I found this from an ad on Instagram and I was so excited. It would have helped to know this was set up like the Amazon lockers. This is not a traditional restaurant where you sit down and eat your food. Be warned this is very automated... Now this is not a bad thing. But ordering your food online or on a kiosk is how you make orders. With that being said I'm pretty tech savvy I had no problems. The food came quick.. My friend who was with me ordered his online a few minutes later. His food was delivered maybe 15 minutes after mine. Now I have to say the food was okay. It is not some amazing make you want to go back and talk to the chef great. But the food is okay. I have to admit it's a lot of butter. To the point your food is soaking in butter. Flavor-wise crab boils have way more flavor. But it is very much so seasoned. Like I said I would never call this food nasty. But I will say it's okay. I probably won't go back because the food was just okay. This is more pricey food also. Overall not a bad experience. Oh when I got home I did realize I ordered corn and eggs but I didn't receive any corn. ?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Potato & Egg Bowl w Smothered Corn on the Cobb
Shana Vanover
We drove to Indy to try this place and it did not disappoint. 1st, the owner handed our food directly to us on pickup. The hospitality is endearing, you don’t get that most places.2nd, you can tell it’s made with LOVE. That butter is so good. It’s not like other seafood boil places popular lately, and I love that. Those are good too, but it’s completely different with the real butter. Feels like my auntie or mom made it, like a warm hug.3rd, the seafood was cooked perfectly.And finally, the amount of food for the price compared to other seafood places was fantastic. I would absolutely recommend the meal with the lb of crab, half of shrimp and sausage and it comes with potatoes, corn, and eggs all for only $60. My only tiny, tiny criticism would be to use fresh corn, as it was a bit soggy (like frozen gets) but, that could very well be due to the time of year here and corns not in season. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Legs
Mighty Bogan
We came through tonight and got two meals of crab potato sausage and shrimp. Every thing was so good and cooked great. No overdone crab or shrimp which we get alot at other places. The sauce goes amazing with everything. Don't sleep on this place. You also have to get an extra butter for dipping.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marcus Noel
The best food in Indianapolis!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cocreate 2
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nichole Mcgee
I ordered the catfish meal and it was overwhelming salty. This was my first time ordering here. Just a suggestion to get the container with the 3 departments. The fish was salty and made the potatoes extra salty . I’m about to drink a gallon of water .
Food: 2
Keema Watson
Food was great! Everything was perfectly done.??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Legs, Potatoes
Natalie G.
I've had takeout from here and it is so delicious! I bought the crab cracker kit, but it wasn't needed for the crab legs as they are already cracked. Everything is drenched in Tiff's Love Butta. It is finger licking good!!!!!!
Jen K.
Delicious food! This place is take out only. You order at the iPad and wait for it in a small room. Loved the crab legs - I just wish they were a little pre-cracked so that they could marinate in the butter/seasoning and also be easier to open! The shrimp was also amazing. Reasonably priced! Would come back.
Kelly J.
Yummy yummy in my tummy! Food was awesome! I can't wait to come back! Service was great!
Miss Tiff. I love you! The crab leg shrimp sausage corn egg potato combo was the best thing i ever ate?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mylissa Compton
I used to review food shortly after eating but I've learned to wait to determine if the food was actually really that good or was I just hungry. Well Tiff's Love Butta is THAT good. I got the Salmon, 1/2 shrimp, corn and egg dinner with extra potatoes based on other reviews. Let me tell you the food was so full of flavor I was smacking my lips, thank goodness I was in the privacy of my own home. The salmon and shrimp were cooked to perfection. You can tell she really loves cooking for her customers. Those potatoes...OMG I'm glad I ordered extra because I would be mad if I dint have potatoes for my leftover meal. That's right I was given enough food for TWO meals. I love food and my waistline shows it but there was no way José I could of ate all the food I received in one sitting. The corn and the egg were delicious as well. If you are hungry for some GREAT seafood please check out Tiff's Love Butta Baked Seafood you won't be disappointed. I need to order soon so I can try the lambchops....mmmm!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah W.
If you love your seafood baked, this is the place to go. I had ordered a small portion just to try it and boy did I make a mistake. I needed more as soon as I was finished. It was so good and especially when you get some of that extra butta. Baby let me tell you, it's the truth. My mouth is watering just thinking about it. The eggs that I had with my crab legs was sealed with flavor and wasn't all hard or soggy. It was easy to tear into those legs and eat Roth up. It was nice that there is an option to order yourself a cracking kit. I was at work on my lunch and was needing those tools. Bottom line is, stop stalling and go get you some of her food!
Tiffany R.
Best Baked Seafood I've ever had! I will never eat a boil again. Baked is more Flavorful and less messy. And that Tiff's Love Butta butta sauce is DELICIOUS!!!
702weak ..
Wow! Amazing platter. So I ordered thee Salmon 1/2 shrimp with potatoes and corn. It was really good and the taste was very on point ... I should have ordered more lemon but overall it was really good. My food was ordered through doordash and arrived one hour later and was still hot and tasty.
