New Bethel Ordinary
8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker
(317) 862-5020
Customers' Favorites
The Nbo Large Sausage Pizza with Extra Cheese
Half and Half Supreme and Meat Lovers Pizza
Breaded Tenderloin and Fries
Traditional Bone in Wings
16-Inch Deluxe Pizza
7-Inch Cheese Pizza
New Bethel Nachos
Tenderloin Strips
Brisket Sandwich
Fried Cauliflower
Menu
Photos
+52 photos
+51 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We ate at New Bethel Ordinary last Sunday after attending the IU/PU game. What a fabulous finish to a great day. The meat lovers pizza was over the top. Highly recommend....wish we could find a place like this in SWFL!!! Great place, TY!
I’m speechless…the pictures does it no justice. We are loyal 3+ year customers of Xtrordinary Pizza down the street but they were closed for the day so we decided to try Ordinary for the first time as we have heard they are better and they admittedly are! LJ and Alley were both great! I tipped 3 of the girls $10 bucks a piece, we will definitely be back!
This was a 16’ half deluxe half meat lovers with extra pizza sauce, cheese and sausage.
This was a 16’ half deluxe half meat lovers with extra pizza sauce, cheese and sausage.
I really prefer locally owned restaurants to chains and the Ordinary is a humdinger. The menu pretty varied but people rave about the Pizzas. I recommend them but I seem to wind up with the tenderloin most of the time. This place is a favorite of the locals so you'll struggle to find parking during peak hours. There's a lot out back, too.
