27 Best Ice Cream Shops in Evansville

“Great ice cream and great service. I highly recommend them.“

“The eastside location is so good when it comes to making your cookies look like they should in the advertisements and the workers always make sure to show you the cookies/cakes so you don't walk away unsatisfied, the workers are also super friendly at this location and I can genuinely tell that they love making making customers smile when they hang them the pink box! 10/10!“

“Pizza side is great. we found this gem a few weekends back. Unfortunately, the "adult swim" portion was lacking in knowledge and communication skills when we tried to take a dive and check out that section. (3/21/26) Yes, I was greeted. When I said oh only a few minutes left (literally 2 minutes.) I said "we would like to sit over on this side." I proceed to ask if my Service Dog in training could join us. would it be an issue to have lay under my feet? Back to I really do try to avoid making a scene or get something out of it. So, here's what needs to be addressed. I only have to answer two questions. Yes, I do have a service animal in training. Yes, he does provide for my medical needs. You do not need to know those needs. ADA and State Laws and rules state the following: He does not need to have a vest on or otherwise marked He doesn't need to show his training. If he misbehaves: barks other than to alert or getting in the way of staff we can be asked to leave you. In Indiana service animals in training are treated as if they are are a a service animal. These are things that are often overlooked in customer service and hospitality industries training. I seen it many times. I have forgotten to train new hires before when I worked in customer service and hospitality myself. I personally did not appreciate the young lady at the bar area. While she said "No" and I didn't correct her. It wouldn't have been a productive conversation. Once my other half order food we went to find our seat. Same girl.... "Oh no you can't sit here" I don't know if she was having a bad day or that's how she is, but I would have suspected when gestured to the guy at the register ordering an me asking about my SDiT... that might have clued her in. The last time we went there wasn't a problem??? So can we a sign on what's up on how the "adult swim" area operating 'today' sign at the front table?“

“After a long morning baking and then delivering pies for Pi Day, We stopped in for a couple slices and a quick break. The service and pizza was perfect! The pistachio slice is absolutely perfection! 🍒❤️🍒“

“The soft serve is delicious. Their portions are huge so you get good value for your money. My daughter and I split the two cheeseburger meal and we were full. I love this place. The workers are friendly and helpful. The food was made fresh. Highly recommend!“

“this restaurant has amazing quality food but for the price is crazy i went here thinming it would be cheap like mc donalds but NO the price for large onion rings costed me almost over 8 BUCKS thats crazy. the price needs to be lowerd im coming for the food not for the looks of the place so please get it better for the prices cause im not going back if it keeps costing like its a 5 star restaurant.“

“It was pretty good!! My mango slushi thing kinda threw me off guard but its was pretty good 7/10 amd my fiances oreo shake was delicious 9/10 and my birria taco was yummy!! Hint of cinnamon and yummy cilantro with fresh onions it was yummy!! 9/10!! Definitely a cute little place in evansville IN“

“Just came from the Diamond Ave. Store, the salads and sandwiches are all homemade with fresh baked breads. Excellent ! However the best part was having Becky and Jessica who work there fix the food correctly. They fixed everything as if it was there own. What more could someone ask for : great service , good food , and fair prices, five stars to this Lics crew.“

“This place has the coolest vibe and atmosphere! Also the best fish n chips at Bodine’s Newsstand. Can’t wait to get back and enjoy them again! There is a nice outdoor eating area with casual, comfortable seating and patio heaters for when it’s cool out.“

“My granddaughter loves the frozen yogurt“

“All around delicious, the cookies or brownies are too die for. Whether you want classic size or deluxe they got you covered. A twist and one of their many ice cream flavors on top or make a sandwich. You will not be disappointed going here. And they're open super late“

“We live in Columbus Indiana and go to the local Culvers a few times a month but we were in Evansville Saturday night and as we were heading back to Columbus we hadn't eaten so we drove through this Culvers. Everything was pretty decent except there was an abundance of salt on my onion rings. Who puts salt on onion rings??? I had to scrape it off just to eat them. Is it just me or has fast food service gone in the toilet the last few years?“

“Just came from the Diamond Ave. Store, the salads and sandwiches are all homemade with fresh baked breads. Excellent ! However the best part was having Becky and Jessica who work there fix the food correctly. They fixed everything as if it was there own. What more could someone ask for : great service , good food , and fair prices, five stars to this Lics crew.“

