Jack's Pizza

Name: Jack's Pizza
Address: 5650 E 86th St, Indianapolis, Indiana, 46250, US
Telephone: (317) 841-1966
Price range: $
Rating: 3.9

$ • Pizza, Italian

Hours:
5650 E 86th St, Indianapolis
(317) 841-1966

Menu Order Online

About Jack's Pizza

Jack's Pizza offers a distinctive and flavorful pizza experience, with plentiful and fresh toppings and a tasty, sturdy crust. The restaurant's service is commendable, with a lively and communicative crew who delivers high-quality pizzas. While it may be on the pricier side, the quality justifies the cost. The "Big Jack" (Supreme) pizza is a popular choice. It is recommended to arrive in a timely manner for pick-up to ensure the pizza is received hot and fresh. Parking can be limited, with some spots allocated to nearby shops. The restaurant is worth visiting, even if seating is not available.

Customers highlight the thin crust and generous toppings, with some enjoying the pizza cut in a grid for easier eating. The "Big Jack" and other options like sausage and pepperoni are prepared quickly, often within 30 minutes. Many visitors find the pizza phenomenal and well worth the visit, praising the friendly and polite staff. Vegetarian options like the Jack Rabbit pizza, which is loaded with vegetables, are also appreciated.

The staff are known for being very good, with some reviews mentioning that even when delivery was late, they re-made and delivered hot food. Longtime customers appreciate the consistency and the nostalgic feeling of the Castleton location, where the pizza is always made with lots of toppings and delicious taste. The pizza is often described as loaded with toppings on a thin, tavern-style crust, especially the supreme variety, which is fresh and packed.

Overall, Jack's Pizza provides a casual, tasty experience that keeps customers coming back, especially for their loaded specialty pizzas. It is highly recommended for those who love toppings and want a flavorful, hearty pizza.