Myrtle's Pie
927 N Main St, Princeton
(815) 915-8397
Customers' Favorites
All American Apple Pie a La Mode
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Dutch Apple Pie a La Mode
Peach Pie and Apple Pie
Caramel Apple Walnut Pie
Chocolate Cream Pie
Raspberry Lemon Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Banana Cream Pie
Chocolate Silk
Menu
Photos
+48 photos
+47 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
A wonderful bakery! enjoy a slice, take and bake, or ready made pies. we had a slice of pie each there, took a pie and quiche home to bake. oh my was it delicious 😋, definitely worth the drive!
VIsited September 2025, had the Brownie salted caramel coffee cream pie; my sister had the cherry rhubarb; took home some peanut butter monster cookies. Everything was excellent in all aspects. Read the story of Myrtle on the business' page for some really nice family baking history.
You May Also Like
Barrel Society - 930 N Main St
![]()
Bar, Cocktail Bar, Whiskey Bar, Beer Bar, Pet Friendly
Paisano’s Ristorante - 1007 N Main St
![]()
Italian, Pizza, American, Vegetarian
Cafe Grace - 1009 N Main St
![]()
American, Coffee & Tea
They have a cake batter one with sprinkles for kids!
Strawberry Mango sounds delicious too!