Rico's Pizza

5404 W 25th Ave D, Gary
(219) 845-6300

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jason Murray

Had the meat lovers pizza. One of the best pizzas I have ever had!!!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Burts Desserts

Great pizza, good service ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hector Macias

Expensive $39 a medium meat lovers

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Queen Harris

I Called Rico pizza didn’t feel like driving took a DoorDash order 12 inch pizza extra cheese, beef and pepperoni also ordered boneless wings and bites. The chicken dried out. The pizza is overdone. Very disappointed never again for dinner !!! I would’ve been better off ordering Domino’s Pizza instead sooooooo angry then I called the restaurant to explain what happened. She immediately cut me off talking about their close at 9:20 after receiving my food the manager statement was they closed nothing more or less , not apologetic I’m soooo over this place don’t waste your money & time dealing with this company stay at home make a home run in pizza or just call Domino’s heck you can even get away with little Caesar’s better than what I received also they just dont care ??‍♀️

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Erikka Stewart

They're food never disappoints

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Robert Schmidt

Good food and people

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

April

My pizza was delicious, I know next time to request that it is well done.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Sausge and Cheese Pizza

Victoria

Should change delivery mile radius .. would be very beneficial $$$$

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

David Bryant

Very good pizza a little on the expensive side but you pay for what you get

Parking: Limited parking so sometimes it's hard to get in

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sausge and Cheese Pizza

Bunny Yetsko

If you need a delivery, ask If their are any drivers first. Too many times I have ordered to be told afterward, NO DELIVERIES TONIGHT"...Just bluntly stated, just like that. AFTER I BEGIN MY ORDER. I was told "no deliveries tonight" then "CLICK"☎️ ! I DIDN'T KNOW WHETHER TO FEEL OFFENDED OR STUPID. BUT.... THEY'RE 1/4 MILE AWAY FROM WHERE I LIVE SO ?. I HAVE TO SAY THAT IF I HAVE ORDERED 10 TIMES IN 5 YEARS FROM THERE. I HAVE OFFICIALLY HAD ONE PLEASANT EXPERIENCE. Don't get me wrong, the pizza usually is decent. The staff, once you get past that automatic voice recorded machine ?, at the beginning, some are amazingly kind?‍?, and some just don't want to be there?. Nor do they care if you know that?. It seems that the delivery driver, is overworked?️ and underpaid or perhaps the entire staff is. My big issue pertains to a delivery.Here Goes!
Not long ago I ordered a small pizza with one topping. Sausage. Perhaps a 2-liter to go with it. I do have the receipt still just not in front of me. So one small sausage pizza and perhaps a 2-liter. Upon ordering at 5:45pm. I was told it would be 40 minutes for my delivery. NO PROBLEM ?. 1 hour went by, we began to get concerned. Called just to check the status on the order. Informed that the pizza left 10 minutes ago, so aprx 6:45-7pm. I live 3 minutes away. Nothing. After another half hour we call back. After the machine sent us to idk where. I was told I'm being transferred to the front. After the girl picked up, I asked if I could have the drivers number so I can contact the driver. I mean as of now my small one-topping pizza has been enroute for 40 mins according to the front girl. I Was not given driver's number. I Was told "I'LL CALL HIM" then hung up on. We were baffled, is she calling us back, are we calling her back,. She made a statement and hung up. Waited another 10 minutes for a call back. Nah, apparently that was our job. Call back the awful machine,to be transferred to the wrong person again, who transferred me to the front again, who hung up on me this time. It seems my small one topping pizza was on her last nerve. I mean I order at 5:45pm. We are approaching 7:45pm fast. Nobody cared. Finally the phone rings. It's our driver, he has great news, he had a bunch of deliveries and he just got back to Rico's to pick up our small one topping pizza and bring it 3 minutes away. Considering we ordered at 5:45 p.m. they must have been overwhelmed for the 6:00pm Rush hour? That was not my problem though. If you look back at the beginning of this. The very first call we placed. The girl had told us our order left 10 minutes ago. Now you might as well say it's 8: 00pm. IF OUR ORDER LEFT AT 6:35 P.M.OUT FOR DELIVERY....ACCORDING TO THE GIRL ANSWERING THE FRONT PHONE. WHY IS THE DRIVER PICKING UP OUR SMALL ONE TOPPING PIZZA FROM RICO'S APRX 8PM? THE VERY SAME GIRL SAID 1 HOUR AFTER WE PLACED THE ORDER THAT IT WAS IN THE CAR ON ITS WAY FOR 10 MINUTES ALREADY. NOW THE DRIVER SAYS HE IS AT THE FACILITY PICKING UP OUR ORDER. ONE SMALL SAUSAGE PIZZA... "maybe a 2-liter also" just to be fair. I'm not sure what you're looking for in ordering from this place but if it's a small pizza with one topping, AND you've got about 2 hours and 20 minutes to sit on your hands and wait for your food to get cold or be taken back to the restaurant to be reheated. Whatever they decided they wanted to do, because at that point you have no options. If we cancel it we've just spent two and a half hours in vain, Also it was already charged on our credit card. The message that I received from the evening in question displays A larger concern for the big money orders, so the couple who just needed a small pizza had to eat "in our opinion, reheated Pizza" . Which is why the delivery person had to go back to the restaurant....To fix it. Because he did not have the order with him as we were told on our very 1st phone call for a order ofstatus. Where's the integr

Food: 3

Service: 3

Sister Kristiniyah Goshen

Mine you this was my first time coming here I went in there the other day for my lunch break and the lady with the glasses seen me standing there and still didn’t greet me or nothing 5mins passed still not a word she was only in the back so I was trying to be patient since I seen she was the only one there but once the 10min mark hit(which by this time my pregnant butt took a seat to still wait for her to come to acknowledge that I was even there) I got up and left and went to the restaurant a few doors down called Philly Steak and Lemonade where the service was a 10 and food was a hit. My craving was for pizza but that experience turned me completely off (and I am really big on people having a certain spirit while cooking my food ??‍♀️)was on to the next and as long as she is in there I will never try them nor come back unfortunately

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Shawna Armstrong

Very good! Good service! Good fresh food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kimberly Ross

2 weeks ago I ordered a sub sandwich I thought it was the best sandwich ever. Now today I ordered the sub sandwich again. I get it and it feels way lighter than before opened it up 2 slices of meat so I called and told them about my order so they offered to make me another one so I said ok. When I get the next one instead of two pieces of meat they give me three pieces. They going to tell me it's like that cause I didn't want ham. So what happened to the other meat. 15.00 for three tiny slices of meat. This is why you have to go outside of Gary to get what you paid for. Just ridiculous. My first sandwich was full of meat. I'm mad cause for dinner I a salad between to slices of bread SMH

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

R St

I usually LOVE this place my favorite is the meat lovers pizza but lately it just doesn't taste the same I'm not sure if the ingredients changed or what, I know the price definitely increased which would be fine as long as the taste would've remained the same. I hope the last couple of times were the only time that was different, I'll try once again though to see. And this all seemed to happen after I started bragging to my job about this place trying to get my job to cater from Rico's for our next luncheon.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers 5

yo mama

I will never go here again my stomach was in a lot of pain I think it gave me a parasite then when they gave me my pizza it was it was not cut I had to cut it on my

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...