First time stopping in at Rusty’s, and it was great! The ice cream is as good as any, and the venue itself is a great homage to bygone eras of ice cream parlors and the like. Would definitely come back again and again!
Helen Atkinson
Was celebrating my birthday and went with a friend for the first time. Both of us went to middle school and or High School in the 80s. I was definitely in the first MTV generation. I just heard of this place last week and thought it would be fun. It really was lots of fun! I had Cherry ice cream but I don't think that was the official name. What I liked the most about the place was the 80s memorabilia and 80s music. I will bring quarters the next time for the Jukebox. Rusty joined us in an informal game of 80s trivial pursuit. He was fun and friendly. I would recommend this place to anyone who is most formative years were in the 80s or anyone who just loves 80s pop culture.
Adam Hamel
You, too, can look like me. Ka-chow.
Kayla Rupright
Great selection and service! The decor is awesome too! Be sure to check out the bathrooms too!
Sharon Maddox
The ice cream is nothing to write home about its ice cream. The place itself is very nostalgic and definitely wouldn't take any young (toddler age) children to this place they have tons of candy down within reach, and board games. The employees acted like they didn't even want to be there. I absolutely loved the ice cream spoons they changed colors and I kept mine. Lol the shop itself is cool looking, and definitely brings me back, but they need to update the ice cream, put the candy behind a case and maybe even the games even if it's where older people can access them. Then this place would definitely deserve a 5 star rating that they almost have. The owner is on the right track though. The prices are also higher than most shops in the area. I would also do some research on the local prices.
Dietary restrictions: Has plenty of sugar free options
Kid-friendliness: Not unless you want to pay for a bunch of candy that is on an open shelf.
Stepping into Rusty’s is like stepping into a time capsule from the 1980s. The moment you walk through the door, you’re enveloped in a world that feels like a retro movie set. The color palette bold, vibrant neons and pastels, immediately transports you back in time, while the walls are adorned with classic movie posters from iconic '80s films. Overhead, a TV plays old-school music videos, filling the air with the tunes that defined a generation. It’s more than just an ice cream shop; it’s an immersive trip back to a time when everything seemed larger than life, nostalgic in the best possible way.
I decided to keep it simple with my order, opting for a scoop of chocolate ice cream topped with pecans. Sometimes, simplicity is where the magic lies, and this was no exception. The ice cream was perfectly creamy, rich with a sweet chocolate flavor that wasn't too overpowering. Each bite had a velvety smoothness that melted in my mouth, but what truly elevated it was the pecans. Their salty, slightly crunchy texture balanced the sweetness of the chocolate in the most delightful way, creating a harmonious blend of flavors. It was like a dance of salty and sweet on my palate, the perfect pairing.
Rusty’s isn’t just about the ice cream; it’s about the feeling it creates. It’s a place where the past feels present, where you can indulge in something sweet while being surrounded by the vibrant energy of the '80s. It’s a spot that not only satisfies your sweet tooth but also gives you a sense of joy and nostalgia with every scoop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Magnum, Sundaes, Smurfalicious with Added Marshmallow Sauce, Ninja Turtle Sundae, Chocolate Chunk Truffle Shuffle, Cheesecake, Black Raspberry, Pretty in Pink Strawberry Cheesecake in a Waffle Cone, Coconut, Pretty in Pink Sundae, Bananarama Split Sundae, Oreo Speedwagon Sundae, Mint Chip, Dairy Free Mint Chip with Fudge and Oreo, Shakes & Floats
Mike Weingartner
Love this place. The retro 80s atmosphere is awesome and the ice cream is the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandon Trout
This place is a cool vibe and the ice cream is definitely one of the best in ft wayne!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Magnum, Sundaes
Mike M
This place is totally awesome. The ice cream is great, the atmosphere is the bomb and the staff is outstanding. Sydney and Jacob are amazing.
Had Rusty’s for the first time today at my company picnic. The themed van and whole get up was super cool with retro 80s vibes! I had 4 different bowls of ice cream and all were super yummy! 🍦❤️👍
NUNYA
Had a totally RAD time at Rusty’s! The ice cream was bodacious and the decore was tubular! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Lazar
Upon entering, we were welcomed by a friendly smile and fun atmosphere! Highly recommend the Magnum P.B.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Magnum
Martin Cabela
Bright and fun. Jukebox, video games, oh and Super premium ice cream! Had the straw-ba-berry with real chunks of strawberries. scoops, shakes, floats & sundaes Waffle cones, dipped cones or killer cones as they call them... Friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aaron Quigley
If you're looking for a great ice cream shop that is both nostalgic and family friendly, then you can not miss this place! The staff are very friendly as well. This is a good retro 80s place that will surely bring back memories of your youth and a good place to bring it to the next generation as well. Oh, the ice cream is as good as the atmosphere is...Awesome! Last thing, there are dairy free options as well.
First time stopping in at Rusty’s, and it was great! The ice cream is as good as any, and the venue itself is a great homage to bygone eras of ice cream parlors and the like. Would definitely come back again and again!
Was celebrating my birthday and went with a friend for the first time. Both of us went to middle school and or High School in the 80s. I was definitely in the first MTV generation. I just heard of this place last week and thought it would be fun. It really was lots of fun! I had Cherry ice cream but I don't think that was the official name. What I liked the most about the place was the 80s memorabilia and 80s music. I will bring quarters the next time for the Jukebox. Rusty joined us in an informal game of 80s trivial pursuit. He was fun and friendly. I would recommend this place to anyone who is most formative years were in the 80s or anyone who just loves 80s pop culture.
You, too, can look like me. Ka-chow.
Great selection and service! The decor is awesome too! Be sure to check out the bathrooms too!
The ice cream is nothing to write home about its ice cream. The place itself is very nostalgic and definitely wouldn't take any young (toddler age) children to this place they have tons of candy down within reach, and board games. The employees acted like they didn't even want to be there. I absolutely loved the ice cream spoons they changed colors and I kept mine. Lol the shop itself is cool looking, and definitely brings me back, but they need to update the ice cream, put the candy behind a case and maybe even the games even if it's where older people can access them. Then this place would definitely deserve a 5 star rating that they almost have. The owner is on the right track though. The prices are also higher than most shops in the area. I would also do some research on the local prices.
Dietary restrictions: Has plenty of sugar free options
Kid-friendliness: Not unless you want to pay for a bunch of candy that is on an open shelf.
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes it's wheelchair accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Sundaes
Fun place to get ice cream and reminisce.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stepping into Rusty’s is like stepping into a time capsule from the 1980s. The moment you walk through the door, you’re enveloped in a world that feels like a retro movie set. The color palette bold, vibrant neons and pastels, immediately transports you back in time, while the walls are adorned with classic movie posters from iconic '80s films. Overhead, a TV plays old-school music videos, filling the air with the tunes that defined a generation. It’s more than just an ice cream shop; it’s an immersive trip back to a time when everything seemed larger than life, nostalgic in the best possible way.
I decided to keep it simple with my order, opting for a scoop of chocolate ice cream topped with pecans. Sometimes, simplicity is where the magic lies, and this was no exception. The ice cream was perfectly creamy, rich with a sweet chocolate flavor that wasn't too overpowering. Each bite had a velvety smoothness that melted in my mouth, but what truly elevated it was the pecans. Their salty, slightly crunchy texture balanced the sweetness of the chocolate in the most delightful way, creating a harmonious blend of flavors. It was like a dance of salty and sweet on my palate, the perfect pairing.
Rusty’s isn’t just about the ice cream; it’s about the feeling it creates. It’s a place where the past feels present, where you can indulge in something sweet while being surrounded by the vibrant energy of the '80s. It’s a spot that not only satisfies your sweet tooth but also gives you a sense of joy and nostalgia with every scoop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Magnum, Sundaes, Smurfalicious with Added Marshmallow Sauce, Ninja Turtle Sundae, Chocolate Chunk Truffle Shuffle, Cheesecake, Black Raspberry, Pretty in Pink Strawberry Cheesecake in a Waffle Cone, Coconut, Pretty in Pink Sundae, Bananarama Split Sundae, Oreo Speedwagon Sundae, Mint Chip, Dairy Free Mint Chip with Fudge and Oreo, Shakes & Floats
Love this place. The retro 80s atmosphere is awesome and the ice cream is the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is a cool vibe and the ice cream is definitely one of the best in ft wayne!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Magnum, Sundaes
This place is totally awesome. The ice cream is great, the atmosphere is the bomb and the staff is outstanding. Sydney and Jacob are amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Had Rusty’s for the first time today at my company picnic. The themed van and whole get up was super cool with retro 80s vibes! I had 4 different bowls of ice cream and all were super yummy! 🍦❤️👍
Had a totally RAD time at Rusty’s! The ice cream was bodacious and the decore was tubular! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Upon entering, we were welcomed by a friendly smile and fun atmosphere! Highly recommend the Magnum P.B.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Magnum
Bright and fun. Jukebox, video games, oh and Super premium ice cream! Had the straw-ba-berry with real chunks of strawberries.
scoops, shakes, floats & sundaes
Waffle cones, dipped cones or killer cones as they call them...
Friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you're looking for a great ice cream shop that is both nostalgic and family friendly, then you can not miss this place! The staff are very friendly as well.
This is a good retro 80s place that will surely bring back memories of your youth and a good place to bring it to the next generation as well. Oh, the ice cream is as good as the atmosphere is...Awesome!
Last thing, there are dairy free options as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...