“it was very good we had a great time“

“Just came from the Diamond Ave. Store, the salads and sandwiches are all homemade with fresh baked breads. Excellent ! However the best part was having Becky and Jessica who work there fix the food correctly. They fixed everything as if it was there own. What more could someone ask for : great service , good food , and fair prices, five stars to this Lics crew.“

“Food was as always, great. The biggest problem is the way the place is laid out. The entrances are on both sides of the building which are at the ends of the space in front of the counter. The condiment station is precariously set at one end and becomes an area of congestion and hazards. There's not a big enough place to put more than one tray. Which is already a task to carry after the cashier / server / hostess has loaded it down with all of the food and mainly the unwieldy soft drinks. Then there's the elevated dining area that has chrome separation bars, which add to the awkward layout of the dining area.“

“the service was Epic and I was so excited to try this type of ice cream for the first time. My kid chose to get the strawberry ice creme and it Divine as can be. we originally bought two of the bobo teas....and they were so good before we left the mall we decided to go back and grab two more drinks and got the ice cream we spoke of above. I think the best part was the two workers and how kind they were, dedicated to explaining to us everything we asked questions about and how they went over the top to make it healthy...was even better. 10/10 we will absolutely be returning for more“

“I recently stopped by Cold Stone Creamery and tried something called the Mud Pie Mojo, and I’ve got to say—it was seriously good. The ice cream had big, chunky pieces of cookies and nuts mixed all throughout it, and whatever else they add in there just works perfectly together. Every bite had a nice crunch and tons of flavor. 🍪🥜🍨
One of the coolest parts is watching them actually make your order on the frozen stone. They scoop the ice cream out, then start chopping, crunching, and folding all the mix-ins right into it. It’s kind of fun to watch and makes the whole experience feel fresh and custom.
The atmosphere inside is great too. You can see all the toppings and all the different ice cream flavors lined up. Honestly, it almost overloads your brain trying to decide what to get because there are so many options. In the end I just went with the Mud Pie from one of their menu suggestion boards (the little sticker menu), and I’m glad I did.
Overall, I’m really impressed. If you’ve got a sweet tooth like I do, this place is a must-try. I’d honestly take Cold Stone Creamery over Dairy Queen any day. 🍦🔥“

“The employees working today deserve a raise. They gave us excellent service. When I asked for a side of pickles with my chicken, they asked how much. Of course, I said “a whole lot!” They gave me a surplus of pickles with a smile. This was my first time at Freddys and there is no doubt I will be back“

“Just came from the Diamond Ave. Store, the salads and sandwiches are all homemade with fresh baked breads. Excellent ! However the best part was having Becky and Jessica who work there fix the food correctly. They fixed everything as if it was there own. What more could someone ask for : great service , good food , and fair prices, five stars to this Lics crew.“

“Just came from the Diamond Ave. Store, the salads and sandwiches are all homemade with fresh baked breads. Excellent ! However the best part was having Becky and Jessica who work there fix the food correctly. They fixed everything as if it was there own. What more could someone ask for : great service , good food , and fair prices, five stars to this Lics crew.“

“We live in Columbus Indiana and go to the local Culvers a few times a month but we were in Evansville Saturday night and as we were heading back to Columbus we hadn't eaten so we drove through this Culvers. Everything was pretty decent except there was an abundance of salt on my onion rings. Who puts salt on onion rings??? I had to scrape it off just to eat them. Is it just me or has fast food service gone in the toilet the last few years?“

“i don’t know her name but it’s thing young girl with purple hair, she is always working and she is so so polite and sweet and works so hard! i think she is the only respectful one out of all the workers and definitely makes a different much love to her 💖💖“

“Tried Cookie Plug today & wow. the cookies are wonderful & Marcie (I think that was her name) was so friendly & helpful. Forget the other cookie places because this is the BEST“

“DQ is great! I visit there often!“

“Average enough Sonic, but for the love of God, label if a stall is to go only on BOTH sides of the panel. I don’t want to have to pull into multiple stalls until I find one that isn’t a mobile only stall. While we are on that subject, there is NO reason to have 6 stalls for mobile orders.“

“This DQ just feels different when you are there. Service and food quality is consistently good, which is why I drive across town and past two dozen or more restaurants to dine here. Well, and the sundaes, Blizzards, and other ice cream treats keep me coming back, to!“