Spanish peanuts roasted & coated in Kilwins crunchy kitchen-made brittle.
Milk Chocolate Almonds
Fresh dry-roasted supreme almonds covered in creamy milk chocolate.
Milk Chocolate Raisins
California raisins covered in creamy milk chocolate.
Kilwins "Heritage" Dark Chocolate Bar 2.25 oz.
Kilwins Heritage Dark Chocolate Bar is made with Fair Trade & Kosher Kilwins Heritage Dark Chocolate, featuring hints of spice, licorice, & a dark, fudgy flavor.
Dark Sea Foam 6 oz
Kilwins Dark Chocolate Sea Foam is a crisp, salty, light-as-air center enrobed in Kilwins Heritage Dark Chocolate.
Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Bark 6oz
A layer of Kilwins Heritage Dark Chocolate covers peanut butter cup filling, drizzled in Dark Chocolate.
Dark Chocolate Almonds
Fresh dry-roasted supreme almonds covered in dark chocolate.
Milk Sea Foam 6 oz
Kilwins Milk Chocolate Sea Foam is a crisp, salty, light-as-air center enrobed in Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate.
Caramel Chews 6 oz.
Our own hand-crafted copper-kettle Caramel is cut into bite sized chews & perfectly packaged for you.
Milk Chocolate Cherry Cordials 8 oz.
A delightful whole cherry center is enrobed in a double layer of rich Kilwins Heritage Milk Chocolate.
Nutcracker Sweets 8 oz.
Our Nutcracker Sweets features freshly-popped corn, whole almonds & mammoth pecans in our classic homemade copper-kettle Caramel.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+80 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+79 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Went here tonight with my kids- the ice cream is always great. Shannon's service was excellent. She was friendly and patient. I highly recommend. (pic of toasted coconut ice cream
January 2026
There was a specific apple flavor they were out of and Robyn offered to make it for me and even after I said she didn’t need to, she insisted! She was so sweet and super friendly. She gave us samples of ice cream and fudge and everything was so delicious!!!
November 2025
Mediocre, not bad, but not great either. They ended up having what I needed but the vibe check is definitely a better experience with slightly more options at the location downtown (Chicago) vs Evanston. Trust me it's the little things that'll make the extra trip a worthwhile experience.
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

TOMO Japanese Street Food - 1726 Sherman Ave
Japanese, Ramen, Japanese Curry, Asian Fusion, Vegetarian
Mumbai Indian Grill - 1728 Sherman Ave
Indian
Jamba - 1732 Sherman Ave
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies

Kilwins Evanston

1724 Sherman Ave, Evanston, IL 60201
(847) 868-8739