Annie's Custard & Cafe
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
1320 Mulholland St, Nauvoo
(217) 980-1031
About Annie's Custard & Cafe
Annie's Custard & Cafe Reviews
We stopped at Annie’s Frozen Custard & Café in Nauvoo, Illinois, and ended up going three days in a row — it’s that good! The biscuits and sausage gravy were perfectly seasoned and comforting, and the Wagon Wheel cinnamon roll was absolutely unforgettable — soft, sweet, and made with love.
One of the best parts was meeting the owner, who was kind, welcoming, and truly invested in the community. She hires and supports local staff, and it shows in the warm, friendly...read full review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
A Hidden Gem in Nauvoo!
I had the absolute pleasure of enjoying breakfast at Annie and Custard Café, and wow — it was unforgettable! The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, but the food is what truly steals the show.
The cinnamon rolls — lovingly called “Wagon Wheels” — were massive, gooey, and perfectly spiced. They alone are worth the trip. I also tried the biscuits and gravy, which were rich, comforting, and full of flavor,...read full review
I absolutely love this place! It is a staple of any visit to Nauvoo! It is so fun to gather there after the pageant - costumes and all! They are so friendly and their custard is the best - especially grasshopper!!
Menu
People in Nauvoo Also Viewed
Annie's Custard & Cafe offers a delightful dining experience with its tasty custard, delicious paninis, and fresh salads. The restaurant has a welcoming atmosphere, and the staff is attentive, helping customers with their specific preferences. Customers praise the quick service, particularly for the custard orders. The menu features a variety of options, including the recommended 9:37 panini and the teriyaki panini. Overall, Annie's Custard & Cafe provides a satisfying dining experience with good food and friendly service.