New York Gourmet Deli
9945 East 21st St, Indianapolis
(317) 429-9754
Customers' Favorites
Philly Cheese Steak and Onion Rings
Chopped Cheese Sandwich Combo
Sweet Chilli Chicken
East Coast Sammie
Honey Bee Sub
Pastrami
Og blt
Menu
Photos
+6 photos
+5 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
My husband heard about NY Gourmet Deli on a Facebook Reel food review. We went on Super Bowl Sunday...as both of us are NOT sports enthusiasts. I got the Philly and he got the Italian. EXCEEDED expectations. 100% will be back! I was especially excited about the variety sodas from Mexico! Too bad they don't have tables, but I understand why.
New York Gourmet Deli absolutely nails it. Their chopped cheese is insane — perfectly seasoned, loaded with flavor, and cooked exactly how it should be. You can tell they don’t rush it or cheap out.
What really makes it stand out is how fresh everything tastes. The bread is soft, warm, and never stale, and the meat is clearly fresh and high quality, not greasy or dry like a lot of other places. Every bite hits.
What really makes it stand out is how fresh everything tastes. The bread is soft, warm, and never stale, and the meat is clearly fresh and high quality, not greasy or dry like a lot of other places. Every bite hits.
You May Also Like
Domino's Pizza - 9935 East 21st St
![]()
Pizza, Chicken Wings
O B's Pizza Pub & Eatery - 2102 N Mitthoefer Rd
![]()
Pizza, Dance Clubs, Pubs, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly
I’ve tried many, and traveled far to do so.
I found NY Gourmet Deli on a Google search and gave it a try.
They had a good menu of sandwiches. I decided to stick with the sandwich I am always chasing.
I ordered the Philly Cheesesteak combo. It was reasonably priced and came prepared right.
I’ll give this sandwich an 10 out of 10. Everything...