Fisherman's island

429 81st Ave, Merrillville
(219) 750-9111

Recent Reviews

Sort by
J McF

Too costly for the small portions

Gail Thomas

I don't even know if they have eat in.We got our shrimp to go and aided in the car.It was great.

Anne Aiken-VZ

I love the fact that all the food is steamed, not fried. The food is fresh & deliciously seasoned if you wish.

Nitapooh Jelks

Ist time love it... Got 2 snow crab & shrimp & corn Cajun
Sausage suck ass tho

Queen W

Food was over cooked could’ve been much better

Antonio Madera

Is so good!!!

Marcella Griffith

I ordered #14 ( jerk seasonings) and when I say flavor-less that’s an understatement. I need the salt and pepper right now.
Also #16 with salmon (house seasoned) the salmon is dry and no flavor. Even the butter sauce is flavor-less.
I’ve ordered from the one on Broadway in Gary and had the same issue. It’s really hard to enjoy when it tastes like nothing. I gave it several attempts with the same result I won’t be back

BigWorkHouse Transportation Company LLC

Very Excellent food steamed and vegetables!!!
Clean establishment, friendly staff members and fast!!!

Marlo Stanfield

So, I go into this establishment and order king Crab, I spend close to $200. I simply ask, "the lemons in the bag?" But I'm told by the young African American woman, that "No, you don't have lemon , lemon is EXTRA!!" Wow!! and rude about it! Any other Fisherman Island, I've gone to, this has never been a problem. The employees were professional and courteous. Maybe she needs to be retrained. Now I'm hoping the food lives up to my expectations 😞

Carla Stimage

Not enough season on the seafood.

Phillip Norman

Love it!

Marissa B

Love going for the well seasoned oysters Everytime.

Rae Isabell

The food was "GOOD"

Danny Cross

I love the food here

N OHara

I didn’t appreciate paying $50 for a crab boil and getting old, brown, over cooked crab legs. This the second time this has happened! Won’t get me again!

Loading...