9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sidney

“Anyone who googles places to eat in Sidney, Illinois may get one of three things. We have Casey's for pizza, the Dairy Barn for sweet treats, and the Saloon for everything in between. The staff are super attentive, make the effort to take care of the customer, and do a great job. Entertainment is always great and the food is pretty good. Prices are fair. Overall a good experience.“

“I recommend everything on the menu. Baldarotta’s is incredible. I’m Italian myself and I’ve never had any Italian food more authentic than here. I’m also a relatively picky eater and I know with certainty that I could literally order anything on the menu and be shouting its deliciousness. And it’s even delicious as carry out or as leftovers when no longer technically “fresh.” A must try and you’ll absolutely return. We come from 40 minutes away solely to dine here.“

“Amazing food! Pizza is fresh, dough doesnt make me sneeze like most pizza does. Fresh made dough each day. Owner is an amazing Gentleman and served us the most delicious and fresh tasting pizza I have had in decades. Will be eating here again. Excited hearing they might be doing Kabobs and rice and other dishes too. Can't wait to see! Happy to have eaten here today!“

“Terrible customer service. After waiting an hour and a half for our delivery we called in to check on the order and were laughed at when we told them we had a house full of kids waiting for dinner. They couldn’t even tell us when our order would be ready. Our orders are typically messed up from here anyways I don’t know why we even tried again, definitely lost a costumer tonight. Spoke with a girl on the phone, but the manager (Donny I believe) was standing next to her at the time. Matt Umbarger“

“We love Charlie’s food! Their chicken fingers, fries, meatball sub, Italian beef sandwich, salads, and thin crust pizza are some of our favorites.“

“They normally have great service but not only has my items been missing… When they brought me my pizza they had the nerve to give me a frozen pizza… That’s why I stopped tipping and why I stopped order for awhile… Smh! 8/30/22 5pm“

“Very friendly staff, was able to accommodate a large group and the food was fresh and very reasonable priced.Our large group was served very quickly.“