Jimmy John's

1437 E 86th St, Indianapolis
(317) 475-0251

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Erika

I ordered extra provolone cheese didn't get it. I added extra cheddar, didn't look like extra like I've ordered before. I also added extra shaved parmasean & there was none on my sandwich. Plus I told the gentleman who delivered it, thank you and he didn't even respond.🙄 My sandwich was not how I've had it before. 😶

Food: 1

Service: 1

BabyGrandma

I was up north on an assignment during lunch time. I was headed to Skyline Chili but really had a hankering for a Jimmy John's sandwich but had no clue where one was when at a red light, on 86th st, I saw a Jimmy John's right next to me so I made a b-line for it. I sure wasn't sorry I did either. I got the JJ Gargantuan, I think it was called, I really don't remember for sure but it was huge. This sandwich was delicious and fed 3 adults with a little leftover. I wish there was a Jimmy John's closer to my home. The closest restaurant to my home is almost 4 1/2 miles away. Still close enough if I'm already out shopping but not close enough for delivery. Maybe one day there will be a location in the Christian Park/ Irvington area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Inna Shvets

I came to Jimmy John’s for one reason and one reason only: the pickle. Not the sandwich (though it’s fine), not the chips, but for THE PICKLE. That’s why I didn’t go to some other place. I placed my order, they handed me the bag, and I left. Long drive, I’m tired, I trusted them. Big mistake. I get home… no pickle. None. The entire reason for my visit, GONE. Do you know what it’s like to mentally prepare your taste buds for a pickle and then have that dream ripped away??!! If you want to feel deep, soul-crushing disappointment, come to this location. They’ll happily send you home pickle-less😭

Food: 2

Service: 1

Ryan Lewis

The chicken bacon ranch sub is not that great. The chicken tastes really weird and needs double the ranch dressing to mask the bad taste. Should have stuck with my go-to...the Vito.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Maggie McLean

Slowest Jimmy John’s I have ever been to. Employees are also extremely unattentive.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Florida Hurson

Great service,I usually get my meal delivered,almost in 10- 15 minutes!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Country Club

Growth Foundry

Jimmy John's has the best bread of all the sub places. Get the peppers on your sandwich! They have great flavor and don't add too much heat. This JJ's always has good service and they get the sandwiches made fast.

I love this one for a quick lunch that isn't too heavy. The beach club with the peppers is my favorite.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Beach Club

Wanda Sims

Basic sub sandwich, nothing to write home about. Decent for a quick bite.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Beach Club

Amanda H.

Last time I went, it was my birthday. They had given me a free sandwich in the app. I ordered a Hunter's Club & it was DELICIOUS!!! The man that fixed it was very careful to make my sandwich exactly the way I ordered it. He was reading from the receipt that they print out to make your sandwich. I love watching them make my sandwich. I got almost all the freebies on it. It was so big that I shared it with my husband, and it filled us up.

Vegetarian options: Don't forget the freebies😋❣️I love adding extra freebies!!

Parking: There is always parking available directly in front of the door. If you park there you can almost touch the door handle from your car😉.

Kid-friendliness: What kid doesn't love a sandwich, chips, & dessert?

Wheelchair accessibility: There is no button to press that opens. You would need to pull the handle. I'm sure anyone would open it for you to come in. The friendly staff may even come from behind the counter. You could probably even call and tell them that you are coming and that you will need someone to hold the door open for you because you are in a wheelchair. Once you get inside, you will find that there is plenty of room.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Regular Jimmy Chips, Oatmeal Raisin Cookie, Vito, Beach Club, Giant the J J Gargantuan, Country Club, Jumbo Kosher Dill Pickle, Giant 9 Italian Night Club

Matt

Jacked the prices up AGAIN. The main guy is super friendly but I'm not paying these prices for a sandwich, you're crazy. Jets is 7$ for a pizza box and a drink across the street

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Grace Harding

Red headed girl who rang us up tonight and made our sandwiches had a terrible attitude. Sandwiches were missing ingredients and were not evenly distributed (all cheese on one half none on the other). Won’t be returning to this location.

Nick Strain

Why is a place that advertises “freaky fast DELIVERY” always operating on Uber eats delivery instead of having their own drivers? Pretty sad that the one thing they advertise in their slogan is now outsourced and takes so long, I might as well order food from

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

van gogh

the employees are just talking about my sick color and about me right in-front of me while making my order. looks like bunch of high school kids acting like gangsters. I just took my food and left quite because was thinking in my head at least i am not working at a fast-food place. Extremely disappointed. just sad

Brian Mullins

No one in the drive thru line and the guy at the speakers tells me, "it will be 10 mins before we can even make your order". Pathetic, you all need to change that slogan to, "freaky slow".

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

drrtm

I go out of my way to go to this location.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...