Myrtle's Pie
927 N Main St, Princeton
(815) 915-8397
Customers' Favorites
All American Apple Pie a La Mode
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Dutch Apple Pie a La Mode
Caramel Apple Walnut Pie
Peach Pie and Apple Pie
Chocolate Cream Pie
Raspberry Lemon Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Banana Cream Pie
Chocolate Silk
Menu
Photos
+44 photos
+43 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
It's a cute little shop. The pies are really good. The Key lime rivals anything in Florida and I love the lemon meringue and custard pies as well. It's a very popular place, but keep an eye out for hours. They're only open until 2 on Thursdays, Fridays and Saturdays.
I visited yesterday. I was a tourist in Princeton. Most amazing pies I’ve ever had. I bought the French silk, I loved it. The banana cream pie I think is my favorite. I regret not buying more flavors. I also bought the root beer cookies! I really love how fresh the cookies felt and tasted. I’ll be back in July to get more! The owner was so nice by the way! You can tell he works very hard and he’s personable with everyone. Exceptional service, truly!
The best bakery in the area for pie, cinnamon rolls, and more. Get here early or you'll miss out. Of course, you can always order ahead.
I would list all the pies we've tried, but they're all simply divine. My personal favorite so far is Rum Chata. And the cinnamon rolls... I dream about them. It's an unhealthy relationship, to be honest. But I'll go out of my way to get em. And you should, too.
I would list all the pies we've tried, but they're all simply divine. My personal favorite so far is Rum Chata. And the cinnamon rolls... I dream about them. It's an unhealthy relationship, to be honest. But I'll go out of my way to get em. And you should, too.
You May Also Like
Barrel Society - 930 N Main St
![]()
Bar, Cocktail Bar, Whiskey Bar, Beer Bar, Pet Friendly
Skoonerz Grill & Bar - 912 N Main St
![]()
Bar & Grill, Bar, American, Pet Friendly
Paisano’s Ristorante - 1007 N Main St
![]()
Italian, Pizza, American, Vegetarian