Harry & Izzy's

153 S Illinois St, Indianapolis
(317) 635-9594

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

World Famous St Elmo Shrimp Cocktail
Special Aged Ribeye Steak 18 Oz
Woodford Reserve Bread Pudding
Brussels Sprouts with Bacon
Vanilla Bean Crème Brulee
St Elmo Prime Rib Sandwich
Vanilla Bean Creme Brulee
Signature Brownie Sundae
St Elmo Prime Rib Pizza
Steak House Mac & Cheese

Menu

Specials
Prime Ribeye
10 ounce USDA prime, excellent marbling, loaded with flavor.
Izzy Style New York Strip
14oz. Rolled in cracked pepper, pan-seared, orange brandy butter sauce.
Filet Mignon
Six ounce tender and center-cut.

Appetizers
St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail
Four jumbo shrimp served with out spicy signature cocktail sauce.
Calamari
Lightly hand-breaded, served with sweet chili sauce.
Toasted Ravioli
Cheese filled ravioli served with traditional marinara sauce.
French Onion Soup
Prepared with a trio of sweet caramelized onions.
Prime Beef Meatballs
3 house-made beef, veal, pork meatballs, tomato sauce, ricotta gratin.
Grilled Slab Bacon
Root beer maple glazed bacon, locally sourced from smoking goose.
Guacamole
Haas avocado, serrano peppers, aged manchego , tortilla chips.

Steaks and Chops
Ribeye
14oz. Excellent marbling, loaded with flavor.
Filet Mignon
10 oz. Tender, center-cut.
Bone-In (Cowboy) Ribeye
18oz. Exceptional flavor, great balance of marbling.
Filet Mignon
8oz. Tender, center-cut.
Ribeye Filet
8oz. Center cut ribeye, full-flavored with generous marbling throughout.
New York Strip
12 oz. flavorful strip with a mid-range of marbling.

Specialties, Pasta and Pizza
Penne Alfredo
Penne pasta with a garlic parmesan cream sauce, choice of chicken, shrimp, or salmon.
Roasted Chicken Breast
10oz Airline-cut with wild mushroom demi-glace, served with mashed potatoes.
USDA Prime Meatloaf
USDA Prime beef, pork, and veal, bourbon peppercorn sauce. Served with redskin mashed potatoes.
St. Elmo Prime Rib Pizza
1/2 pound of prime rib, horseradish ricotta, mushrooms and campfire onion marmalade.
Tuscan Pizza
Pesto ricotta, red bell pepper, kale, sliced tomato, four cheese blend.
Downtown Special Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms.
Berkshire Pork Chop
Bourbon peppercorn sauce, truffle parmesan roasted red potatoes.
Cilantro Lime Tacos
Marinated Denver steak, kale slaw, chimichurri, lime crema.....also comes with a small order of chips, salsa and guac.

Seafood
Grilled Salmon
Served with house-made remoulade and redskin mashed potatoes.
Scallops
Jumbo sea scallops, edamame, roasted corn, rainbow carrots, bacon , cajun beurre blanc.
Fresh Atlantic Cod
Blackened, house-made remoulade, served with sauteed French green beans.
Cold Water Lobster Tail
9oz succulent cold water lobster tail, drawn butter, served with roasted asparagus and redskin mashed potatoes.

Sandwiches
St. Elmo Prime Rib Sandwich
White cheddar, au jus, creamy horseradish, served with fresh-cut fries.
Prime Steakburger
Ground USDA prime, traditional toppings, white cheddar, mayo, served with fresh-cut fries.
Tavern Club
Fr'Mani ham, roasted turkey, Applewood smoked bacon swiss and cheddar cheeses, shredded lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and honey truffle dijonnaise, served with fresh-cut french fries.
Turkey Burger
Traditional toppings, mayo, served with house-made chips.

Sliders
Filet Slider
Sesame seed bun and creamy horseradish on the side.
Fried Chicken Slider
Pretzel Bun, Honey Mustard Mayo, Pickle.
Fried Shrimp
Sesame seed bun, shredded lettuce, remoulade, cocktail sauce on side.

Salads
Wedge
Bacon, tomatoes and creamy gorgonzola dressing.
Izzy's House Salad
Mixed greens, English cucumbers, grape tomatoes, aged cheddar, peppered bacon, and seasoned croutons.
Caesar
Romaine hearts, shaved parmigiano-reggiano and herb croutons.
Burrata & Brussels Sprouts Salad
Hand-tied burrata, Champagne Rosemary vinaigrette, green onion, snap peas, radishes, pickled onion.
Cali Chopped Salad
Avocado, gorgonzola, peppered bacon, grape tomatoes, provolone, cucumber, carrots.....feel free to add on a protein.
Romaine Hearts
Apples, gorgonzola, candied pecans and champagne-rosemary vinaigrette.
Emerald Kale Salad
Aged Manchego, dried cranberries, green onion, sunflower seeds, fresh mint, cilantro vinaigrette and a peanut satay sauce.

Sides to Share
Redskin Mashed Potatoes
Fresh Cut Fries
House-Made Onion Rings
House-Made onion rings served with ketchup.
Roasted Broccolini
Roasted Asparagus
House Made Chips
House made chips served with a french onion dip.
Steak House Mac n Cheese

Children's
Filet Medallions
Two Steakburger Sliders
Chicken Fingers
Small Signature Brownie
Hot fudge, Woodford Reserve caramel sauce, vanilla ice cream, whipped topping, candied pecans.
Cheese Pizza

Dessert
New York Cheesecake
Topped with Raspberry Puree.
Signature Brownie
Hot fudge, woodford reserve caramel sauce, vanilla ice cream, whipped topping, candied pecans.
Bread Pudding
Chocolate bread pudding with sea salt caramel ice cream.
Vanilla Bean Creme Brulee
Traditional vanilla bean custard.
Peanut Butter Pie
Homemade brownie crumb crust filled with creamy, rich peanut butter filling topped with a peanut butter sauce, whipped cream and mint garnish.
Scoop of Ice Cream
Choose from vanilla or sea salt caramel.
Sorbet
Enjoy a scoop of our weekly sorbet flavor.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+97 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+96 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Very busy spot pre Indy Fever game. Upscale place with no dress code so you can have a wonderful eating experience in your Fever Stranger Things jersey and not feel “out of place”.
August 2025
Had a great meal with our party of 7. I've been several times, but this was better than I remembered. Prime rib sandwich was especially good, but everything we had was excellent.
August 2025
Had the ribeye lunch special and it was delicious! The redskin mashed potatoes are to die for...loaded with cheese, etc. For dessert, the bread pudding was excellent and worth the 15 minute wait! Loved the flavored ice tea also.
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

1933 Lounge - 127 S Illinois St
Bar, Lounges, American, Cocktail Bar
St. Elmo Steak House - 127 S Illinois St
Steak House, Seafood, Cocktail Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian
Social Cantina - 148 S Illinois St
Mexican, Tacos, American, New American, Vegan

Harry & Izzy's

153 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
(317) 635-9594