Einstein Bros. Bagels

3450 W 86th St, Indianapolis
(317) 802-9888

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Single Bagel with Shmear
Vanilla Hazelnut Latte
Cheesy Hashbrown Bagel
Baker's Dozen Bagels
Half Dozen Bagel Box
Breakfast Sandwich
Half Dozen Bagels
Nova Lox & Bagel
Classic Bagels
Tasty Turkey

Menu

Fresh Baked Bagels & Shmear
Single Bagel with Shmear
Choose any of our fresh-baked bagels topped with double-whipped cream cheese.
Shmear Tubs
Assorted flavors of double-whipped cream cheese.
Nova Lox
Choice of bagel with shmear, red onion, capers, tomato and cold-smoked Nova Lox salmon. ***Cold Smoked Salmon is not cooked. Consuming raw or undercooked seafood may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Single Bagel
Choose any of our fresh-baked bagels.
Baker's Dozen Bagels with Shmear
Serves up to 13 people. 13 fresh-baked bagels (3 Plain, 2 Sesame, 2 Chocolate Chip, 2 Cinnamon Raisin, 2 Blueberry, 2 Asiago) with 2 tubs of double-whipped cream cheese shmear (1 Plain, 1 Garden Veggie). Feel free to replace your shmears with your favorites in store.
Baker's Dozen Bagels Only
Serves up to 13 people. 13 fresh-baked bagels (3 Plain, 2 Sesame, 2 Chocolate Chip, 2 Cinnamon Raisin, 2 Blueberry, 2 Asiago).
Half Dozen Bagels with Shmear
Serves up to 6 people. 6 fresh-baked bagels (1 Plain, 1 Sesame, 1 Chocolate Chip, 1 Cinnamon Raisin, 1 Blueberry, 1 Asiago) and 1 tub of Plain Cream Cheese Shmear.
Half Dozen Bagels Only
Serves up to 6 people. 6 fresh-baked bagels (1 Plain, 1 Sesame, 1 Chocolate Chip, 1 Cinnamon Raisin, 1 Blueberry, 1 Asiago).
Avocado Toast
Fresh-baked Plain Bagel topped with smashed avocado and our Everything Bagel Seasoning.

Everyday Brunch Boxes
Brunch Box for Two
Serves up to 2 people. Bacon & Cheddar Egg Sandwich, Farmhouse Egg Sandwich, 2 Twice-Baked Hash Browns and 2 Blueberry Muffins.
Nova Lox Brunch Special
Nova Lox Sandwich, Twice-Baked Hash Brown and a Blueberry Muffin.
Bacon & Cheddar Brunch Special
Bacon & Cheddar Egg Sandwich, Twice-Baked Hash Brown and a Blueberry Muffin.
Brunch Box
Serves up to 8 people. 6 fresh-baked bagels (2 Plain, 1 Sesame, 1 Asiago, 1 Chocolate Chip, 1 Cinnamon Raisin), 1 tub of Plain Cream Cheese Shmear, 1 Farmhouse Egg Sandwich, 2 Bacon & Cheddar Egg Sandwiches, 4 Twice-Baked Hash Browns and 4 Blueberry Muffins.

Egg Sandwiches
All-Nighter Egg Sandwich
Cage-free eggs with bacon, American cheese and chipotle mayo on a fresh-baked Cheesy Hash Brown Gourmet bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Farmhouse Egg Sandwich
Cage-free eggs with bacon, ham, cheddar cheese and Country Pepper Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Cheesy Hash Brown Gourmet bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Texas Brisket Egg Sandwich
Cage-free eggs with smoked beef brisket, cheddar cheese and smoky chipotle aioli on a fresh-baked Cheddar Jalapeno Gourmet Bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Turkey-Sausage & Cheddar Egg Sandwich
Cage-free eggs with turkey-sausage and cheddar cheese on a fresh-baked bagel of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Garden Avocado Egg Sandwich
Cage-free eggs with smashed avocado, tomato, spinach and roasted tomato spread on a fresh-baked Everything Bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Bacon & Cheddar Egg Sandwich
Cage-free eggs with bacon and cheddar cheese on a fresh-baked bagel of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Chorizo Breakfast Burrito
Cage-free eggs, chorizo sausage, bacon, shredded hash browns, melted cheese and Jalapeno Salsa Cream Cheese Shmear on a flour tortilla.
Santa Fe Egg White Sandwich
Cage-free egg whites with turkey-sausage, cheddar cheese, salsa and Jalapeno Salsa Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Asiago Bagel Thin. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel Thin.
Chorizo Sunrise Egg Sandwich
Cage-free eggs with chorizo sausage, cheddar cheese, smashed avocado and Jalapeno Salsa Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Green Chile Gourmet Bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Cheddar Cheese Egg Sandwich
Cage-free eggs with cheddar cheese on a fresh-baked bagel of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Bacon, Avocado, & Tomato Egg White Sandwich
Cage-free egg whites with bacon, smashed avocado, tomatoes and roasted tomato spread on a fresh-baked bagel thin of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel Thin.
Ham & Swiss Egg Sandwich
Cage-free eggs with ham and Swiss cheese on a fresh-baked bagel of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
NEW! Maplehouse Egg Sandwich
Cage-free eggs with pork sausage, bacon, cheddar, Honey Almond Shmear and sweet syrup on a fresh-baked Maple French Toast Gourmet Bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.

