Tilly's Tea Room
8701 E 116th St Suite 140B, Fishers
(317) 537-2185
Customers' Favorites
Afternoon Tea
Scone
Menu
Photos
+95 photos
+94 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I made reservations for 4 online several weeks in advance. When we arrived, on time, we could not get a table for over 5 minutes even though there were 2 tables that were empty that seated 4. I finally asked to be seated at one of them and we got seated. Not enough staff and it took quite awhile before we were able to order and then again before the food arrived. Food was good but nothing special. My group of 4 will sadly not be returning to this establishment.
We had a lovely tea at Tilly's. We did high tea and the sandwiches were delicious. We got so full we couldn't make it past 1/2 a scone. Tea service was lovely. And the atmosphere of the tea room is chic and feels upscale next generation high tea. Holly, our server, was an absolute delighted and provided for an elevated experience.
Holly was an amazing help in determining what we ordered for food and tea as well as a wonderful ambassador in sharing about the story behind Tilly's Tea Room and Max & Tilly's right next door. Say yes to the bread pudding/blueberry spotted dick- delicious!
You May Also Like
The Cheesecake Factory - 8701 Keystone Crossing Suite 4A
![]()
American, Seafood, Vegan
Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - 8702 Keystone Crossing
![]()
Hamburger, Burgers, Vegetarian, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Fast Food