Tony's of Indianapolis

Great food and awesome staff. Our server Adrian was great and very attentive and informative.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Here for volleyball tournament and stopped in for dinner. Adrian was our waitress and was amazing. Great food, great atmosphere!
😃

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Friendly staff and solid. Both the tuna and crab cake were awesome

We ate here for Father's Day. Service was great. (There weren't very many customers.) Food was very good. I was disappointed when I ordered au gratin potatoes. Told first there were only a couple of servings remaining but more would be available so I said I'd wait for fresh. Then, no more au gratin potatoes. I suspect they didn't want to prepare another pan since there were so few customers.

Staff member filling water glasses offered to box the remaining portion of my (wonderful) salad but this morning I see that the salad didn't make it home with the rest of our leftovers. I was very disappointed that I couldn't get the potatoes I wanted for dinner and that I didn't get all our leftovers to eat for dinner tonight.

Certainly not what I expected from a restaurant that claims to be superior to St. Elmo's.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

This is an elegant restaurant with top notch service. The filet mignon was the best I have ever had - anywhere.

It was a big decision to choose a steakhouse for our anniversary. We chose Tony’s. I put in the reservation that it was our 27th wedding anniversary and that also we were celebrating a big promotion. I was hoping that they would say something to my wife or wish us a happy anniversary but that didn’t happen. Instead the manager of the restaurant talked to the older couple next to us for over minutes about their wedding anniversary. He asked us if our food was ok and we said yes. At other steakhouses we have received small desserts or at least the manager stopped by and said thanks for choosing them for our special day. We almost chose another steakhouse. Definitely will go some place else for our 28th.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Today was my first visit at Tony’s. Our server Alyssa was excellent. Hosts and other wait staff were excellent. Food was phenomenal. Greek salad was delicious. I will order with extra olives next time as I could eat those like potato chips. The herb aoli served with the truffle fries is amazing. Our group ordered a crab cake starter, Greek salad starter, 2 different steaks, and salmon. Everything was cooked perfectly. Decent price for a fine dining establishment. Great if you want to treat yourself.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

a first. stack of dinner plates fall next to me, i can feel fragments on my leg, and the crashing sound would be enough for a 'fight or flight' feeling.

needless to say, the adrenaline and trigger was enough to lose my appetite completely.

really not sure how to rate this location. really didn't get to taste the food, had one drink, even if the server was great, but the person who knocked over the plates...

looked like a really quiet upscale place.

can't recommend this restaurant at this time.

Go somewhere else. We always get great service other places like Oceanaire, go on Sunday's and ask for Greg in the bar area, St. Elmo's or Del Frisco's both have amazing steaks. This place is just sad, none of the employees seem to want to be there. The restaurant was dead on a Friday night at peak time. Took a friend here for his birthday and they could not bother to comp a $12
dessert on a $400+ meal for 2 people. They would have more customers if they could take care of the few they have.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The 12oz Filet with horseradish and chive butter was amazing! Thier Brussels sprouts were delicious also!

Great food but mediocre service. Had to wait 30 minutes and 3 requests for bread and one person never got his second drink. Very disappointed given what it costs.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 2

Excellent atmosphere. Very friendly waitstaff. Huge, huge portions. Great food. Waitress found out it was my birthday and gave me a free dessert plus a nice discount on appetizers. Will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We dined here on Saturday with another couple, and while the food was delicious—as it usually is—the overall experience fell flat due to the service.

Our server, Jay, took an unusually long time to greet us, even just for drink orders. We were all pretty hungry and wanted to start with bread, but he didn’t return to the table, so we had to ask another employee. When he finally came back, he told us they aren’t allowed to provide bread until after orders are taken and menus are removed, which felt unnecessarily rigid and frustrating in the moment.

Unfortunately, things didn’t improve as the evening went on. At the end of the meal, he brought a single check without asking, despite it being clearly two couples. When we asked to split it, the revised checks were incorrect—items were added that no one ordered, and everything was mixed up, which made the process drag on even longer.

The food remains consistently excellent, but this is an expensive restaurant, and we expected a much higher level of service. Overall, the inattentiveness and confusion with the checks left us disappointed and made what should have been a great night feel underwhelming.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Atmosphere was great. Staff was knowledgeable, professional and had a funny side (which i appreciate). Food was very good. I ordered the bone in ribeye. It was cooked perfectly for me,(medium-well). I also ordered the ceaser salad. My only criticism, is the steak lack a little seasoning. I expected a little more after the waitress raved about how seasoned their steaks are. Not a huge deal. I was there for a business meeting, but I'll return with my wife soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very loud. Hard to hear the server. Hard to hear anything even eachother. This was our 3rd time an probly the worst time. We never got bread or butter. Food was good an cooked correctly. The oysters were expensive for the quality several of them had hard pieces hit my tooth. Wrong drink was served. Most issues likely due to the noise level an not able to communicate. Also outside an entry way there was an awful smell.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3