New Bethel Ordinary
8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker
(317) 862-5020
Customers' Favorites
The Nbo Large Sausage Pizza with Extra Cheese
Half and Half Supreme and Meat Lovers Pizza
Breaded Tenderloin and Fries
Traditional Bone in Wings
16-Inch Deluxe Pizza
7-Inch Cheese Pizza
New Bethel Nachos
Tenderloin Strips
Brisket Sandwich
Fried Cauliflower
Menu
Photos
+60 photos
+59 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Placed a carryout order. Food was hot and fresh at the time they told us to pickup. We ordered 2 pizzas. Their pizza is ok. They do not skimp out on the toppings. The only thing keeping thier pizza from being great is the crust. The crust is horrible! flabby, rubbery and chewy. Homemade crust would be a game changer.
Food was awesome. I had the Patty Melt, my son ordered a pizza and a sandwich on a hoagie bun. The portion sizes were generous. Potato salad was very good. Sweet Tea was great. Sausage has a very good taste. Atmosphere and staff were very friendly. I recommend this place. There is also a bar area and outdoor seating.
Our pizza was ready a few minutes after we arrived and it was DELICIOUS!!!!
We do not live near the New Bethel Ordinary, but anytime we are close to that area, we ALWAYS stop and pick up a pizza - it's so, so, so GOOD!!
HIGHLY RECOMMEND