The Original Fish of Stroh
$ • Seafood
Hours:
4230 S 1175 E, LaGrange
(260) 351-4600
About The Original Fish of Stroh
Customers' Favorites
The Original Fish of Stroh Reviews
Share your opinion about The Original Fish of Stroh
Me and my fiance visited for the first time last night and we will never be back! We got the fish dinner thinking we were going to eat pretty good. Fish was way over cooked and dry doesn't explain how dry it really was. The salad bar is extremely weak. Lettuce, cheese, and dressing. No other options. The "loaded" baked potato consisted of a half baked potato that was so hard in the middle with some butter, sour cream, bacon that tasted like it sat on the counter for 3 days and...read full review
Great food, All you can eat fish was awesome! Fair price too. Service was spot on as well. We'll be back soon with a bunch of friends. We ate on the bar side but there's a large family room too. Clean & cozy little piece of Indiana history! 5 stars!
Well worth the hour drive!
Amazing gluten-free options and my husband loved his as well!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 7PM |
The Original Fish of Stroh offers a warm, homey atmosphere for diners seeking a delicious seafood experience. Guests can enjoy a variety of homemade dishes, with the fish dinner standing out as a highlight. Many visitors consider the fish superior to any other, with some traveling from far away just to enjoy it. The tarter sauce is notably flavorful, and the hush puppies are sweet, crunchy, and highly recommended. The all-you-can-eat option is popular, and some customers have even driven or flown long distances to taste the fish, feeling truly blessed and full afterward. The service is friendly and helpful, though it can sometimes be slow, and on occasion, the waitstaff may forget to bring salads or bills, requiring a bit of follow-up. Despite occasional concerns about the restaurant's appearance or prices, the consistent quality of the fish makes it a favorite spot for many.