Beach Cafe
903 N Shelby St, Gary
(219) 938-1100
Customers' Favorites
Lake Perch Dinner
Lobster Tail
Shrimp Skewer
Baked Potato
Frog Legs
Calamari
Steak
Rolls
Menu
Photos
+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
My girlfriend and I were there on Wednesday February 28 for our 9 month anniversary. She had no idea I had plans to propose to her that night. Destiny was our server and she was very accommodating and pleasant. We ordered two filet mignon steaks with loaded baked potatoes and the steaks were cooked to perfection and the potatoes were mouth wateringly delicious. We had Hennessey BBQ chicken wings and fried green tomatoes as our appetizers and those were also on point. I ordered...
First time dining here since the name change "Nostalgia" Waitstaff was pleasent, informed, and simply friendly, knowledgeable and made sure she took care of her customers. I ordered the 16 ounce bone in rib eye it was a perfect medium rare. Calimari appetizer hit the spot, the marinara sauce was a big lift. Grilled asparagus had just the right amount of crunch and tenderness. The soup served hot was a stomach warmer. Last but not least the cocktails were generous, stop...
I hadn't been there for 30 years. I had to move to Indianapolis due to being laid off. I guess they have new management. Went there for lunch, and all they had was breakfast. Didn't even know if they would have any seafood by dinner.
You May Also Like
Flamingo Pizza of Miller - 8341 Locust Ave
![]()
Pizza, American, Bar & Grill, Pubs
Beach Buds NWI - 7132 Oak Ave
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Paint & Sip, Beach Equipment Rentals, Ice Cream