What a wonderful local caterer! Friendly, responsive staff, fantastic food for luncheon buffet (the carrot souffle was particularly a hit), and reasonably priced services. Would definitely hire them again.
Michelle Karl
We contacted Mills about doing our wedding reception. We wanted plated dinner because of some elderly family members, a buffet would have been difficult for them to manage. Mills had the most reasonable approach to handling the process (I won't name names but another caterer budgeted 10 hours with all the extra hands for serving the plated dinner because they couldn't leave before the event ended. Talk about crazy!) And they had a reasonable price.I will say, we had some issues getting responses to our questions. However, we were emailing directly with the owner because he was shorthanded at the time. In the end, the event went flawlessly, so this didn't turn out to be an issue but it did cause some stress in the beginning.Matt was great at the tasting and the food was amazing. We were blown away by the salmon and the vegatable lasagna (no, really, that was my second favorite!). The sides were great and we loved the ahi tuna hors d'oeuvre. We were underwhelmed by one of our first choices for hors d'oeuvres so we switched it out during the taste testing meeting to one he recommended (pear and sausage skewers). We didn't get to try them until the event, but they were also amazing! They also made accommodations for our two lactose intolerant friends, which was appreciated.The staff at the event were wonderful. They did a great job passing the hors d'oeuvres during cocktail hour. They also preset the salads and the presentation was beautiful. There were a variety of rolls which was fun.The lead staff member for the evening checked on us twice (I wish I remembered her name!) And was very thoughtful, anticipating our needs before we did.The servers got all the tables their food fairly quickly, and everyone enjoyed their meals.Mills beat my expectations and their great staff and food contributed to the magical evening. We would highly recommend Mills for your wedding (or any event really).
Autumn Burris Manuel
The BEST caterer to use in Indy, hands down! Matt helped us to craft the perfect menu for our wedding celebration and everything was amazing! We received SO many compliments about how fantastic the food was and have referred Mills Catering to many of our friends. We will absolutely use in the future for other events, as the quality of food and attention to detail is incredible. Highly recommend for any event!
Katt Hawthorne
My husband Andy and I chose Mills Catering for our wedding in September of 2021. We had growing concerns while vendor shopping because all of the rescheduled events from 2020 meant that many vendors' calendars were already filling up for 2021. We therefore realized that it would be best to act quickly and choose our vendors without procrastinating. Luckily, that was supremely easy in the case of Mills Catering. They were the only catering vendor that we interviewed, and the only one that we needed to.Everything about our experience with Mills was simply amazing. The food at our wedding was just as delicious as the samples at our tasting. The staff were expert service providers who executed their work with confidence and calm, both of which were indispensable in the hectic wedding atmosphere. The price for everything was more affordable than many of the other caterers I researched. We absolutely recommend Mills Catering to anyone planning an event. Matt Mills and his team with do everything they can to ensure that your day is simply perfect.
Kelsey George
Mills Catering did an amazing job for our wedding! They go above and beyond to make sure the food is everything you want it to be. We received so many compliments from our guests on how great the food was!
Haley Logan
Mills Catering is the best. I have used for countless business lunches, whether informal between colleagues, or hosting large stakeholders and I've never been letdown. He is professional, fast to respond and very understanding. Will be a lifelong customer. Thank you!
Mary Dickson
Mills Catering provided hors d'oeuvres and plated meals for our wedding, and they were incredible! We had three different hors d'oeuvres and three different meal options for our guests (150 guests). The feedback that we got from our guests on all of the different foods were highly positive! The entire team was professional and kind, and everyone was served in a timely manner. I highly recommend Mills Catering if you're in need of catering services!
Mark Paul
Can't say enough good things about Mills and the on-site manager Amanda. They catered my daughter's wedding at Laurel Hall in June 2022 and did a fantastic job. Highly recommend.
Jonathan Kafoure
My wife and I highly recommend Mills Catering. They went above and beyond our expectations. Service was great, and after the wedding people commented on the quality of the food-- it was excellent! Would gladly hire them again.
LaDonna Broadstreet
Mills Catering made our company picnic the best!!! The food was fresh and flavorful! Everyone was happy with their food, especially my bosses! Thank you!!!!
Mills Catering did an outstanding job for our daughter's wedding (115 guests). The food was excellent and the serving staff did a superb job before, during, and after the reception. Highly recommend! Thanks Jessie and Nancy for all your hard work!
Heidi Stone
Absolutely loved the food! My wedding guests were amazed by the amount of food and quality! I highly recommend using Mills Catering for any occasion!
Chris Branson
Mills Catering was willing to assist us at our fine home on short notice- great food and a nice bar service. Excellent service all the way around. Thank you!
Ginny W.
Matt was fantastic to work with, we communicated mostly by email and he was able to execute the menu we had chosen so well. The chicken and waffle skewers were a huge hit as were the mini beef tenderloin sliders and beef wellington. Also something to repeat were the stuffed mushrooms. It earned rave reviews at the party and people kept coming back to munch...thank you!
Elizabeth C.
This is one of the most consistently amazing caterers in Indy! The food and service are unmatched. Recently I attended an event where they created the most delicious gluten-free and vegetarian meal and it was by far the best catered meal I've ever had at any event in any city. Incredibly well-done cauliflower steak with creamy risotto and lavender roasted carrots ... usually vegetarians can be left with kind of mediocre meals at events and add a gluten allergy to it and the meal is almost always underwhelming. The care and thought that went into creating this meal was like nothing I've ever seen before. Cannot recommend Matt, Jessie, and the Mills team more highly!
