50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Evansville

“Amazing food and wonderful owner! We have enjoyed conversations every time we have gone there!“

“Great! Fresh ingredients, crispy thin crust, and it's always hot when they deliver! AAA+“

“Heard it was the best in town and by god they weren’t kidding! Simple menu great food and some of the friendliest people you’ll ever encounter! Highly recommended the cheesy bread too! The price beats everywhere else also with the generous toppings!“

“Stopped here by chance on our way back to TN from St. Louis. So glad we did! Our server was amazing. The food was delicious and portions were nice sized and was freshly made to order! Definitely making this a must stop on our way back in the future!“

“It's fire. Best tasting food I've ever had. The service is magnificent and the atmosphere is amazing. I really loved it!“

“Their Stromboli is great. I have been a Pizza King Stromboli guy for years. Lately, the new building on the west side Stroms have tasted like heartbreak and disappointment. That is NOT the case here. This former Pizza King guy now has a new place to get Strombolis. You should try them too.“

“I rarely write reviews, shame on me, but I had to share this. I went to Casey’s Dugout last night to pick up a to-go order for my wife. After I ordered, Casey actually came up to personally thank me for coming in. Then, when the young woman brought out the food, she mentioned they had thrown in some cheese bread on the house. I know how tight margins are for local businesses right now, so that kind of generosity really stands out. It was so, so kind. You have a customer for life!“

“I am amazed at how well the staff handled food allergies! They took all precautions for a gluten allergy (celiac). The pizza tasted so good! I would 10/10 recommend!“

“Azzip pizza was a hit last night for dinner. The kids loved it! MARCH CRABNESS- Crab Rangoon Mix, Mozzarella, Sweet Soy Sauce, Thai Chili Sauce & Crispy Wontons E'VIL PIG / WESTSIDER PIZZA- Sweet 'n Sassy BBQ Sauce, Mozzarella, Slow Smoked Pork, Red Onion, Grippos, Ski Reduction Definitely would recommend. 10/10“

“This is some good pizza....“

“Great pizza, we usually opt for combo or pepperoni and awesome smiling faces when you walk through the door. They always do a great job.“

“So I’m out sourcing product for catering/food truck items and decided to give The Slice Evansville a try today. I’ve been trying to get there for a year or 2 now but just haven’t had the opportunity yet. Folks this place is GREAT! Probably the best pizza I’ve had in awhile. I didn’t know what to get so I just had the guy working choose mine from their “buffet”. The way that works is— you choose for slices (NY style so they’re HUGE) and they make the first 2 and then you let them know when you want the other 2 plus it comes with a drink all for only $14.50 INCLUDING tax!! The first 2 they chose for me was a “Stromboli” slice and the “Mr. Potato Head” then the other 2 were the “Ranch” slice and the “Gyro” slice. All 4 slices were beyond good and I also had some Tiramisu which was excellent! If you’re down in Evansville you should try this place out!“

“I was there early today. placed an order at the carry out section. I am the one that screwed up my own order, they made it right for me anyway. The young lady that waited on me and her manager were absolutely awesome. I hope they both know how much I appreciated their attitudes concerning my mistake.“

“FANTASTIC New York style Pizza!! I love thin crust that isn't like a cracker and has flavor. Top tier toppings. Reheats beautifully. The slice of the day options are fire!!“

“We absolutely love Spankey’s pizza and salads. Service is always amazing 🍕🥗 😋“

“First time to order and it's the best pizza in town. I've been here 4 years and not sure how I missed this place. Delivery was faster than the time they said, the pizza was huge and hot, the drinks were ice cold. Friendly delivery driver. This is my new go-to place for pizza.“

“We absolutely love Spankey’s pizza and salads. Service is always amazing 🍕🥗 😋“

“Deerhead never disappoints.“

“Awesome vibe and hometown community feel. Food is the absolute best! Good people and great entertainment. Don’t miss this place!“

“Y little girl always has such a wonderful time visiting Chuck E Cheese! Chuck E comes out every hour and dances with the kids and stays for pictures. The employees are great at customer service and keeping the kids happy.“

“The Pizza Oven is the perfect hole-in-the-wall joint that makes excellent pies with the tastiest toppings and a perfect crust. Their strombolis are top-notch. This is by far the best pizza in Evansville. You just can't go wrong at The Pizza Oven!“

“Visited Turoni’s today while visiting from Texas and I have to say we received the best service from Haley and the food was awesome!! The Stromboli was delicious and such a hefty portion for the lunch special! We also order the buffalo chicken pizza which was delicious! The entire experience was on point and so glad we picked this place to eat today!! thank yall!!“

“Miranda was absolutely amazing. Absolutely recommend and ask for her.“

“My husband took our kids and his mom to Rounders Too for lunch Friday and had the best experience. Our son uses a speech device primarily to communicate and was super interested in the iPad the waitress was using to order. She asked him what he wanted and then offered him to order everyone's food and drink using the iPad himself. He was extremely happy to be able to do that, as most people don't direct questions to him due to him being mostly non-verbal. We appreciate her kindness in giving him that opportunity and making his day. When they left, our daughter had left behind a stuffed animal and the waitress came out to the car to make sure they didn't leave without it. Eating out can be a very stressful situation for us in general, but I think we have found a new lunch spot!“

“Best stroms and hot ham and cheese around.“

“great service pizza is awesome got to try finger bread the cheese on the pizza is so thick pick up slice the cheese comes right with it the way it should“

“Our first experience with DiMaggio's was a take and bake we ordered for our son's archery team fundraiser- let me tell you! The pizza was so good! 5 people completely demolished 3 pizzas quickly. We agreed that we need at least 4 pizzas next time. We live on the east side but will definitely make the drive to visit the restaurant. Thanks DiMaggio's for helping to get Central's archery team to nationals!“

“I have thoroughly enjoyed this Northside Evansville gem. We go to trivia on Wednesdays, start at 7pm CST, and staff are excellent about posting on FB any changes.

