Acted inconvenienced when I called to make a pickup order. Google stated their hours were till 11 on weekends. Hard to find menu online and apparently no longer sever fried foods. Place needs to close
Joshua Alvino
This is by far the BEST PIZZA I've had in Indiana and being from Florida, I would have to say this is the best quality, best value, most consistent, freshest ingredients, passionately made pizza I've ever had.My family has lived in the Wanamaker Estates area since the late '50s and they have been ordering Randy's for ever.I've heard about it all of my life but only got to try it for the first time about 5 months ago. I've gone and grabbed a pizza at least twice a month since! Great pizza, great service, great value, and great quality.The 16" is huge and feeds my sister and I for at least three separate meals if not four with us each eating 2-4 pieces at a time!I know there may be some not so great reviews about service, but we have NEVER had a bad experience. Just be kind, be patient, and have your order ready when you call and you will have a great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Two Topping Pizza, Randy's Special Pizza
Thomas Maddox
I can't really properly judge their food with this reveiw, but i can say i have tried to call them three times, and i go straight to the answering machine. If anything, the service is
Service: 1
Patricia Hall
All carry out or eat outside, so no atmosphere
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tim Henslee
The only pizza I actually get a craving for.I've ate Randy's Pizzas for close to 50 years.Perfect crust,flavor and value.I'll drive by 4 or 5 pizza places to get a Randy's Pizza
Tamika Freeman
This is by far one of the best Pizzas I’ve had in quite some time!!
Heather R.
We love, Randys pizza! The pizza is amazing! Best pizza in town. Friendly staff! I wish delivery was available more often, but that is my only complaint.
Greg Davidson
They make one of the best pizzas around if you have not had one you need to try one
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Noel Sutton
Decent pizza, incredibly slow. I think they’re just understaffed.
Kathy Miller
Really, atmosphere is irrelevant. Randy's is not a dine in place. They were honest about how long it takes to get a pizza, but it's still too long.
Nice people and great pizza. Waited an hour and a half after being quoted 45 minutes and still paid full price. I love this place but I feel like that's taking advantage.
Jody Knox
I live right around the corner and I just love love this pizza Randy‘s you rock yummy 100% every timeParking: Call it in wait 20 minutes show up pizzas ready awesome customer service delivery pick up I just wish you would open earlier but it’s all good it’s worth the wait☮️ The only problem that I do seem to have it when you call to place an order they’re on the other line with other people and you have to keep calling and keep calling I need to have where you can leave your phone number and you guys call back please that is my biggest concern
J C.
Ok pizza if you are local. They usually only have one person working so answering the phone to take your order is sometimes a challenge. No delivery, and you have to call them when you arrive so they will bring the pizza out to a table for you to pick up. Not high on my chart. There's New Bethel Ordinary, extraordinary, donatos, papa johns, and Godfathers in the area thats more accomodating.
Jim Grady
Had not been to Randys for awhile. Glad we did everyone's loved the pizza. Espically the chicken bbq one.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle A.
Is this place even open anymore. I've called multiple times on multiple days. I get a recording every time.
Acted inconvenienced when I called to make a pickup order. Google stated their hours were till 11 on weekends. Hard to find menu online and apparently no longer sever fried foods. Place needs to close
This is by far the BEST PIZZA I've had in Indiana and being from Florida, I would have to say this is the best quality, best value, most consistent, freshest ingredients, passionately made pizza I've ever had.My family has lived in the Wanamaker Estates area since the late '50s and they have been ordering Randy's for ever.I've heard about it all of my life but only got to try it for the first time about 5 months ago. I've gone and grabbed a pizza at least twice a month since! Great pizza, great service, great value, and great quality.The 16" is huge and feeds my sister and I for at least three separate meals if not four with us each eating 2-4 pieces at a time!I know there may be some not so great reviews about service, but we have NEVER had a bad experience. Just be kind, be patient, and have your order ready when you call and you will have a great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Two Topping Pizza, Randy's Special Pizza
I can't really properly judge their food with this reveiw, but i can say i have tried to call them three times, and i go straight to the answering machine. If anything, the service is
Service: 1
All carry out or eat outside, so no atmosphere
Food: 5
Service: 5
The only pizza I actually get a craving for.I've ate Randy's Pizzas for close to 50 years.Perfect crust,flavor and value.I'll drive by 4 or 5 pizza places to get a Randy's Pizza
This is by far one of the best Pizzas I’ve had in quite some time!!
We love, Randys pizza! The pizza is amazing! Best pizza in town. Friendly staff! I wish delivery was available more often, but that is my only complaint.
They make one of the best pizzas around if you have not had one you need to try one
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Decent pizza, incredibly slow. I think they’re just understaffed.
Really, atmosphere is irrelevant. Randy's is not a dine in place. They were honest about how long it takes to get a pizza, but it's still too long.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Nice people and great pizza. Waited an hour and a half after being quoted 45 minutes and still paid full price. I love this place but I feel like that's taking advantage.
I live right around the corner and I just love love this pizza Randy‘s you rock yummy 100% every timeParking: Call it in wait 20 minutes show up pizzas ready awesome customer service delivery pick up I just wish you would open earlier but it’s all good it’s worth the wait☮️ The only problem that I do seem to have it when you call to place an order they’re on the other line with other people and you have to keep calling and keep calling I need to have where you can leave your phone number and you guys call back please that is my biggest concern
Ok pizza if you are local. They usually only have one person working so answering the phone to take your order is sometimes a challenge. No delivery, and you have to call them when you arrive so they will bring the pizza out to a table for you to pick up. Not high on my chart. There's New Bethel Ordinary, extraordinary, donatos, papa johns, and Godfathers in the area thats more accomodating.
Had not been to Randys for awhile. Glad we did everyone's loved the pizza. Espically the chicken bbq one.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Is this place even open anymore. I've called multiple times on multiple days. I get a recording every time.