13 Best Bakeries near Middlebury

Country Lane Bakery Bakery • $
59162 Co Rd 43, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Italian Herb & Cheese
Sour Cream Cookies
Jalapeno Cheese
Chocolate Chip
Garlic Cheese
Cinnamon Roll
Whoopie Pies
Pumpkin Roll
Small Pies
Honey Wheat

“I didn’t know it was cash only and when I was $6.00 short, I tried to put something back but another customer insisted I had to have it, and offered to pay for it. As I waited for my items to be bagged, the customer tried to pay but the owner motioned “no” and didn’t take her money so she gave it to me for free. They were the best cinnamon rolls and peanut butter cookies I’ve had in a long time and the customer service was over and beyond.“

5 Superb36 Reviews
Rise'n Roll Bakery & Deli - Middlebury Bakery • $
1065 N 1150 W, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Caramel Donuts
Jellies & Pickled Vegs
Ice Cream Filled Donut
Amish Crack Donuts
Biscuits and Gravy
Cinnamon Rolls
Broccoli Salad
Salad Sandwich
Filled Donuts
Apple Fritter

“Rise ‘n roll is a good place to pick up donuts or dine in and have a casual meal. I have never had a bad thing there. For first timers, you need to try the cinnamon carmel donuts. You should order a dozen, it will be worth it! My favorites are the chocolate covered cashew crunch candy. Lots of things are offered here jams, deli items, cinnamon rolls, noodles, the list goes on!“

4.7 Superb124 Reviews
Essenhaus Bakery Bakery • $
240 US-20, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Microwave Popcorn Bowl
Amish Monster Cookies
Assorted Pastries
Chocolate Brownie
Chicken Dinner
Artisan Bread
Pulled Pork
Pumpkin Pie
Custom Cake
Whoopie Pie

“Great food & servers. We have gone there for years & will go back soon for my 82nd birthday.“

4.4 Superb173 Reviews
Essenhaus Bakery • $$
Wayne St, Middlebury

“Great food & servers. We have gone there for years & will go back soon for my 82nd birthday.“

4.1 Good53 Reviews
Das Dutchman Essenhaus Family • $
240 US-20, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Gift Shop Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes
Fried Chicken Mashed Potatoes and Mozzarella Sticks
Fried Chicken and Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Mashed Potatoes & Gravy Coleslaw
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Pie
Thresher's Breakfast Buffet
Amish Beef & Pork Buffet
Mashed Potatoes Carrots
Bread Dressing & Gravy
Fried Chicken Dinner

“Great food & servers. We have gone there for years & will go back soon for my 82nd birthday.“

4.4 Superb731 Reviews
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery Bakery • $$
195 N Van Buren St, Shipshewana - 6.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Peanut and Apple and on Each Table
Amish Country Sampler Platter
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Sweet Potato Casserole
Amish Sampler Platter
Country Roast Beef
Lemon Meringue Pie
Chicken Dressing
Mashed Potatoes
Meatloaf Dinner

“Amazing Place! Great place to watch a good show.“

4.3 Superb413 Reviews
Shawna Rae's Bakery & Cafe Bakery • $
125 N Harrison St, Shipshewana - 6.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich and 8oz Soup
Turkey Avocado Wrap
Chocolate Ice Cream
Chili Cheese
Cupcake
Gelato

“The food is fantastic! I had a spicy crab bowl that was fresh and very tasty. The stars of this establishment are the cheesecakes! They are delicious and every element is homemade. The staff is friendly and clearly feel passionate and proud of what they do.“

4.9 Superb39 Reviews
Amish Kuntry Fried Pie Bakery •
10750 W 600 S, Millersburg - 9.32 miles

“My son wanted these for his wedding instead of cake. We order 100 hand pies and picked them up the day before the wedding, approximately a 3 hour (6 hours)drive there and back. He was married June 3, 2023 and they were amazing. I would do it again all over.“

5 Superb31 Reviews
Gutierrez Bakery Bakery • $
122 S Main St, Goshen - 9.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bakery

“fresh food. great selection.“

4.9 Superb25 Reviews
Canelé Café Bakery • $
212 W Washington St # 2, Goshen - 9.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pain Au Chocolat
Sticky Bun

“nothing like buying a box of mixed sweet rolls and taking them to a family gathering and cutting them into tiny bites..They wanted a taste of all of them....They were ranting and rating...mmmm so good“

4.8 Superb28 Reviews
Bakers Nook Bakery • $
62019 County Rd 33, Goshen - 6.09 miles
5 Superb13 Reviews
Aunt Millie's Bakery • $
2247 Caragana Ct, Goshen - 9.55 miles
5 Superb12 Reviews
Dutch Maid Bakery Bakery • $
508 W Lincoln Ave C, Goshen - 9.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Sandwich
Chocolate Cake
Birthday Cake
Sugar Cookie
Croissant
Doughnut
Avocado
Cannoli
Panini

“We absolutely love Dutch Maid!! In fact, my husband and I have made it our favorite place to go for our weekly brunch date. We enjoy trying out their new selections of treats, and being amazed by their fun and fantastically decorated sugar cookies that change every few weeks, though we have our standing favorites, too. Plus, many people might not know that they have delicious food, too! Definitely check out their menu. Also, the staff is incredibly friendly, which is part of why we keep going back. The inside atmosphere is very relaxing and cute as well, so we like dining in, but of course you can get your goodies to go, too. We tell people all the time how much we like going to Dutch Maid. Overall, would highly recommend!!

Vegetarian options: On their food menu there are vegetarian options, and of course all their pastries and other sweets.

Parking: About two dozen free parking spaces available right outside

Wheelchair accessibility: No steps and easy to navigate, though no handicap button for the double doors.“

3.6 Good36 Reviews