Yogurt Beach -Frozen Yogurt, Custard & Treats

I had a horrible experience at this location. The yogurt was fine, however the staff was extremely rude and ill mannered. It definitely seemed like the man working there hates his job and didn’t want to do any extra work. He accosted us for throwing out extra trash in his bin OUTSIDE of the store. He came outside specifically to yell at my family. I will not be coming back here again.

We usually go to Menchie’s for our frozen yogurt fix, but it was a bit farther than we wanted to drive this time. While searching the area, we came across Yogurt Beach, and we’re really glad we did!

The setup was clean and well-organized, and there were plenty of great flavor options and toppings to choose from. I went with a twist of cake batter and cotton candy—both flavors were smooth, not overly sweet, and didn’t taste artificial at all. My daughters loved their FroYo, and we all left happy.

The owner (I believe his name was Jeff) and his coworker were very friendly and welcoming. The customer service really stood out—both were kind, helpful, and made the experience feel personal.

On top of that, Yogurt Beach also offers shakes, bubble tea, and other treats, so there’s something for everyone. The layout of the space made it easy to navigate and enjoyable to hang out in.

Bonus: If you’re a teacher, they offer a 25% discount on your order, which is a thoughtful touch!

All in all, Yogurt Beach has definitely earned a spot in our rotation. We’ll be back for sure—and my daughters might not be Menchie’s-only fans anymore.

Loved this place. Very food allergy friendly
So you won’t die here.
Only thing. It is a hustle to get samples, but other than that, it’s fine

We were pleasantly surprised with the value and atmosphere. It's a great place to take a young family out for a treat. In the evenings it also seems to turn into a date spot for high schoolers.

The yogurt is absolutely delightful! I really appreciate how well decorated the place is, and I genuinely enjoy my visits here.

Family owned frozen treat gem! Allergy friendly, cool tropical vibes and the BEST frozen treats around. Over 50 toppings, self serve custards, gelatos, froyo & non dairy gourmet flavors--Your local vacation getaway.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love it! The staff keeps it super clean and they are super friendly. Great place to take the kids!

Craving yogurt ice cream, stopped on my way back to Indy. Very happening and crowded place even on a Sunday night which was pleasantly surprising. There’s a variety of yogurt, gelato and sorbet flavors and the number of toppings are definitely a lot. Total of 5-6 minutes but everyone was courteous and friendly. I did like they had flavor separators which is definitely not common in every yogurt ice cream spot.

Many options for flavours and toppings.

Family favorite!

They have a good selection of different flavor yogurts and an even more amaxing selection of toppings. Literally everything you can think of.

This ice cream was absolutely delicious! Super creamy, rich in flavor, and just the right amount of sweetness. I tried the Coconut Flavour and it was spot on—definitely one of the best I’ve had in a while. Perfect treat for a hot day!

Always so clean, so many options, reasonably priced, great hours. Just love it!

Yum! Plenty of flavors of frozen yogurt, sorbets and good variety of toppings.

this place is such a gem, it quickly turned into a date spot for me and my partner after we tried finding a self serve froyo place. i love love love the beachy vibes and delicious fro yo.