14 Best Bakeries in Evansville

Crumbl Cookies - Evansville Bakery • $
939 N Burkhardt Rd Suite B, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

All the Flavors of Cookies
Chocolate Dream Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Peanut Butter Cookie
Milk Chocolate Chip
Cookie Dough Cookie
Cinnamon Fry Dough
Blueberry Cookie
Pineapple Whip
Birthday Cake

“Staff are always friendly and the cookies are delish!Parking: Crumble shares the lot with a couple other businesses but I have never had a problem parking.Wheelchair accessibility: There are various accessible parking spots with a ramp up to the building.“

4.6 Superb163 Reviews
panaderia San Miguel Bakery • $
2004 Washington Ave, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Mexican Cheesecake
Pan Dulce
Conchas

“Ordered a tres leches cake for my birthday after seeing someone else post about them - it was absolutely delicious! Worth the drive from Owensboro. The owner was super friendly and just walking in everything smelled incredible. Will definitely stop in next time I’m back in town! :) thanks for making my birthday so great!“

5 Superb30 Reviews
GaylaCake Bakery • $
320 North Main Street, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

German Chocolate Cake
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Gayla Cakes
Cupcakes
Cake Pop
Cannoli

“The cake I got from Gayla was perfect. Everything my daughter asked for on her birthday cake. Handcrafted mermaid on top of the cake just like she asked for. It was also the first confetti cake I've tasted that wasn't dried out and still delicious. Gayla crushed it.“

4.9 Superb35 Reviews
Parlor Doughnuts Donut Shops • $
301 N Green River Rd, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Turtle Cheesecake Doughnut
Keto Friendly Doughnut
Strawberry Shortcake
Doughnuts and Coffee
Raspberry Pistachio
Coconut Cream Donut
Maple Bacon Donut
Breakfast Tacos
Campfire Donut
Blueberry Hill

“2 years ago, I stopped in this random town as I was driving across the country. I picked up a box of doughnuts. Now, I think about these doughnuts all the time. I compare all doughnuts to these. I've yet to come across a doughnut all my life, as good as these. Because of this place, anytime I see the word doughnut, I only desire these doughnuts. Whenever I see a doughnut shop, I look, just to see if they have doughnuts like these. Never have I found a doughnut like these. How many times have I thought about driving across the country again, just to go to this place and get these doughnuts? I do not know. What I do know is that these doughnuts were so good that no other doughnut has ever satisfied me like these. These doughnuts were so good that I don't eat doughnuts anymore because no doughnut can give me what these doughnuts have given to me. Oh, what I would do to have a box of these doughnuts baked and shipped overnight to my home so I can once again satisfy my long-lost craving for a doughnut that has the power to destroy all the doughnuts that I have ever known. These doughnuts, oh these doughnuts, are like a prized diamond, a rare gem hidden. Closely held and tucked away from the rest of the world. So delightful, so sweet, so flaky and lovely are these doughnuts. So much so that if I had to give up all other doughnuts for the rest of my life just for a taste of one of these doughnuts as it comes out from the oven, I would. Sometimes, these doughnuts pop into my mind at random times, bringing me back to a moment of pure bliss. No one goes to a doughnuts shop to be dissatisfied. And no one ever expects to be so satisfied that time itself stops for you to sit with yourself and be at peace with the choices you just made. for these doughnuts, so absolutely completely fulfill the very need that caused you to go into a doughnut shop in the first place.“

4.6 Superb68 Reviews
Be Happy Pie Company, LLC Bakery • $$
2818 Mt Vernon Ave B, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chess
Key Lime Pie
Cherry Crumb
Cherry Pie
Pie Bites

“The best of the best truly. The quality of products and the customer service you experience is unmatched. All of their amazing products are also packaged very well eliminating the stress of transporting your freshly purchased treats. Owned and operated by amazing local people. Will continue to recommend this business. Glad to have now 2 locations in our community.“

4.8 Superb34 Reviews
North Main Annex Gourmet Catering & Deli Deli • $
701 N Main St, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Vegetable Salad

“Chef Jones was a delight to work with. She was flexible, helpful with suggestions and quick to respond to questions. The food was delivered right on time. Hot food was steaming hot, and salad was perfectly chilled. All the food was fresh, beautifully presented and delicious. She thought of everything and every detail was perfect. I highly recommend! It was a perfect way to celebrate our granddaughter's baptism.“

