Jimtown Pizza

CLOSED
$ •

59176 Co Rd 3, Elkhart

Jimtown Pizza Reviews

FYI: only cash or check are accepted, no credit cards.Jimtown Pizza is located in a quaint little stone front building with a cute burgundy and white awning. I ordered a 10" pizza with sausage and bacon for $10 and was told it would be ready in 10 minutes. When I picked up my pizza, it was still piping hot from the oven. The crust was shaped by hand, well done and golden brown throughout with a nice crunch to it. On top was a nice layer of sauce with flavorful sausage and pieces...read full review

I'm a pizza snob. This is damn good pizza. Lots of cheese and toppings. Sauce is a little bland but still good. I will be ordering from here again because I love supporting local businesses. It's definitely worth trying.

Before I get into my official ranking, there are some things I'd like to disclaim. I've only tried their pies twice now. Also their ice cream is a pleasant surprise potentially the second best local ice cream only following up the chief. However, this ranking is specific to the pizza NOT the ice cream per usual as I dont pretend to be an expert in ice cream.

More Reviews(55)

Ratings

View all photos
Updated on: