Rusty's Ice Cream
9171 Lima Rd, Fort Wayne
(260) 222-9280
Customers' Favorites
Pretty in Pink Strawberry Cheesecake in a Waffle Cone
Smurfalicious with Added Marshmallow Sauce
Dairy Free Mint Chip with Fudge and Oreo
Chocolate Chunk Truffle Shuffle
Bananarama Split Sundae
Oreo Speedwagon Sundae
Pretty in Pink Sundae
Ninja Turtle Sundae
Ice Cream Sandwich
Black Raspberry
Menu
Photos
+12 photos
+11 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
First time stopping in at Rusty’s, and it was great! The ice cream is as good as any, and the venue itself is a great homage to bygone eras of ice cream parlors and the like. Would definitely come back again and again!
Was celebrating my birthday and went with a friend for the first time. Both of us went to middle school and or High School in the 80s. I was definitely in the first MTV generation. I just heard of this place last week and thought it would be fun. It really was lots of fun! I had Cherry ice cream but I don't think that was the official name. What I liked the most about the place was the 80s memorabilia and 80s music. I will bring quarters the next time for the Jukebox. Rusty...
The ice cream is nothing to write home about its ice cream. The place itself is very nostalgic and definitely wouldn't take any young (toddler age) children to this place they have tons of candy down within reach, and board games. The employees acted like they didn't even want to be there. I absolutely loved the ice cream spoons they changed colors and I kept mine. Lol the shop itself is cool looking, and definitely brings me back, but they need to update the ice cream,...
You May Also Like
Lucille's BBQ - 9011 Lima Rd
![]()
Barbecue, American, Barbeque, Vegetarian
Five Lakes Coffee - 8939 Lima Rd
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Bagels, Chocolatiers & Shops, Coffee
Coney Dog Café - 8915 Lima Rd
![]()
American, Hot Dogs, Burgers, Fast Food