17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Henderson

“we wanted to get out of Evansville and try something new this place has a great view of the Ohio River outdoor seating also available the pizza was great we also tried the cheesy bacon fries great service great atmosphere can't wait to come back and try the strombolis and onion rings!!“

“the best pizza in the tri-state“

“Tiny shop that belies how amazing the deep dish pizza is. Nothing like it in the tri-state. If you're tired of cracker-crust pizza everywhere else, Rick's is gonna change your life. I'm talking pizza measured in POUNDS, not slices.“

“Very good little restaurant with friendly service and delicious sushi“

“boneless wings were fantastic great atmosphere for the UK game“

“Picked up a large meat lovers pizza on our way home. This is the best we’ve had in a long time. Will be trying the Stromboli next.“

“Kelsey G's has been around since I was a kid and has always been a solid, reliable choice in town. It’s one of those places that’s just consistently there when you want something good without overthinking it.

The strombolis are easily the highlight—loaded, flavorful, and always hit the spot. They’re also one of the few places around here where you can still get a taco pizza, which is a big plus and something you don’t see everywhere anymore.

It’s family-owned and operated, and that local feel comes through. You can tell they care about their food and the people coming in. I’m usually not a fan of cracker crust pizza, but they actually do it pretty well here—crispy without being too dry or overdone.

Overall, it’s not trying to be anything fancy, but it doesn’t need to be. It’s just a dependable local spot that’s been doing its thing for years, and it’s definitely worth stopping in if you’re in Henderson.“

“food very delicious always on point“

“the people are so friendly..Great atmosphere. .Great deals..“

“the people are so friendly..Great atmosphere. .Great deals..“

“the people are so friendly..Great atmosphere. .Great deals..“

“There was a point when Pony Express had really fallen off…they were rarely open, usually pickup only, barely answered the phone, etc. But the new owners are KILLING IT. Same great recipes, but somehow made better. Great service, too!“

“This is one of my favorite local establishments. Wood-fired pizza is superb, but I'm personally a fan of pan crust so that is always my go to. Wings are top-tier and the house rub is unmatched. I've literally had every single menu item and you can't go wrong with any choice. It has a family-friendly vibe where kids are always welcome to be kids.

For any first timers, my advice for the perfect order to get the full Firedome experience would be a wood-fired pizza with your choice of toppings, house rub bone-in wings, an order of fried banana peppers as an appetizer and a cookie dome for dessert.“

“We usually like Fazolis, however we stopped yesterday to try the subs. Me and my husband got the Italian sub. $10 a piece. We got home and tried to eat them but they were so spicy we couldn’t. We both like spicy. But for one it didn’t say it was spicy, and for 2 it was entirely too spicy. They should advertise if it’s spicy! My daughter got the club, and it only had meat and cheese on it. That’s not what the picture showed. Waste of $30!!! Do better!!!“

“I just want to leave a comment about my latest experience. I attempted to place an order late on a Monday night and circumstances happened that were out of the managers control. She told me to call the next night and she would make everything right, which she did. She was waiting for my call and took care of everything. Thank you Hope for being so on top of everything and being so professional.“

“The pizza was hot and fresh. It was absolutely delicious!! I'll definitely be going back for more!! The workers where fast to answer any questions I had.“