Colonial Tavern
4343 Madison Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 783-2553
Customers' Favorites
Ranch and Hot Sauce Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Chicken Wings
Food Menu
Menu
Photos
+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Colonial (Inn) Tavern has seen a lot of changes since 2020, including the fact they have no waitresses so customers go to the bartender. So what they DO have is the fastest bartender, (Cupcake) who's 16 years speaks for itself. Cupcake always smiles and is calm and was always a pleasure to work with for years. You can't call enforcing Colonial policy being rude or unattentive. We've seen all types of customers so please consider the numerous responsibilities a bartender...
I seen the newest comments made about Cupcake and I would like to comment on it. I have known Cupcake for 10 years + and have been going into colonial Tavern for years ans well and I have NEVER seen Cupcake treat anyone poorly. She is very attentive to ALL her customers! She is an amazing bartender and sever. She is a great addition to the Colonial tavern. She is the best bartender I have ever had. YOU ROCK CUPCAKE!
I have known Cupcake for years and she is a great bartender and sever. She is always attentive to her customers and I have never seen any issues with her what so ever. She is a great addition to the colonial! She is the best bartender I have had!
You May Also Like
Carnitas Y Taqueria La Frontera - 4102 Madison Ave
![]()
Mexican, Tacos
Open Kitchen Restuarant - 4022 Shelby St
![]()
Fine Dining, American, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
Subway - 936 E Hanna Ave
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food