17 Best Pizza Restaurants near Middlebury

“Very tasty no-frills offerings at great prices. We ordered pizza, a calzone, and a grinder at the counter, then filled our drinks and settled ourselves in a booth. The food came pretty quickly and we were impressed by the generous portions and fresh ingredients.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Yes, in this tiny little town, I had the best pizza I had for years. They do pizza right by heaps of cheese and toppings, not bread! While everyone else props their crust, the bread, Piccadilly Circus Pizza puts the focus where it should be, cheese, cheese, and more cheese. Delicious!“

“Awesome friendly staff, I between Middlebury, Ligonier, and Lagrange pizza hut's Middlebury is the most consistent in quality to me. Haven't gotten one uneven pizza where there are gaps of missing cheese or toppings missing. In my experience.“

“Excellent Italian Food and great Service! Really enjoyed the pizza and the wife enjoyed her lasagna!! Very generous portions! Would highly recommend!! 5 stars out of 5!“

“today was our first time going and it was sooooo good! the service was amazing she explained about some of the items, which I appreciated, and uugh it was just so good! Will definitely go back!“

“We were a group of eight who went in on the Saturday before Christmas at 5:00. We were visiting from Indy and wanted some good pizza. This place did not disappoint! The buffet was constantly stocked and the salad bar had a good variety. Our little kids enjoyed the breadsticks and dessert pizza. Most importantly, we realized on Sunday (after returning to Indy) that we had left our diaper bag at the restaurant. Obviously, we were not going to make the trip back. The owner kindly offered to ship it to us and despite me asking to pay for it, she declined. We were truly so appreciative of this kind gesture. Anytime we are back in shipshewana, we will return for the great food and good service. Thank you for your kindness during the holidays.“

“The pizza is great, my favorite is the buffalo chicken bacon ranch or New York White. All of the appetizers are good, but I think the cheesy garlic bread is best. A solid selection of beer that updates occasionally, plus great bartenders like Molly and Spencer who mix excellent drinks. The staff is always friendly and welcoming.“

“We’ve ordered take out a few times- never a bad meal! Order the deep dish- it’s not a true Chicago style deep dish - it’s a thicker crust and very yummy but not as overwhelming as Chicago Deep dish! ❤“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“some good stuff and convenient at most stores I love it“

“Service was fast! Pleasant! Food was delicious!!!!“

“I have not been here for over a year. I tried it last night and came back again tonight. There have been major improvements done to the pizza. The sauce is better, the crust is better, the toppings are on top of the cheese which just looks delicious and they now have stuffed crust!!! 10 out of 10!!!“

“Great service and friendly staff. Even being shorthanded, they were prompt. The food was great as usual!!“

“Massimo's is a little hole in the wall pizza joint that makes the best pizzas I've ever had, hands down. I only visit Goshen once a year for an annual event, but I make it a point to get pizza here every visit. Outstanding quality.“

“I have been coming to this location for a little over a year now. The manager here is great and she makes sure she takes care of the customers. My orders are always correct and my food is fresh. I recommend giving this place a try. Great staff and great food. Will continue to frequent the location!“

“Went in this last Friday to get my pickup order I had called in. Soon as I walked In I seen a guy with tattoos all over his arms wipe BBQ off a ready to bake pizza with no gloves on… then licked his two fingers, the one finger went all the way in his mouth, and licked another part of his hand, the dug his hand into the meat and continued making coustomers pizzas. Disgusting! Absolutely disgusting… not a single person at this place had a pair of gloves on… sad…sad…sad… this was the Goshen location by the way right down town ..310 north Main Street.“