Theo's Ice Cream

3633 N Gale Ave, Peoria
(309) 688-5854

Recent Reviews

Jim Hopton

Secret off-menu item to ask for...Vanilla Ice Cream & ButterscotchMalted Milkshake!!!You can thank me later.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

mnm

Great selection of ice cream.Wish they didnt take cash only and had more seating. Parking lot is hard to get in and out of.Also, would be great if you included small descriptions on your mixers.Parking: Small and difficult to get in and out ofKid-friendliness: Great for taking kids for ice cream

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge, Sundaes

Sara McMillian

First time visiting here...so yummy and prices

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gary Stevens

Best soft serve anywhere. Reasonable price.

Alan Hattermann

Best chili cheese dogs in Peoria. Hands down

Rachel Downing

Hands down the best ice cream in Peoria. So many options but even a simple chocolate or vanilla cone will turn you into a frequent flyer at this walk up ice cream shop. It’s the perfect ending to a summer evening but one you can enjoy year around!

Lola Paulson

The best tamale ever and they are so nice

Jake Hagerdorn

Great ALL YEAR place for ice cream, deserts and food! Chili dog with onion and mustard please!

Michelle Jones

Amazing experience every time!! Great ice cream and friendly service!!

Dennis Zehr

seems to have gone down a bit. only 1 working lunch and out of slushes.... after i paid. tamales were good as usual but nachos were just poured over chips in small container so all were soggy.

Madison Boedecker

We love going to Theo’s anytime it gets warm out! They have the best ice cream and even better food! Never been disappointed and they’re always coming out with fun new menu items, like these ice cream nachos.

Lisa Janco

We love Theo's! Tried the waffle chip sundaes tonight and they were so good!

[OSK] One Shot Kill

Not the greatest but it's a good place to get some ice cream. I'd say Top 3 in Peoria.

westwardh0

Nice little outdoor ice cream place, with a variety of things to add to frozen custard for a Berg. Outdoor seating only, I believe. Local, not a chain.

Shawn Grimm

Tamales are AWESOME! Hot dogs acceptable (but these people downstate putting ketchup on a dog.... Smh)....the Iceberg was good but tutti frutti was accomplished by adding Fruity Pebbles! Lol I would complain but I ate the whole thing so whatever!

Load More