Pizza By Sal

Name: Pizza By Sal
Address: 1133 Greenleaf Ave, Wilmette, Illinois, 60091, US
Telephone: (847) 920-7870
Price range: $$
Rating: 4

$$ • Pizza, Italian, American

Hours:
1133 Greenleaf Ave, Wilmette
(847) 920-7870

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Pizza By Sal

Pizza By Sal in Wilmette offers authentic New York-style pizza that has been highly sought after by many. This hidden gem has finally satisfied a 50-year-long search for a true New York pizza experience. The restaurant features a classic, thin, and delicious cheese pizza by the slice, with options like pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom. Customers can enjoy a variety of tasty options, including their spicy pepperoni pizza, which is a must-try. The eatery is clean and well-organized, providing excellent service, with prompt delivery and high-quality pizzas that hit the spot. Visitors have also enjoyed the friendly atmosphere, with some reviews mentioning the attractive staff and a welcoming environment for kids. While the pizza is enjoyable, some found it a bit salty and noted that calling it NY style is a stretch unless you're from New York. The crust strikes a good balance between crispy and soft, making it easy to fold. Prices are considered high by some, with a 16" pie with two toppings costing around $29, possibly influenced by inflation and the local area. The noise level can increase when families with kids arrive, adding to the lively atmosphere, which might benefit from sound-absorbing improvements. Parking is available on the street with some attention to parking signs. Overall, Pizza By Sal remains a favorite for pizza lovers, especially if they address minor service issues and noise concerns. The restaurant also offers other tasty options like pasta and chicken tenders, which have received positive comments.