What a wonderful local caterer! Friendly, responsive staff, fantastic food for luncheon buffet (the carrot souffle was particularly a hit), and reasonably priced services. Would definitely hire them again.
We contacted Mills about doing our wedding reception. We wanted plated dinner because of some elderly family members, a buffet would have been difficult for them to manage. Mills had the most reasonable approach to handling the process (I won't name names but another caterer budgeted 10 hours with all the extra hands for serving the plated dinner because they couldn't leave before the event ended. Talk about crazy!) And they had a reasonable price.I will say, we had some issues getting responses to our questions. However, we were emailing directly with the owner because he was shorthanded at the time. In the end, the event went flawlessly, so this didn't turn out to be an issue but it did cause some stress in the beginning.Matt was great at the tasting and the food was amazing. We were blown away by the salmon and the vegatable lasagna (no, really, that was my second favorite!). The sides were great and we loved the ahi tuna hors d'oeuvre. We were underwhelmed by one of our first choices for hors d'oeuvres so we switched it out during the taste testing meeting to one he recommended (pear and sausage skewers). We didn't get to try them until the event, but they were also amazing! They also made accommodations for our two lactose intolerant friends, which was appreciated.The staff at the event were wonderful. They did a great job passing the hors d'oeuvres during cocktail hour. They also preset the salads and the presentation was beautiful. There were a variety of rolls which was fun.The lead staff member for the evening checked on us twice (I wish I remembered her name!) And was very thoughtful, anticipating our needs before we did.The servers got all the tables their food fairly quickly, and everyone enjoyed their meals.Mills beat my expectations and their great staff and food contributed to the magical evening. We would highly recommend Mills for your wedding (or any event really).
The BEST caterer to use in Indy, hands down! Matt helped us to craft the perfect menu for our wedding celebration and everything was amazing! We received SO many compliments about how fantastic the food was and have referred Mills Catering to many of our friends. We will absolutely use in the future for other events, as the quality of food and attention to detail is incredible. Highly recommend for any event!
My husband Andy and I chose Mills Catering for our wedding in September of 2021. We had growing concerns while vendor shopping because all of the rescheduled events from 2020 meant that many vendors' calendars were already filling up for 2021. We therefore realized that it would be best to act quickly and choose our vendors without procrastinating. Luckily, that was supremely easy in the case of Mills Catering. They were the only catering vendor that we interviewed, and the only one that we needed to.Everything about our experience with Mills was simply amazing. The food at our wedding was just as delicious as the samples at our tasting. The staff were expert service providers who executed their work with confidence and calm, both of which were indispensable in the hectic wedding atmosphere. The price for everything was more affordable than many of the other caterers I researched. We absolutely recommend Mills Catering to anyone planning an event. Matt Mills and his team with do everything they can to ensure that your day is simply perfect.
Mills Catering did an amazing job for our wedding! They go above and beyond to make sure the food is everything you want it to be. We received so many compliments from our guests on how great the food was!
Mills Catering is the best. I have used for countless business lunches, whether informal between colleagues, or hosting large stakeholders and I've never been letdown. He is professional, fast to respond and very understanding. Will be a lifelong customer. Thank you!
Mills Catering provided hors d'oeuvres and plated meals for our wedding, and they were incredible! We had three different hors d'oeuvres and three different meal options for our guests (150 guests). The feedback that we got from our guests on all of the different foods were highly positive! The entire team was professional and kind, and everyone was served in a timely manner. I highly recommend Mills Catering if you're in need of catering services!
Can't say enough good things about Mills and the on-site manager Amanda. They catered my daughter's wedding at Laurel Hall in June 2022 and did a fantastic job. Highly recommend.
My wife and I highly recommend Mills Catering. They went above and beyond our expectations. Service was great, and after the wedding people commented on the quality of the food-- it was excellent! Would gladly hire them again.
Mills Catering made our company picnic the best!!! The food was fresh and flavorful! Everyone was happy with their food, especially my bosses! Thank you!!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Mills Catering did an outstanding job for our daughter's wedding (115 guests). The food was excellent and the serving staff did a superb job before, during, and after the reception. Highly recommend! Thanks Jessie and Nancy for all your hard work!
Absolutely loved the food! My wedding guests were amazed by the amount of food and quality! I highly recommend using Mills Catering for any occasion!
Mills Catering was willing to assist us at our fine home on short notice- great food and a nice bar service. Excellent service all the way around. Thank you!
Matt was fantastic to work with, we communicated mostly by email and he was able to execute the menu we had chosen so well. The chicken and waffle skewers were a huge hit as were the mini beef tenderloin sliders and beef wellington. Also something to repeat were the stuffed mushrooms. It earned rave reviews at the party and people kept coming back to munch...thank you!
This is one of the most consistently amazing caterers in Indy! The food and service are unmatched. Recently I attended an event where they created the most delicious gluten-free and vegetarian meal and it was by far the best catered meal I've ever had at any event in any city. Incredibly well-done cauliflower steak with creamy risotto and lavender roasted carrots ... usually vegetarians can be left with kind of mediocre meals at events and add a gluten allergy to it and the meal is almost always underwhelming. The care and thought that went into creating this meal was like nothing I've ever seen before. Cannot recommend Matt, Jessie, and the Mills team more highly!