Pots & Pans Pie Co.

Ordered on Door Dash. Wasn't super clear that it was frozen. Why would I order a frozen pot pie. From the time I ordered until the time I was going to eat would have been 2 hours. No one wants to run their oven in the summer. Bake it yourself Pot & Pans and serve it hot. If I wanted to bake a pot pie myself, I would have gone to Kroger Also, they said they had the oatmeal cream pies but they were out of stock.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Pots and Pans Pie Co did mini pies for the dessert table at my wedding reception. They were outstanding and many of my guests commented on them. Definitely recommend!

Everything here is either great or amazing. The price may seem a little high but it is well worth it when you eat it. Cannot rate higher.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a slice of rhe creme brulee sugar pie and it was absolutely delicious!! Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delicious. Almond, peach creme pie. So yummy for my first experience.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

I tried the Sugar Creme Brulee Pie and Peaches & Almond Cream Pie. The pies are exceptional with a flaky, buttery crust and well-balanced fillings. There's a wide variety of savory pies also like mac and cheese and pork chili

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I got a the lamb pie from the broad ripple farmer market. I had high hopes because I love lamb. But this pie STINKS! The meat does not taste great at all and there’s only 1 piece of meat inside. It’s filled 98% of just the sauce and some beans. Do not recommend. What a ripoff

Food: 1

10/10 no notes. Pots & Pans should have a Michelin star. Best pie and pot pie I've ever had in my life. Also, the crust is perfect (Baked in a buttery, flaky crust, iykyk sorry I had to 😉) It's exactly how pie crust should be. This last visit I got the blueberry pie and the peaches and almond, both are sooo delish. As for pot pie, the OG chicken is my favorite!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

What a disappointment. 3 different items and they were all bad. Creme brule pie was not sweet at all and the top was completely burnt. The Shoofly pie was probably the nastiest thing I have ever eaten and the oatmeal cream pie tasted like an oatmeal cookie with a glob of butter in the middle. The cream had no sweetness at all. We drove over 100 miles to try this place because of TikTok and will never do this again.

Update : we also got a frozen to go Mac and cheese pie. To continue on the disappointment journey. Spoiler: this is not a pot pie at all. Just a pie pan with Mac and cheese in it.

Amazing! You can't go wrong with their pot pie and any dessert! Five years later this review is still accurate. They have great seasonal and rotating dessert pies!

Good pies.

This was one of several places I stopped at in my quest to try as many different sugar cream pies as possible, and while their pie offerings are certainly tasty, I have to say that in terms of bang for buck, I felt I got a lot more at a number of other places. I do love that they offer some unique pie flavors that you don't see anywhere else, but for me to fully justify the price they charge per slice, I'd have to be pretty blown away, and I just wasn't. I had a slice of sugar cream and a slice of pineapple passionfruit, and my brother had the butterscotch, and we both agreed that it was some good pie, but not anything we'd consider standout, and therefore not quite worth the fairly high price they charge in our opinions.

Fast service! And yummy food! My first time coming here! Glad i did the food was really good and fresh tasting! We got the most popular, the classic chicken! 10/10! The cost is kinda higher for 6” -$13. But its homemade so its worth it. The store is super small so not any seats! The parking is small. But definitely recommend

Perfect pies ✔️ from a cute little shop with friendly people. Seriously, y'all were so patient as I indecisively mulled over which of the many delicious pie options.

We ended up getting a supreme pizza hand pie, and individual slices of the sugar creme brulee and the blackbottom frangipane. My favorite was the creme brulee since I have a sweeter palette but my significant other really liked the frangipane as it was less sweet and had a bit of a kick of salt and depth of flavor. The hand pie was a little different than I was expecting. It was good but definitely for someone who likes cheese on a pizza more than I do, because I love tomato and I was hoping for more of a tomato flavor.

I'm going to need to come back to try the other pies as well as get one of the take-home and bake pies as those seem to be more of the savory hearty variety.

Check out these photos!

I've been wanting to try their pies for a long time. They did not disappoint! Apple pie was a hit with the entire family, even when I wasn't able to reheat it. The oatmeal cream pie was delicious and the mushroom hand pie was excellent.