The finger bread is amazing for an app.
Their buffalo chicken and bbq chicken pizzas are to notch.

Wings are properly glazed so they aren't dripping.

They have an often overlooked salad bar that is decent too!

Soda prices are $2.50 (as of this post).

Their staff is friendly, fun and professional.

Let Twisted Tomato become your next favorite pizza place!“

“Build your own delicious pizza in a clean restaurant! The “no name cake” takes me back to the foil wrapped chocolate cakes of my childhood-delicious! The name brand ones that aren’t wrapped in foil any longer just aren’t as good as they used to be.“

“Kiki, Andrew and the staff at kipplees outdid themselves today in service and friendship. Had my husband's retirement party today and they did an outstanding job. I highly recommend them for parties and gatherings. Thanks again Kipplees“

“Pizza side is great. we found this gem a few weekends back. Unfortunately, the "adult swim" portion was lacking in knowledge and communication skills when we tried to take a dive and check out that section. (3/21/26) Yes, I was greeted. When I said oh only a few minutes left (literally 2 minutes.) I said "we would like to sit over on this side." I proceed to ask if my Service Dog in training could join us. would it be an issue to have lay under my feet? Back to I really do try to avoid making a scene or get something out of it. So, here's what needs to be addressed. I only have to answer two questions. Yes, I do have a service animal in training. Yes, he does provide for my medical needs. You do not need to know those needs. ADA and State Laws and rules state the following: He does not need to have a vest on or otherwise marked He doesn't need to show his training. If he misbehaves: barks other than to alert or getting in the way of staff we can be asked to leave you. In Indiana service animals in training are treated as if they are are a a service animal. These are things that are often overlooked in customer service and hospitality industries training. I seen it many times. I have forgotten to train new hires before when I worked in customer service and hospitality myself. I personally did not appreciate the young lady at the bar area. While she said "No" and I didn't correct her. It wouldn't have been a productive conversation. Once my other half order food we went to find our seat. Same girl.... "Oh no you can't sit here" I don't know if she was having a bad day or that's how she is, but I would have suspected when gestured to the guy at the register ordering an me asking about my SDiT... that might have clued her in. The last time we went there wasn't a problem??? So can we a sign on what's up on how the "adult swim" area operating 'today' sign at the front table?“

“VERY good food. Flavors and portions on point, reasonable prices. Only negative thing is it’s so quiet and music was way too low. Kinda depressing. Will come back though when we’re in really, really good moods! 🤪“

“I was born and raised here until I was 18, and every time I come home to visit, Fazoli’s is my 1st stop. Everything is always delicious, hot and the staff are top tier. They are always so sweet and go above and beyond. Yolanda was our fave today. Such a sweet soul. Thank you for decades of happiness 💜“

“Great“

“The big Don sub is the best in the United States!“

“I am surprised to hear other locations in Evansville have closed. Lack of sales? I’m fairly new to the area from the west coast. Papa Murphy’s is very popular there. Tuesdays are ANY large pizza for $10!! Ten dollars for delicious food. Take & bake here is fresh and delicious. All you have to do it preheat your oven, remove the plastic wrap and bake it for the time noted. These are the best take and bake pizzas. I’m glad they are convenient to my house. Keep it goin Papa Murphy’s!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“😤😤Love the food!!!! but every time I try to order delivery it’s turned off. So I end up ordering elsewhere. I haven’t caught it available yet 😞“

“I love the different variety of pizza and desserts. I love the fact that its a buffet style and you can eat how much you want and also pick whatever kind of pizza they have up there. It's hot and its convenient. Cici's is my favorite pizza place! My absolute favorite is there spinach pizza! 😋“

“Service and food was great. Great little place to eat.“

“My wife and I ate here for the first time today. I ate the fried shrimp and it was amazing. She ate the Monte Cristo and loved it! Our server was Destiny and she was the best! She even made my wife a special drink she asked for. Definitely will return!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“We had a great experience tonight! Our server Kelsey was exceptional. Not only did she make great recommendations on food but beer choices as well. She was able to keep up with my joking husband . Lol The food came out hot, fresh and flavorful. We were there about 30 mins from closing so that makes the fact that the food was still fresh even better. Definitely a favorite!“

“I truly appreciate the staff for being so generous and allowing me to leave my loved ones vehicle there when he got lost and allowing me to come back and pick it up with my sister! Thank y'all so much and hopefully I will find my way back there soon, to try out y'all's pizza 🍕“

“Placed my order online, and it was ready in 20 minutes, despite the place being busy. The pizzas were hot and fresh, made exactly how we asked them to be. This is the 3rd time we've ordered from this location and 3/3 they were better than any little caesars experiences we've had.“

“I happen to meet Ed, and Sara. The first time my wife and I were looking for lunch. I was a firm believer that Turonis was the best pizza around. With Steve's Una in second place. Ed informed me I have to try their pizza, and I was at the right place. Keep in mind I was 1.60 short as well. Sara said it wasn't a problem I assured her if it was as good as Ed said she will be getting the 1.60 back soon enough. When I tell you they are great people and a awesome couple. I mean it when I say they don't come no better. I took a first bite and I couldn't stop eating the pizza. Slice after slice I thought it wasn't possible. The pizza took over the number one spot, and it wasn't even a close call. The environment is family friendly. Like I said earlier the people don't get no better. If I could give more stars I would. Sara went above and beyond for me, and I have to admit Ed you were right. I was at the right place. You will think I'm family as much as you'll see me. Awesome Food, Awesome People, and Awesome Environment... No better place in the tri-state area.“