Arrenellos Pizza
$ • Pizza, Seafood
Hours:
2556 45th St, Highland
(219) 924-2525
About Arrenellos Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Arrenellos Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about Arrenellos Pizza
Best pizza in nwi hands down
I had one of the worst customer service experiences I've ever dealt with. After waiting over 2 hours for a pizza, I called to check on the order. While I was on the phone, the delivery driver pulled up. I told the guy on the phone that, and his response was: "So do you want the pizza or not?" - then he hung up on me.
I called back to ask if that's really how you talk to customers. The same guy suddenly claimed he was the manager. When I asked to speak with the owner, I...read full review
I have always been a fan, but this location seems to have lost something. I ordered pizza bread and some fries. My order arrived and I received tomato bread instead. When I called, I was told that their ovens were off for the night. I let them know this was not right, and they said they would send out a pizza bread that arrived almost 35 min from the time I called. Meanwhile the other part of my dinner was getting cold. Cold fries are not appetizing. You would think that they...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 4 - 8:30PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4 - 8:30PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 8:30PM |
| Friday | 4 - 9:30PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 9:30PM |
| Sunday | 4 - 8:30PM |
People in Highland Also Viewed
Arrenellos Pizza is known for its stuffed pizza, and many customers still find the pizza delicious, especially the Chicago style deep dish loaded with tasty ingredients. The sauce is very sweet and unique, making it highly recommended. Customers have been enjoying Arrenellos for years, with some traveling from nearby states to get their favorite pizza. The quality and consistency remain good across different locations, though some have noticed a decline in quality recently. The cheese on the pizzas has become less, and the thin crust pies are often not rolled thin enough, with the dough's taste and texture feeling off. Despite these issues, the pizza remains a popular choice for many. Wait times for pick-up can sometimes be over 25 minutes, which can be inconvenient, and the staff and service are considered mediocre, with some overhearing staff discussing turning off the phone due to many orders. Prices are seen as high for the level of service, and one customer was not informed of a service charge for credit card payments. Overall, the pizza is regarded as delicious, but customers hope for improvements in quality and service.