11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newburgh

Azzip Pizza Pizza • $
8850 High Pointe Dr, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Custom Hot Little Clucker
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chicken on the Beach
Old World Pepperoni
Banana Pepper Rings
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Sriracha Sticks
Mr Potato Head
Garlic Butter
Azzip Pesto

“Awesome pizza! Great price, fast and friendly service.“

4.8 Superb83 Reviews
Fat Boy's Pizza Newburgh Pizza • $
10722 IN-662, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Fat Boy Sandwich with Mozzarella Cheese
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Five Topping Pizza
Stromboli Sandwich
Meat Lovers Pizza
One Topping Pizza
Thin Crust Pizza
Pepperoncini's
Supreme Pizza

“One of best pizzas I have ever had! So sad that we don’t have this near Nashville but nice to have when we visit family in Newburgh.“

4.6 Superb69 Reviews
Godfather's Pizza Express Pizza • $
7288 Oak Grove Rd, Newburgh

“Ordered Godfathers pizza over the phone and when I got to the store they had part of the order wrong. It was all good though because Makayla, Jason, the manager and the rest of the staff were amazing. They rectified the situation quickly and were apologetic the whole time. I wasn't upset about the miscommunication at all but this crew is really on top of things. Great customer service all around. I love coming here and I'll definitely be back.“

4.7 Superb12 Reviews
Archie & Clyde's Pizza • $
8309 Bell Oaks Dr, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Classic Double Cheeseburger with Bacon
Salad with Grilled Chicken
Pull-A-Part Cheesy Bread
9 - Hawaiian Special
Meat Mountain Pizza
Texas Cheeseburger
Kids Chicken Strips
Country Fried Steak
Fried Mushrooms
GF - The Works

“We picked up Italian salad-large, 3 pizzas, 2 orders of cheese pull a part bread. Everything was delicious! Thanks for making our evening enjoyable!“

3.9 Good74 Reviews
Godfather's Pizza Express Pizza Takeaway • $$
7777 W State Route 66, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger
Classic Combo
5 Superb2 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
854 State St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Garlic Bread

“Let me start off by saying I've never had any bad experiences with this location. The last time I ordered there was a mix up and I was delivered the wrong pizza, stuff happens, the pizza was hot so that was no issue at all. I absolutely hate complaining or saying negative things like this but tonight I ordered a pizza for me and my son because it's friday, I'm a working mom and I'm feeling lazy. The pizza was hot and delicious, I ordered a cheese with extra pineapple. It's my sons favorite and I don't really like meat so it's a nice texture change. I bit into whatever this was. I kept chewing but it wasn't breaking apart. I spit it out and looked at it and i was like oh this is just cheese...but why is it so chewy??? I'm a little worried now and hope this wasn't something not meant for consumption. 4 stars because I don't want to be a j*** about this. Things happen, but i am a little concerned as I can't identify what this is.“

3.9 Good31 Reviews
Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery Pizza • $$
8011 Bell Oaks Dr, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Stromboli Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: No Takeout: Yes
Hawaiian Delight Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Lots a Meat Pizza
House Special
Sausage Pizza
Popper Toast
Bruschetta

“we went into Turoni's tonight for my birthday and our server Cameron was AMAZING! My 6 year old was very excited to make a big deal over me and my special day. Cameron went above and beyond. He listened attentively to an excited little boy who kept whispering in his ear ideas on how to surprise me. Even with other tables to attend to, he remained polite and never rushed him. It's hard to put into words how exceptional the service truly was on this particular night especially to a 6 year old little boy and his family.“

3.7 Good56 Reviews
Prime Sports Bar & Grill • $
4944 Old State Rte 261, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Dozen Fresh-Baked Cookies
Lunch - Caesar Wrap
Pizza Bombs
Pepperoni

“"My wife and I dined at Prime Sports last night, and it was a fantastic experience. The food was absolutely delicious. I had the stromboli, which was perfectly baked and packed with flavor. My wife tried the pizza bites, and she couldn't stop raving about them. The service was top-notch, with attentive and friendly staff making sure we had everything we needed. Overall, it was an excellent dining experience, and we highly recommend Prime Sportsto anyone looking for great food and excellent service."“

4.5 Superb35 Reviews
Pizza King | Evansville, IN Pizza • $
7777 IN-66, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza Large-16
Mozzarella Bread Sticks
King Royal Potato Skins
Frozen Strombolis to Go
Diced Pepperoni Pizza
Original Stromboli
Stromboli Deluxe
Hot Stromboli
Cheesy Bread
Cheese Pizza

“Strombolis were good as always. We called order in and then dined in when we got there. Still had to wait for food and when done our order was wrong. 1 sandwich was made incorrectly. No big deal. We didn't have time for new one so we just got refunded for the sandwich. Dining room was kinda warm that particular day but still enjoyed the food and will definitely be back. Wish they could have a restaurant like pizza king where we are from. Best strombolis around!!

Parking: Huge parking lot. Great for large vehicles/trailers or heavy equipment“

3.4 Good51 Reviews
Burgh House & Family Entertainment Center Pizza • $$
8099 Bell Oaks Dr, Newburgh

“awesome place and so much to do. staff was friendly, games all worked, can even get a drink and carry it around while you play. place was very clean also. there's even movies and bowling on site. Great place, would definitely go back. we grabbed food while we were there and the pizza and garlic cheese bread were really good.“

4 Good99 Reviews
Cricket's Bar & Grill • $
518 W Main St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Jumbo Pretzel with Nacho Cheese
Breaded Corn Nuggets
Miller Lite Fishbowl
Mozzarella Sticks
Jalapeno Poppers
Sausage Pizza
Cheese Burger
Deluxe Pizza
Meat Pizza

“After saying for 2 years "we need to try this place" we finally did and the ONLY regret I have is not trying it sooner. For any of my friends from Mount Vernon who remember Dean's Pizza, the taco pizza here is identical. Not similar. Not close. Literally identical in the best way. I have craved this since it burned down in 2016? 17? Years!!! So I'll also be letting all my MV friends and family know this as well. We also got a hot ham and cheese (fire) and samplers (equally fire). 2 12 inch pizzas, a full sandwich, a combo sampler and a cheesy bread plus extra cheese sauces came out to just a few cents under 75 bucks for a family of 6. Price is good, food is good, 40 minutes for fresh delicious food on a Friday was perfect. Can't wait to continue doing business here.“

4 Good28 Reviews

You May Also Like