“we chaise a busy night for sure for me and my mom and grandma and papaw. which the food was hot. the place was noisy which I wasn't surprised at all because it was a night of the polar express. which it was busy with kids and toddlers.“
“Went 4:30pm mass Monday, looked across the street from the church, seen the sign so I stopped by.Ordered the French Lick Veggie thin crust.First bite, I knew it was going to be a good one The crust was totally amazing, hands down the best EVER ! No flop, toasty underneath, sauce coulda been a little more tangy, but it was a great sweet tomato flavor. Veggies were fresh, black and green olives, tomato, cheese, mushrooms, onions,green peppers. Did I mention that crust ??Other menu items looked good, price was extremely good !#bestcrustever“
“The best pizza in town. Hats off to the little red headed girl with glasses. I know Godfathers isn't the first place most think of when someone asks about best pizza in valley but when cooked to order there's no competition. From all of us at Love Never Fails United Christian Church thank you and great job sister!“
“This is our second time trying this Chicago pizza this first time we got the supreme and it was great, the second time just the meat style, they were both good but the second one was on the dryer side! If you like sauce I would ask for extra!I liked the supreme better!“
“Ordered a pizza for pick up during covid. Easy on the phone, gave CC and then time for pick up. Ordered a Large, double cheese and pepperoni thin crust if possible. Well u didn’t disappoint. Amazing. Typing this while having leftovers from last night. Still great! If this crust isn’t on your menu it should be. It’s off the chart! Thanks again. Touchless pick up, very impressed! 11/10“
“I am a big fan of Papa John's unfortunately in Louisville Kentucky where I lived the Papa John's franchise has went downhill so when I came to Indiana and visit my burst Papa John's Pizza which is in West Baden springs I was very impressed to see that they have stuck with the old ways and the Great taste of the pizza when I walked into this Papa John's it was like walking into my very first one..... This is the best Papa John's restaurant I've ever been in the food is great! The staff keeps a smile on their face makes you feel good you walked in the door this place is highly recommended.“
“Love this place, they have speciality cocktails including boozy shakes and floats and a full coffee bar. Th store is super cute with a variety items from carved wood items,T-shirt's jewelry. The ice cream spoons change color, love that.“