It was very loud and we felt like we were just a table of 3. No conversation with the server. Prefer HC Tavern.
Tevon
Damn!!! It's been 10 years since my husband and I dined at Harry & Izzy's. For our anniversary we thought it was high-time to return and boy did they shown out! Sherry, our waitress, deserves 10s across the board. She made sure were informed of our options, fed well, and served as much water as we wanted (sorry we drank so much). The shrimp cocktail was the perfect starter/palette cleanser🥵. Followed by the warming French onion soup 🙌🏽. Then our entrée of New York strip w/ a healthy portion of loaded potatoes. For most that would have been enough, but we had to stuff ourselves beyond capacity with the famous bread pudding. It's exactly what we needed on a cold night in Indianapolism
Briana
Great food and excellent service! Harry and Izzy's is such a unique Indianapolis gem and I'm always excited to dine here with family and friends.
Kevin
The food was exceptional, our server was great and knowledgeable The price was expected to be premium, but was a bit higher than expected.
Duncan
Took my wife for her Birthday. Food & service were great. There is a reason this place is our go to for celebratory events!
Stephanie
Absolutely love Harry & Izzy's. Excellent food and wonderful location. The service was less than we are used to but overall, a great visit and meal.
Gary
The atmosphere is relaxing and very classy. Our waiter was exceptional! The food was fabulous. We had a perfect dining experience!!! A very memorable anniversary dinner!
Jennifer D
Lovely setting in the dining room and fun festive setting in St Nick’s Lodge. Great service, cocktails and best prime rib sandwich ever!
wdearmitt
Excellent food, great atmosphere, great service. I had the ribeye filet. My grandsons both had the specupial of the day which was “halfway dry aged ribeye. All very tasty and perfectly cooked. One of my grandsons (in his twenties) said he thought it was probably the most tender steak he had ever eaten.
Dave
Great experience, excellent service all around, and the food was delicious. Our party had a few kids and the staff was great with them. Their kids menu is excellent also. Will be back
We three besties were celebrating 2 birthdays and had the best time! Our server (I forget his name) added to the fun!
Sierra
The experience that we had was okay, but we paid a very luxury price for it. Steak was poorly cooked and badly marinated. Most food felt under seasoned except the bread. We also had a near miss with an undisclosed allergen, and at previous experiences at a similar price point our servers have made a point to ask about allergies and dietary restrictions
Brad
Way over priced. Ordered the Scallops meal for $50 and got 3 scallops, decent amount of Orzo and undercooked Bocilini. Yes 3 scallops for $50. Filet Sliders were great and a good value.
Paula
We sat at the bar for a Saturday noon reservation and had great service from Ryan. Drinks are pricey but good, and love the lunch Parlay option which offers 4 items for $25 that can include shrimp cocktail, soup or salad, filet sliders or salmon, and fries or homemade chips. It's a good value and excellent food. We celebrated a birthday too and shared a free dessert. Highly recommend!!
Chris
Service was fantastic. Serge was amazing and made sure our experience was great. My steak was overcooked and my wife's was a little undercooked but they had good flavor and the sides were amazing. Definitely recommend and will be back.
It was very loud and we felt like we were just a table of 3. No conversation with the server. Prefer HC Tavern.
Damn!!! It's been 10 years since my husband and I dined at Harry & Izzy's. For our anniversary we thought it was high-time to return and boy did they shown out! Sherry, our waitress, deserves 10s across the board. She made sure were informed of our options, fed well, and served as much water as we wanted (sorry we drank so much). The shrimp cocktail was the perfect starter/palette cleanser🥵. Followed by the warming French onion soup 🙌🏽. Then our entrée of New York strip w/ a healthy portion of loaded potatoes. For most that would have been enough, but we had to stuff ourselves beyond capacity with the famous bread pudding. It's exactly what we needed on a cold night in Indianapolism
Great food and excellent service! Harry and Izzy's is such a unique Indianapolis gem and I'm always excited to dine here with family and friends.
The food was exceptional, our server was great and knowledgeable The price was expected to be premium, but was a bit higher than expected.
Took my wife for her Birthday. Food & service were great. There is a reason this place is our go to for celebratory events!
Absolutely love Harry & Izzy's. Excellent food and wonderful location. The service was less than we are used to but overall, a great visit and meal.
The atmosphere is relaxing and very classy. Our waiter was exceptional! The food was fabulous. We had a perfect dining experience!!! A very memorable anniversary dinner!
Lovely setting in the dining room and fun festive setting in St Nick’s Lodge. Great service, cocktails and best prime rib sandwich ever!
Excellent food, great atmosphere, great service. I had the ribeye filet. My grandsons both had the specupial of the day which was “halfway dry aged ribeye. All very tasty and perfectly cooked. One of my grandsons (in his twenties) said he thought it was probably the most tender steak he had ever eaten.
Great experience, excellent service all around, and the food was delicious. Our party had a few kids and the staff was great with them. Their kids menu is excellent also. Will be back
Restaurantji Recommends
We three besties were celebrating 2 birthdays and had the best time! Our server (I forget his name) added to the fun!
The experience that we had was okay, but we paid a very luxury price for it. Steak was poorly cooked and badly marinated. Most food felt under seasoned except the bread. We also had a near miss with an undisclosed allergen, and at previous experiences at a similar price point our servers have made a point to ask about allergies and dietary restrictions
Way over priced. Ordered the Scallops meal for $50 and got 3 scallops, decent amount of Orzo and undercooked Bocilini. Yes 3 scallops for $50. Filet Sliders were great and a good value.
We sat at the bar for a Saturday noon reservation and had great service from Ryan. Drinks are pricey but good, and love the lunch Parlay option which offers 4 items for $25 that can include shrimp cocktail, soup or salad, filet sliders or salmon, and fries or homemade chips. It's a good value and excellent food. We celebrated a birthday too and shared a free dessert. Highly recommend!!
Service was fantastic. Serge was amazing and made sure our experience was great. My steak was overcooked and my wife's was a little undercooked but they had good flavor and the sides were amazing. Definitely recommend and will be back.
Loading...