Deli Lunch
Tasty Turkey Sandwich
Turkey, spinach, cucumbers, lettuce, tomatoes Onion & Chive Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Asiago Bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips.
Pizza Bagel Cheese
Fresh-baked Plain Bagel, topped with pizza sauce and a blend of mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, asiago, parmesan, and romano cheeses. Includes Sea Salt Chips.
Nova Lox
Cold smoked salmon, red onions, capers, tomatoes and Plain Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Plain Bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips. If selected Bagel is not available, sandwiches will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Turkey, Bacon & Avocado Sandwich
Turkey, bacon, smashed avocado, lettuce, tomatoes and roasted tomato spread on a fresh-baked Plain Bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips.
Ham & Swiss Sandwich
Ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, mayo, and deli mustard on a fresh-baked Plain Bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips. If selected Bagel is not available, sandwiches will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Pizza Bagel Pepperoni
Fresh-baked Plain Bagel topped with pizza sauce, pepperoni and a blend of mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, asiago, parmesan and romano cheeses. Includes Sea Salt Chips.
Turkey & Cheddar Sandwich
Turkey, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, mayo, and deli mustard on a fresh-baked Plain bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips. If selected Bagel is not available, sandwiches will be made on a Plain bagel.
Avocado Veg Out Sandwich
Smashed avocado, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, spinach, lettuce and Garden Veggie Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Sesame Seed Bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips.

Sweets & Sides
Twice-Baked Hash Brown
Shredded hash brown potatoes, twice-baked with double-whipped cream cheese shmear and grated cheeses.
Cinnamon Bliss Roll
Cinnamon roll topped with cream cheese frosting and served warm.
Strawberry & Cream Strudel
Strawberries and sweet cream filling wrapped in a flaky pastry.
Blueberry Muffin
Blueberries baked into a fresh-from-the-oven muffin and topped with cinnamon-streusel crumbles.
Apple Pie Pastry
Sweet apples wrapped in a fresh-baked flaky pastry.
Chocolate Chip Muffin
Chocolate Chips baked into a fresh-from-the-oven muffin.
Heavenly Chocolate Chip Cookie
Fresh-baked cookie loaded with semisweet chocolate chunks.
Sea Salt Chips
Classic sea salt kettle-cooked potato chips.

Coffee & Tea
Classic Cold Brew
Classic cold brew coffee, served over ice.
Hot Coffee
Premium coffee made with 100% Arabica beans and brewed fresh every hour. Choose Vanilla Hazelnut, Medium Roast, Dark Roast or Decaf.
Iced Tea
Freshly-brewed iced black tea.
Hot Tea
Freshly-steeped hot tea.

Juices & More (Bottled Drinks)
Blackberry Lemonade - Large
Orange Juice - Large
Bottled - Simply Orange
11.5 oz
Orange Juice - Small
Lemonade - Large
Bottled - Chocolate Milk
7 oz
Blackberry Lemonade - Small
Lemonade - Small
Bottled - Smart Water
33.8 oz
Bottled - Diet Coke ®
20 oz
Bottled - Coke ®
20oz
Bottled - Dasani Water
20 oz
Strawberry Banana Smoothie - Large
Strawberries and bananas blended together with low-fat yogurt.
Strawberry Banana Smoothie - Small
Strawberries and bananas blended together with low-fat yogurt.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+64 photos
Photo credit: google
+63 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Update:

The GM (Lisa) of the store reached out and we had a great conversation that this is not normal, she made it right and went above and beyond. This store has a very bright future with her at the lead. I would say if you are frustrated with this store give it time and they will surprise you, what started off very poor has turned into we will only go to this store!

Ordered via the mobile app. The charged for items not provided. Order two...
October 2025
Fresh bagels, friendly service and very clean and organized location. Marley and PJ are great on the weekends and my mobile orders are always correct and ready when promised. Please keep in mind they are making online, in person and catering orders at the same time. Great experience and great job handing the Saturday morning rush.
August 2025
Clean and the food was good quality. However, without it being too busy, it took 20 minutes from payment to ready on just two breakfast sandwiches outside of rush timeslot. Also, they were out of so many ingredients that nearly every order that was coming through had to be changed for lack of one thing or another.

Ok, but avoid if you are on a time crunch.
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Chicken Salad Chick - 3450 W 86th St
Southern, Chicken Shop, Chicken, Sandwich Shop
Jack's Pizza - 8620 Purdue Rd
Pizza
Five Guys - 3454 W 86th St
Fast Food, Burgers, Pet Friendly, Hot Dogs

Einstein Bros. Bagels

3450 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46268
(317) 802-9888