Great American Cookies
49 West Maryland Street Suite D20A, Indianapolis
(317) 929-1647
Create Your Own Custom Cake
Create Your Own Custom Cake
Create your perfect Cookie Cake! Choose your favorite Cookie Cake shape and flavor, then customize your message with any of our icing colors. For an additional charge, add a design or extras!
Birthday
Dude, You're OLD - B1041
Balloons - B1030
Forever 29 - B1038
Happy Birthday Jenny B1037
Birthday BBall - B1039
Popcorn Happy Birthday - B1035
Fish - B1034
Princess Crown - B1028
Boot - B1027
Guitar - B1026
1st Birthday - B1025
Motorcycle Happy Birthday - B1023
Jeep Happy Birthday - B1022
Pirate Ship Happy Birthday - B1021
Princess Cake- B1019
Caterpillar & Butterfly - B1014
Island - B1013
Butterflies - B1006
Dinosaur - B1005
Dog - B1004
Horse & Flowers - B1003
Painter Birthday- B1032
Roller Skate Birthday- B1031P
Happy Birthday Dump Truck B1036
Work Occasions
Happy Boss's Day Ribbon - O4046
Best Boss Ever - O4047
Happy Boss's Day - O4027
Happy Nurse's Day - O4022
You're The Best! - O4011
Sports
Score Basketball - S3509
Good Luck Team Baseball - S3508
Go Team Helmet - S3506
Goal! - S3505
Football Field - S3504
Football Fever! - S3503
Great Season - S3502
Special Occasion & Thank You
Thanks A Latte - O4040
Family Reunion Watermelon - O4030
Girls' Night Out Martini - O4020
Sad To See You Go! - O4019
Good Luck Moving - O4018
Brighten Your Day! Rainbow - O4017
Best Friends Forever - O4016
Yellow Ribbon - O4010
Pig Out - O4009
Poker Night - O4008
Get Well Flowers - O4005
Prom? - O4024
Find Your Sparkle - O4043
Baby
Ahoy It's a Boy! O4037
He or She - O4036
Welcome Baby - O4004
It's a Girl Elephant - O4038
Winter Holidays & New Years
Merry Christmas Snow Globe - HW2840
Cheers - HW2902
Merry Christmas - Snowflakes - HW2834
Happy Holiday Lights - HW2815
Merry Christmas Snowman - HW2821
Merry Christmas From the Snows - HW2827
New Years - HW2901
Menorah - HW2752
Joy Love Peace Cake - HW2835
Happy Holidays Snowman - HW2842
Merry and Bright Tree– HW2844
Happy Holidays Wreath– HW2845
Sleigh All Day– HW2846
Easter
Shake Your Cotton Tail - HS2255
Happy Easter Cross - HS2254
Easter Colorful Chick In Egg - HS2253
Happy Easter Bunny - HS2251
Mother's Day
Mom, Love you Llots - HS2322
You're Stuck With Us Mom - HS2323
Happy Mother's Day Butterfly Flowers - HS2318
Mother's Day Flowers and Birds - HS2316
Mother's Day Daisies - HS2305
School & Grad
Congratulations Grad! - S3005
Class of Diploma - S3020
Class of- S3021
Hats off to the Grad! - S3009
Tassel Hassle - S3002
Congratulations Graduate! - S3001
Back To The Books - S3402
Prom? - O4024
Congrats Grad Balloons - S3022
Graduate and Diploma - S3010
Father's Day
Dad You're Reely Great HS2423
Happy Father's Day Football - HS2420
You're Flippin Awesome Dad - HS2419
Happy Father's Day Dad Camping - HS2418
Father's Day Recliner - HS2413
Golf - HS2410
Hammock - HS2409
Grill - HS2407
Halloween
Here for the Boos - HF2572
No Tricks Just Treats - HF2573
Halloween Dog - HF2568
Halloween Cat - HF2569
Zombie - HF2563
Ghost Pumpkin - HF2562
Ghost In Pumpkin - HF2558
Happy Halloween Spider HF2565
Happy Halloscream - HF2571
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Great American Cookies are our family's universal favorite birthday treat. We are so grateful there is now an Indianapolis location! We ordered 2 different cookie cakes for family birthday celebrations in October 2023, and both were done as ordered, on time, and were fresh & Delicious. One order was completed online without issue, and my husband even received a phonecall in advance to verify details. The other order was placed over the phone, as they had a website glitch...
November 2023
Went here before they were closing for the day and they were happy to help. Plenty of creative cookies and brownies, fudge, cakes, and ice cream. They have a pretty large menu with an array of desserts.
September 2023
Faham and his team are amazing! I called wanting to place a large order for a corporate event (same day delivery) and Faham and his team made this happen! Very professional, polite, and the cookies were delicious. Thank you very much!
July 2023
You May Also Like
Auntie Anne's - 49 W Maryland St Space K1 - 01
![]()
Pretzel Store, Bakery, Fast Food, Pretzels
Bella Pizzeria - 49 W Maryland St
![]()
Pizza, Salad
A&W Restaurant - 49 W Maryland St
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers, Hot Dogs