4.9 Superb24 Reviews
Cookies & Cupcake by Design Bakery • $$
419 Metro Ave, Evansville

“Cookies by design donated 60 cookies to deaconess gateway observation unit. Cookies were so good. Staff at the store was kind and friendly! Love this local cookie place! The nurses and techs were very appreciative. Thanks cookies by design!“

5 Superb16 Reviews
Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company Bakery •
102 SE 4th St, Evansville

“Cute little shop. The chocolate chess bar was so goood definitely my favorite from there out of what I tried. Also tried cookie and brownie bars. The brownie bars were a bit on the too sweet for me personally but not gonna change the score on that people like diff amounts of sugar. If someone likes really sweet they can go for that lol. Just a suggestion though. But omg the chocolate chess bar was goood repeat. Fair amount of sweet and flavor. First time having one. The cookies were a good level of texture. Thank you.“

4.8 Superb21 Reviews
Piece of Cake Bakery • $
210 Main St, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Birthday Cake with Chocolate Buttercream Frosting
Baby Shower Cakes
Six Pack Cupcakes
6 Pack Cupcakes
Strawberry Cake
Wedding Cake
Doggie Bag

“Needed a last minute custom cake for my daughter's 15th birthday. I called several bakeries in the area and they were less than helpful. Piece of cake was awesome! They were so nice and understood my dilemma. They made the most beautiful Taylor Swift fifteen cake for my Swiftie. And the taste was amazing. The cupcakes were amazing as well! I made little Toppers for them. Their prices are very good too. I will make sure to order more in advance next time, I promise. But thank you so much for the wonderful cake!“

4.5 Superb45 Reviews
Granola Jar Caterers • $
1033 Mt Pleasant Road # J, Evansville

“Delicious food healthy the cookies are really good if you try to eat healthy here is not bad to go here their sandwiches are really good for you they have grilled cheeses which taste really good so honestly I recommend coming here do you like to support small businesses so we tried out this place and we come every now and then so I recommend it.“

4.7 Superb15 Reviews
Nothing Bundt Cakes Bakery • $
6436 E Florida St Suite 100, Evansville

“So close of tasting of Bundt. There was crackling in my ear. I walked in and two women were checking out. They both turned around and glared me up and down. I felt the tension. They took fifteen minutes picking out what flavor of Bundt they wanted. I got red velvet so creamy. No forks or cutlery in the area. They charged for cutlery should be given. What is the Alexa stop after I ate there was in my ear“

4.1 Good13 Reviews
The Granola Jar East Cafe • $$
5600 E Virginia St, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Pimento Cheese

“A fantastic small business to support! Delicious variety of Chicken Salads, my favorite is the Honey Almond Chicken Salad, followed by the Jalapeño Macaroni and Cheese…yum! We always choose the Three’s Company….a choice of 3 salads and bread/butter.Highly recommended“

4.1 Good12 Reviews
Donut Bank Donut Shops • $
1200 Lincoln Ave, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Bagel

“Since my last post (on bottom) Ben and Alex have gone above and beyond to make things right. They have apologized and more than Reimbursed me for my coffee. I may have to wait for blue berry coffee to come back, but I'm ready for highlandergrog. Thank you guys again.Went through the drive through this morning, ordered a HOT coffee, went to grab it from the drive through worker and the lid was not on all the way, and it spilled all over me and my car. The worker stood there and stared. I had to ask for napkins, my coffee wasn't replaced..she just asked what color lid was on my cup and gave me a different lid. My hand was very burnt along with my leg, not to mention over half of my coffee was gone. Won't be going back.“

4 Good21 Reviews
Donut Bank Donut Shops • $
1950 Washington Ave, Evansville

“Exceptional Customer Service at Donut Bank! After submitting a complaint through the website, I quickly got a thoughtful response from the Vice President with a proactive resolution. Donut Bank's swift action truly made an impact on me. I'm genuinely impressed by their dedication to excellence. They took my complaint and turned it into an opportunity to surprise and delight. With service like this, they've certainly earned a loyal customer in me! Thank you, Donut Bank, for your outstanding service!“

4 Good21 Reviews
Loading...
map Map