The service is hit or miss, and the food is not great compared to quite a few other places in the area that sell similar food. For the price you pay, the portions aren't great and the quality is mediocre. I've tried horseshoes, shepherd's pie, mac and cheese (which the portion was laughably small for $16), and almost all the appetizers in multiple trips. Horseshoes are disapponting with the small amount of cheese you get and how fast it coagulates. Also, for buffalo chicken, having buffalo on the side instead of having the chicken coated in it is a strange default option in my opinion.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Ben Shakman
Not a lot new to offer other than this is a great place for an office party if you have the flexibility to go at the beginning or the end of their lunch rush...otherwise you're SOL. They do an amazing job of producing a dozen or more horseshoes (actually, we all ordered pony shoes) and having them come out at the same time and piping hot.
Place was recommended to us by an employee at the state capital that suggested we get the horseshoe. We got the one with buffalo chicken. It was so good. They had fried green tomatoes. Those were good. The ranch is really good. Definitely would go back and try a different type of horseshoe.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica McGaughy
I'm so disappointed in what D'arcy's has become. I should have walked out when I saw how filthy the floors were, but I thought "They're very busy, and just haven't had time to sweep in the last hour". The service was poor (the attitude of the server was terrible) and the food wasn't cooked well. Bland, breading not stuck to any of the shrimp. This used to be one of my favorite places but we'll probably not go back.
Erin Masters
I ALWAYS visit this restaurant when I am in Springfield! The supreme horseshoe is sooo good! If you don't know what a horseshoe is, stop by and find out. Does not disappoint!!
Brandy
My boyfriend and I went yesterday December 12th 2025. I had my service dog with. I asked them to place us somewhere out of the way and where my service dog wouldn’t be a bother to others (people don’t like “pets” in restaurants and I understand but my service dog has to be with me 🤷♀️). They were amazing about him and the waiter even made sure my boy was comfy. Our waiter was absolutely great. Made sure we had everything needed but didn’t overly bother us or hit us with fake cheer. Was genuinely a pleasant person. The food was just chefs kiss 🤌🏼!!!! I can’t say enough about the food. The garlic aioli was simply amazing as well. Enough so that I had the waiter get me a good size to go bowl of it 😂 yes, judge me. It’s good stuff. We will for sure be returning. We come from Macomb for my many doctor appointments so this is for sure my number one to eat at for now on! Get your butts there and support an amazing place!
Great place to eat! Nice atmosphere. The coconut shrimp is excellent! Also- try the nutty Irishman!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven Sparrow
Outstanding service. Food spot on. $ is high, but worth the quality. Great team effort. We will enjoy again. Semper Fi
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Firmlyanchored
Well you can't see it but there is chicken under that pile of fries! We had to try the infamous horseshoe dish and boy was it good! and fattening... I got the Buffalo chicken. The smaller size, the pony, was only a dollar cheaper, so got for it! BTW, the white sauce is real cheddar cheese too.
Very lively and popular place. I enjoyed everything, thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jeff Shank
Excellent! Great horseshoes, friendly and efficient service all for a reasonable price. Two pony shoes, two horseshoes, an appetizer, 4 sodas and a beer was only $104 and everyone left very full and satisfied. All orders came out promptly and exactly as ordered
The service is hit or miss, and the food is not great compared to quite a few other places in the area that sell similar food. For the price you pay, the portions aren't great and the quality is mediocre. I've tried horseshoes, shepherd's pie, mac and cheese (which the portion was laughably small for $16), and almost all the appetizers in multiple trips. Horseshoes are disapponting with the small amount of cheese you get and how fast it coagulates. Also, for buffalo chicken, having buffalo on the side instead of having the chicken coated in it is a strange default option in my opinion.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Not a lot new to offer other than this is a great place for an office party if you have the flexibility to go at the beginning or the end of their lunch rush...otherwise you're SOL. They do an amazing job of producing a dozen or more horseshoes (actually, we all ordered pony shoes) and having them come out at the same time and piping hot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Horseshoe, Horseshoe Sandwich, Horse Shoe, Pony Shoe
Very good as always. Large portions!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Irish Nachos, Hamburger
Place was recommended to us by an employee at the state capital that suggested we get the horseshoe. We got the one with buffalo chicken. It was so good. They had fried green tomatoes. Those were good. The ranch is really good. Definitely would go back and try a different type of horseshoe.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm so disappointed in what D'arcy's has become. I should have walked out when I saw how filthy the floors were, but I thought "They're very busy, and just haven't had time to sweep in the last hour". The service was poor (the attitude of the server was terrible) and the food wasn't cooked well. Bland, breading not stuck to any of the shrimp. This used to be one of my favorite places but we'll probably not go back.
I ALWAYS visit this restaurant when I am in Springfield! The supreme horseshoe is sooo good! If you don't know what a horseshoe is, stop by and find out. Does not disappoint!!
My boyfriend and I went yesterday December 12th 2025. I had my service dog with. I asked them to place us somewhere out of the way and where my service dog wouldn’t be a bother to others (people don’t like “pets” in restaurants and I understand but my service dog has to be with me 🤷♀️). They were amazing about him and the waiter even made sure my boy was comfy. Our waiter was absolutely great. Made sure we had everything needed but didn’t overly bother us or hit us with fake cheer. Was genuinely a pleasant person. The food was just chefs kiss 🤌🏼!!!! I can’t say enough about the food. The garlic aioli was simply amazing as well. Enough so that I had the waiter get me a good size to go bowl of it 😂 yes, judge me. It’s good stuff. We will for sure be returning. We come from Macomb for my many doctor appointments so this is for sure my number one to eat at for now on! Get your butts there and support an amazing place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Horseshoe, D'Arcy's Loaded Fries, Horseshoe Sandwich, Shepherd's Pie, Irish Nachos, Shepard's Pie, Fries, Sandwich, Horse Shoe, Buffalo Chicken, Hamburger, Pony Shoe, Burger, Steak, Green Tomatoes, Chili, Roast, Cheesesteak, Pot Roast
Loved it! The fried green tomatoes were really good and the pork tenderloin sandwiches are delicious.
Service was awesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We loved this place! We have been to Ireland and the food here was a real tribute to their roots! So Good, I ate every bite!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shepard's Pie, Pony Shoe, Pot Roast
Restaurantji Recommends
Pony shoe was very good..
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great place to eat! Nice atmosphere. The coconut shrimp is excellent! Also- try the nutty Irishman!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Outstanding service. Food spot on. $ is high, but worth the quality. Great team effort. We will enjoy again.
Semper Fi
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Well you can't see it but there is chicken under that pile of fries! We had to try the infamous horseshoe dish and boy was it good! and fattening... I got the Buffalo chicken. The smaller size, the pony, was only a dollar cheaper, so got for it! BTW, the white sauce is real cheddar cheese too.
Very lively and popular place. I enjoyed everything, thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Excellent! Great horseshoes, friendly and efficient service all for a reasonable price.
Two pony shoes, two horseshoes, an appetizer, 4 sodas and a beer was only $104 and everyone left very full and satisfied.
All orders came out promptly and exactly as ordered
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...