It's been a while but these pies are soooooo delicious 😋. You must visit.
Tammy Dammann
It's a cute little shop. The pies are really good. The Key lime rivals anything in Florida and I love the lemon meringue and custard pies as well. It's a very popular place, but keep an eye out for hours. They're only open until 2 on Thursdays, Fridays and Saturdays.
fadia mashni
I visited yesterday. I was a tourist in Princeton. Most amazing pies I’ve ever had. I bought the French silk, I loved it. The banana cream pie I think is my favorite. I regret not buying more flavors. I also bought the root beer cookies! I really love how fresh the cookies felt and tasted. I’ll be back in July to get more! The owner was so nice by the way! You can tell he works very hard and he’s personable with everyone. Exceptional service, truly!
fred vee
Small old place but terrific pies best I've ever had
Victoria Thomas
Very beautiful pies. Can't wait to bake our pie. Offers a wide variety of fruit pies. A d has a little bit of seating for you have a slice with ice cream.
Erik Czerwin
The best bakery in the area for pie, cinnamon rolls, and more. Get here early or you'll miss out. Of course, you can always order ahead. I would list all the pies we've tried, but they're all simply divine. My personal favorite so far is Rum Chata. And the cinnamon rolls... I dream about them. It's an unhealthy relationship, to be honest. But I'll go out of my way to get em. And you should, too.
Linda Battaglia
Amazing... delicious!!! What a gem in the heart of Princeton.
Joe Haggard
We got a strawberry ruebarb pie for a local fundraiser auction. Well the first bite of crust taste like grease out of the can. This was our first pie from here ever and I doubt I will ever buy directly from here. What a big disappointment
Food: 1
Linda Jensen
The pies are ALWAYS delicious and Dave is just a sweetheart! Highly recommend Myrtles.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Peach Pie and Apple Pie, Pumpkin Pie, Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
C. Kunz
Mmmm, pie. We had chocolate peanut butter and custard. Both were excellent. We came down from Chicago and it was worth the trip.
This is the best pie i've ever eaten. It is so delicious. It's just as good as grandma's pies
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Raspberry Lemon Pie, Dutch Apple Pie a La Mode, Peach Pie and Apple Pie, Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, Blueberry Pie, Lemon Meringue Pie, All American Apple Pie a La Mode
Jackie Winter
This place is a breath of fresh air in the Illinois Valley. Rhubarb custard pie was fab! Lavender lemonade was delicious as well! 10/10 loved the service, and dining atmosphere.
B Rad
What a fun place to hang. Oh yeah, and the pie.....ahmaaazing!! I had basic apple pie, but believe me when I say there is nothing basic about the flavor. Reminds of my Grandma's, but better (sorry Grandma.) Everything was delish, from the flaky crust to the perfectly spiced apple filling. I live an hour away, but planning my next trip back soon. Yummmmmmm!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gregg McCarty Sr
Excellent little pie shop.Great service .Bought a variety of desserts pies, banana bread, cinnamon rolls. Everything is delicious. 1st time customer will return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pecan Pie, Chocolate Silk
John Moore
What a hidden gem in Princeton Illinois!
Only open Friday thru Sunday.. this gem makes some of the best pies I have ever had.
The owner loves what he does and it shows . They offer a wide selection of fruit and creme pies. You can also call in advance if there is a flavor you are craving or if you want a gluten free crust.
Prices are very reasonable. We sat inside and had the lemon meringue and banana creme. Both were fantastic.
Purchased a few cinnamon rolls and a key lime pie to go.
It's been a while but these pies are soooooo delicious 😋. You must visit.
It's a cute little shop. The pies are really good. The Key lime rivals anything in Florida and I love the lemon meringue and custard pies as well. It's a very popular place, but keep an eye out for hours. They're only open until 2 on Thursdays, Fridays and Saturdays.
I visited yesterday. I was a tourist in Princeton. Most amazing pies I’ve ever had. I bought the French silk, I loved it. The banana cream pie I think is my favorite. I regret not buying more flavors. I also bought the root beer cookies! I really love how fresh the cookies felt and tasted. I’ll be back in July to get more! The owner was so nice by the way! You can tell he works very hard and he’s personable with everyone. Exceptional service, truly!
Small old place but terrific pies best I've ever had
Very beautiful pies. Can't wait to bake our pie. Offers a wide variety of fruit pies. A d has a little bit of seating for you have a slice with ice cream.
The best bakery in the area for pie, cinnamon rolls, and more. Get here early or you'll miss out. Of course, you can always order ahead.
I would list all the pies we've tried, but they're all simply divine. My personal favorite so far is Rum Chata. And the cinnamon rolls... I dream about them. It's an unhealthy relationship, to be honest. But I'll go out of my way to get em. And you should, too.
Amazing... delicious!!! What a gem in the heart of Princeton.
We got a strawberry ruebarb pie for a local fundraiser auction. Well the first bite of crust taste like grease out of the can. This was our first pie from here ever and I doubt I will ever buy directly from here. What a big disappointment
Food: 1
The pies are ALWAYS delicious and Dave is just a sweetheart! Highly recommend Myrtles.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Peach Pie and Apple Pie, Pumpkin Pie, Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Mmmm, pie. We had chocolate peanut butter and custard. Both were excellent. We came down from Chicago and it was worth the trip.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This is the best pie i've ever eaten.
It is so delicious.
It's just as good as grandma's pies
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Raspberry Lemon Pie, Dutch Apple Pie a La Mode, Peach Pie and Apple Pie, Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, Blueberry Pie, Lemon Meringue Pie, All American Apple Pie a La Mode
This place is a breath of fresh air in the Illinois Valley. Rhubarb custard pie was fab! Lavender lemonade was delicious as well! 10/10 loved the service, and dining atmosphere.
What a fun place to hang. Oh yeah, and the pie.....ahmaaazing!! I had basic apple pie, but believe me when I say there is nothing basic about the flavor. Reminds of my Grandma's, but better (sorry Grandma.) Everything was delish, from the flaky crust to the perfectly spiced apple filling. I live an hour away, but planning my next trip back soon. Yummmmmmm!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent little pie shop.Great service .Bought a variety of desserts pies, banana bread, cinnamon rolls.
Everything is delicious. 1st time customer will return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pecan Pie, Chocolate Silk
What a hidden gem in Princeton Illinois!
Only open Friday thru Sunday.. this gem makes some of the best pies I have ever had.
The owner loves what he does and it shows . They offer a wide selection of fruit and creme pies. You can also call in advance if there is a flavor you are craving or if you want a gluten free crust.
Prices are very reasonable. We sat inside and had the lemon meringue and banana creme. Both were fantastic.
Purchased a few cinnamon rolls and a key lime pie to go.
Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...