Theo's Ice Cream & Cafe
$ • Ice Cream
Hours:
3633 N Gale Ave, Peoria
(309) 688-5854
About Theo's Ice Cream & Cafe
Customers' Favorites
Theo's Ice Cream & Cafe Reviews
Share your opinion about Theo's Ice Cream & Cafe
I got a delicious 😋 strawberry shortcake shake...Definitely recommend
the " Best in the Area 😍 everything is delicious 🩷 they staff is friendly attentive & their Smiles is Radiant! my absolute favorite place😍
Employees were polite and ice coffee I got was ok!
Chili dogs are 100% not the same 😳 They are all beef, rubbery, thin, and chili is awful. Took one bite and threw it out.
Why change something that was so great for so many years? 😬😬I get it they want to make it their own but man, a bit disappointing
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 8:30AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 8AM - 8PM |
People in Peoria Also Viewed
Theo’s Ice Cream & Cafe is a small, charming spot offering a surprisingly large menu with many options. The building is eye-catching, making it easy to find, though the interior feels a bit random with its decor. The black marble-style walls with gold veining give it a unique look, but some areas, like the display case, could use updating. Inside, there are only a few small tables, so it’s best for small groups or quick visits.
The menu features a variety of treats, including ice cream, bakery items, and specialty drinks. Popular choices include the waffle puffs, iced caramel macchiato, Dubai chocolate latte, and the viral fruits from TikTok. The desserts, such as the caramel oreo drizzled cheesecake, are highly recommended and considered some of the best desserts in a long time. The ice cream portions are small, and prices may seem high for what is served, but the desserts look beautiful and taste good.
Customer service is friendly and welcoming, though the space is tight and can be crowded. Some reviews mention the need for more napkins and a cleaner display case. The drinks are enjoyable, with the Dubai chocolate latte praised for its appearance and flavor, though it could be colder. Overall, Theo’s is a delightful place for ice cream and cafe treats, with friendly staff and a cozy vibe, making it worth a visit for those seeking a sweet or coffee break.