Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave.
545 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 602-3401
Customers' Favorites
Pizza Slice Pepperoni Pizza
Breadsticks with Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pizza and Breadsticks
New York-Style Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Slice of Pizza
Taste of Naples
Biggest Pizza
Garlic Bread
Menu
Photos
+63 photos
+62 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
It was absolutely crazy in there... but in a good way. Music was loud, as the guys flipped and spun the crust. It was entertainment while waiting in line. Once we got our pizza, I understood what all the hype was about! Absolutely delicious! Loved it!
When I walked in, Chris greeted me with a big smile and said he remembered me from before, which was so nice. It’s such a good feeling when someone at a place you visit recognizes you—it makes the experience way more personal. Chris was super friendly, and his customer service was on point. He really made me feel welcome, and that’s honestly a huge reason I keep coming back.
The whole staff is great, though. They always take care of orders quickly, but...
The whole staff is great, though. They always take care of orders quickly, but...
I've been coming here 1-2 times a week. By far the best pizza joint in Indy. Nonnas pie is my absolute favorite. If you're not a fan of super greesy and salty pizzas, Goodfellas is the place for you. The BEST ?
You May Also Like
Wiseguy Lounge - Mass Ave - 545 Massachusetts Ave
![]()
Bar, Cocktail Bar, Speakeasies, Beer Bar
LouVino Indianapolis Mass Ave Restaurant & Wine Bar - 530 Massachusetts Ave #140
![]()
Southern, Wine Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian
Kilwins Indianapolis - 530 Massachusetts Ave #110
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Chocolatiers & Shops, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Candy Store, Ice Cream