I found this from an ad on Instagram and I was so excited. It would have helped to know this was set up like the Amazon lockers. This is not a traditional restaurant where you sit down and eat your food. Be warned this is very automated... Now this is not a bad thing. But ordering your food online or on a kiosk is how you make orders. With that being said I'm pretty tech savvy I had no problems. The food came quick.. My friend who was with me ordered his online a few minutes later. His food was delivered maybe 15 minutes after mine. Now I have to say the food was okay. It is not some amazing make you want to go back and talk to the chef great. But the food is okay. I have to admit it's a lot of butter. To the point your food is soaking in butter. Flavor-wise crab boils have way more flavor. But it is very much so seasoned. Like I said I would never call this food nasty. But I will say it's okay. I probably won't go back because the food was just okay. This is more pricey food also. Overall not a bad experience. Oh when I got home I did realize I ordered corn and eggs but I didn't receive any corn. ?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Potato & Egg Bowl w Smothered Corn on the Cobb
We drove to Indy to try this place and it did not disappoint. 1st, the owner handed our food directly to us on pickup. The hospitality is endearing, you don’t get that most places.2nd, you can tell it’s made with LOVE. That butter is so good. It’s not like other seafood boil places popular lately, and I love that. Those are good too, but it’s completely different with the real butter. Feels like my auntie or mom made it, like a warm hug.3rd, the seafood was cooked perfectly.And finally, the amount of food for the price compared to other seafood places was fantastic. I would absolutely recommend the meal with the lb of crab, half of shrimp and sausage and it comes with potatoes, corn, and eggs all for only $60. My only tiny, tiny criticism would be to use fresh corn, as it was a bit soggy (like frozen gets) but, that could very well be due to the time of year here and corns not in season. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Legs
We came through tonight and got two meals of crab potato sausage and shrimp. Every thing was so good and cooked great. No overdone crab or shrimp which we get alot at other places. The sauce goes amazing with everything. Don't sleep on this place. You also have to get an extra butter for dipping.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best food in Indianapolis!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered the catfish meal and it was overwhelming salty. This was my first time ordering here. Just a suggestion to get the container with the 3 departments. The fish was salty and made the potatoes extra salty . I’m about to drink a gallon of water .
Food: 2
Food was great! Everything was perfectly done.??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Legs, Potatoes
I've had takeout from here and it is so delicious! I bought the crab cracker kit, but it wasn't needed for the crab legs as they are already cracked. Everything is drenched in Tiff's Love Butta. It is finger licking good!!!!!!
Delicious food! This place is take out only. You order at the iPad and wait for it in a small room. Loved the crab legs - I just wish they were a little pre-cracked so that they could marinate in the butter/seasoning and also be easier to open! The shrimp was also amazing. Reasonably priced! Would come back.
Yummy yummy in my tummy! Food was awesome! I can't wait to come back! Service was great!
Restaurantji Recommends
Miss Tiff. I love you! The crab leg shrimp sausage corn egg potato combo was the best thing i ever ate?
Food: 5
Service: 5
I used to review food shortly after eating but I've learned to wait to determine if the food was actually really that good or was I just hungry. Well Tiff's Love Butta is THAT good. I got the Salmon, 1/2 shrimp, corn and egg dinner with extra potatoes based on other reviews. Let me tell you the food was so full of flavor I was smacking my lips, thank goodness I was in the privacy of my own home. The salmon and shrimp were cooked to perfection. You can tell she really loves cooking for her customers. Those potatoes...OMG I'm glad I ordered extra because I would be mad if I dint have potatoes for my leftover meal. That's right I was given enough food for TWO meals. I love food and my waistline shows it but there was no way José I could of ate all the food I received in one sitting. The corn and the egg were delicious as well. If you are hungry for some GREAT seafood please check out Tiff's Love Butta Baked Seafood you won't be disappointed. I need to order soon so I can try the lambchops....mmmm!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you love your seafood baked, this is the place to go. I had ordered a small portion just to try it and boy did I make a mistake. I needed more as soon as I was finished. It was so good and especially when you get some of that extra butta. Baby let me tell you, it's the truth. My mouth is watering just thinking about it. The eggs that I had with my crab legs was sealed with flavor and wasn't all hard or soggy. It was easy to tear into those legs and eat Roth up. It was nice that there is an option to order yourself a cracking kit. I was at work on my lunch and was needing those tools. Bottom line is, stop stalling and go get you some of her food!
Best Baked Seafood I've ever had! I will never eat a boil again. Baked is more Flavorful and less messy. And that Tiff's Love Butta butta sauce is DELICIOUS!!!
Wow! Amazing platter. So I ordered thee Salmon 1/2 shrimp with potatoes and corn. It was really good and the taste was very on point ... I should have ordered more lemon but overall it was really good. My food was ordered through doordash and arrived one hour later and was still hot and tasty.